Options
Why is someone who is pregnant part of the stressful live shows?
welshfoxy
Posts: 6,985 Forum Member
✭
Just wondering, like.
0
welshfoxy
Posts: 6,985 welshfoxy
Posts: 6,985 welshfoxy
Posts: 6,985 welshfoxy
Posts: 6,985
Comments
Are you serious? Even Cowell himself wouldn't put someone through in a previous year due to this.
Do they think because SeSe is in a group it'd be easier to get her under the radar? Imagine if she lost the baby due to the stress of performing on XF..it's more of a stupid decision which could come back to bite them than anything else.
Cowell refused to put someone through because they were pregnant
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gxPgOLwVByY
"I mean, the stress that girl would have been under would have been unspeakable" - Simon Cowell, 2007
If she starts to struggle at all she can quit, the group is unlikely to last more than a few weeks into the show anyway, they are a cannon fodder act not meant to make it to the final.
I am disappointed in the other 2 bandmates for not at least attempting to perform as a duo.( In fairness, maybe they tried and weren't allo wed).
I hope the other acts join together and refuse to perform unless they all get an equivalent free pass for a choice they make each.
If she could have somehow managed to keep up and do what is expected of all the contestants, fine, but she just proved she couldn't and can't, and deserves no special treatment or sympathy.
I hope she and the baby will be well, and that she won't regret her choice, but she should be replaced and/or kicked out.Not for being pregnant, but for being unable to do what is required of her to continue for a reason that WAS within her control to choose.It probably won't happen, but it should.
Far more likely to miscarry between 2-3 months than at 5-6 months pregnant.
"You cannot put a competition like this or your ambition over the fact you're about to have a baby..it is crazy!"
Open and shut case.
Any stage of a pregnancy is not ideal to come on to a show like this and yes miscarriages do happen between 2-3 months
I didn't think of that, but you're probably right. Surely it's a rather unique situation though - the situation is inherently stressful, and the show strives on it so it is doubly so. And it's all live in front of the nation. Doesn't get worse than that, really. You're right, they were stuck between a rock and a hard place. Maybe it's proof Cowell doesn't take as much notice of the UK version in terms of detail anymore.
Probably find a new clause in future contracts, failure to
disclose pregnancy results in disqualification from contest, unless that is technically illegal to put into contracts.
Im sorry, hate me all you want but I think its wrong and she should be elimated. it would be different if she was only a few weeks pregnant but shes due in January which means she's far gone already
Girl bands with pregnant members can work and have worked but they were all established acts, Miss Dynamix aren't. Una and Rochelle were able to work till they dropped, Frankie wasn't - what happens if that happens to Sese?
It's too early for Miss Dynamix as a band to cope with a pregnant member.
What about the tour?
What if they were to win?
Sese is a producers nightmare. They couldn't eject her, she withheld the truth and now a collapse in the 2nd week. It's not fair on the other girls as this is their chance.
They need to let Sese rest, leave the band and draft Jade Ewen in pronto.
I don't hate you, and I don't think you should be sorry for your opinion either. I agree.