Options
Rate this weeks performances...
![[Deleted User]](https://w4.vanillicon.com/v2/45e12b8b5ac594d68c9ea5b21f3165fe.svg)
[Deleted User]
Posts: 620 Forum Member
✭✭
Storm Lee - 4/10
TreyC Cohen - 6/10
Paije Richardson - 3/10
One Direction - 6/10
Cher Lloyd - 5/10
John Adeleye - 2/10
Diva Fever - 2/10
Rebecca Ferguson - 7/10
Aiden Grimshaw - 6/10
Wagner - 2/10
Katie Waissel - 5/10
Belle Amie - 7/10
Mary Byrne - 7/10
Matt Cardle - 5/10
Probably the worst night in X-Factor history, I didnt actually enjoy any of the performances and found myself wanting the show to end!
What about you?
TreyC Cohen - 6/10
Paije Richardson - 3/10
One Direction - 6/10
Cher Lloyd - 5/10
John Adeleye - 2/10
Diva Fever - 2/10
Rebecca Ferguson - 7/10
Aiden Grimshaw - 6/10
Wagner - 2/10
Katie Waissel - 5/10
Belle Amie - 7/10
Mary Byrne - 7/10
Matt Cardle - 5/10
Probably the worst night in X-Factor history, I didnt actually enjoy any of the performances and found myself wanting the show to end!
What about you?
0
Comments
TreyC Cohen - 6/10
Paije Richardson - 4/10
One Direction - 7/10
Cher Lloyd - 7/10
John Adeleye - 5/10
Diva Fever - 4/10
Rebecca Ferguson - 7/10
Aiden Grimshaw - 6/10
Wagner - 2/10
Katie Waissel - 9/10
Belle Amie - 8/10
Mary Byrne - 7/10
Matt Cardle - 9/10
TreyC Cohen - 4/10
Paije Richardson - 1/10
One Direction - 6/10
Cher Lloyd - 4/10
John Adeleye - 4/10
Diva Fever - 5/10
Rebecca Ferguson - 9/10
Aiden Grimshaw - 8/10
Wagner - 2/10
Katie Waissel - 8/10
Belle Amie - 7/10
Mary Byrne - 6/10
Matt Cardle - 8/10
Treyc- 9/10
Paije- 2/10
Wand Erection- 5/10
Cher- 5/10
John- 1/10
Diva Fever- 1/10
Rebecca- 6/10
Aiden- 7/10
Wagner- 4/10
Katie- 5/10
Belle Amie- 2/10
Mary- 6/10
Matt- 5/10
Treyc- 4/10 - bad lower register, bad lower register, wait for it, aah theres the shouting.
Paije- 2/10 - hes just not very good
One Direction- 6/10 - Average
Cher- 3/10 - so basically copying Jay-Z from 6 years ago is somehow original. Her singing was awful, her rapping just sh!t
John- 6/10 - He's dull alright, but a decent effort
Diva Fever- 1/10 - I give up
Rebecca- 3/10 - I thought the higher notes sounded really weak.
Aiden- 6/10 - It was okay
Wagner- 1/10 - Just go please
Katie- 5/10 - Basically the same performance as her sing-off last week, It wasn't particularly good, but much better than anything else she does
Belle Amie- 4/10 - Great, basically an ugly Girls Aloud.
Mary- 1/10 - Kareoke, Kareoke. A load of sh!t
Matt- 7/10 - The only 'good' performance of the entire night. I really hated the song but he sang well
Belle Amie - 6/10 too much backing track
Cher Lloyd - 3/10 dreadful song choice, hated the rap part
Diva Fever - 4/10 disappointing song choice again
John Adeleye - 9/10 brilliant, best on the night imo
Katie Waissel - 6/10 much better than last week
Mary Byrne - 9/10 loved the song and her singing
Matt Cardle - 9/10 very special voice, loved the song too
One Direction - 6/10 a bit out of time with each other, better than last week
Paije Richardson - 5/10 disappointed, got the impression he wasn't too keen on the song
Rebecca Ferguson - 7/10 another song that didn't suit her voice
Storm Lee - 4/10 didn't think the song was right for him
TreyC Cohen - 8/10 struggled with the high notes but very good otherwise
Wagner - 2/10 nice fun guy but not a good singer last night
TreyC Cohen - 7/10
Paije Richardson - 2/10
One Direction - 6/10
Cher Lloyd - 0/10
John Adeleye - 8/10
Diva Fever - 1/10
Rebecca Ferguson - 7/10
Aiden Grimshaw - 6/10
Wagner - 4/10
Katie Waissel - 5/10
Belle Amie - 810
Mary Byrne - 7/10
Matt Cardle - 6/10
Treyc -5/10 liked her better last week
Paije- 7/10 loved him
1direction - 8.5/10 liked them alot this week
Cher - 2/10 awful outfit awful song! Awful overall
John - 3/10 boring!
Diva fever - 2/10 boring compared to last week
Rebecca 8/10 another great performance
Aiden 7/10 looked sick and nervous but good vocals
Wagner - 0/10 awful not even funny!!
Katie - 8/10 much better!!
Mary 8/10 lovely lady!!
Matt 9/10 performance of the night!
TreyC Cohen - 7/10
Paije Richardson - 3/10
One Direction - 4/10
Cher Lloyd - 3/10
John Adeleye - 7/10
Diva Fever - 1/10
Rebecca Ferguson - 9/10
Aiden Grimshaw - 2/10
Wagner - 1/10
Katie Waissel - 4/10
Belle Amie - 5/10
Mary Byrne - 6/10
Matt Cardle - 9/10
TreyC Cohen - 7/10
Paije Richardson - 4/10
One Direction - 4/10
Cher Lloyd - 2/10
John Adeleye - 9/10 Best on the night
Diva Fever - 5/10
Rebecca Ferguson - 7/10
Aiden Grimshaw - 4/10
Wagner - 2/10 For effort
Katie Waissel - 3/10
Belle Amie - 5/10
Mary Byrne - 5/10
Matt Cardle - 8/10
Belle Amie - 5/10 a bit meh. I'm not getting this girl group at all.
Cher Lloyd - 4/10 It's an awful song anyway, but she did it no favours. The rapping segment was painful.
Diva Fever - 2/10 The Jedward novelty tag is soooo last year
John Adeleye - 7/10 Good performance but can do (and has done) better
Katie Waissel - 6/10 Major improvement on last week
Mary Byrne - 8/10 One of the highlights of the night
Matt Cardle - 7/10 Not a song I like, but he sang it really well
One Direction - 4/10 Nothing special
Paije Richardson - 4/10 A real disappointment.
Rebecca Ferguson - 6/10 Not her best performance by any means
Storm Lee - 3/10 He is struggling. Needs to stop trying so hard
TreyC Cohen - 9/10 My highlight of the night. Not note perfect, but sang it well
Wagner - 2/10 Awful. Just making up the numbers.
2.Mary - another beautiful performance
3.Aidan - i thought he was good!
4.Matt - really good vocal, but song was a bit boring
5. Paije - another great vocal, but still needs the extra oomph!
6. Treyc - great voice, but still missing x-factor
7. John - as above
8. Katie - good vocal but didnt like the song itself
9. Storm - like his voice, but poor song choice
10.Cher - better then last week for me, but still dont get her!
11.One Direction - better then last week but still fairly dire
12.Belle Ami - didnt like it, dont think they gel at all
13.Wagner - love Wagner, but not the best singer!
14.Diva Fever - woeful, they have to be bottom three
TreyC Cohen - 5 Points
Paije Richardson - 4 Points
One Direction - 3 Points
Cher Lloyd - 0 Points :eek:
John Adeleye - 6 Points
Diva Fever - 1 Point
Rebecca Ferguson - 7 Points
Aiden Grimshaw - 3 Points
Wagner - 2 Points
Katie Waissel - 6 Points
Belle Amie - 4 Points
Mary Byrne - 5 Points ruined a great song
Matt Cardle - 7 Points
Disappointed with all the song choices/performances tonight, dreary show. Matt and Rebecca the best tonight.
2. Cher - Commands the stage, interesting and fresh.
3. Belle Ami - Much better than last week and interesting song choice, seemed to suit them.
4. Katie - Great vocal and clearly her comfort zone.
5. Aiden - Even him straining and making a couple of mistakes was interesting to watch.
6. Rebecca - Completely agree she's got a great recording voice.
7. One Direction - Great song choice - just need to gel more. Zain needs to stop ad-libbing out of tune.
8. TreyC - Obviously a great pair of lungs but missing something.
9. Storm - Can clearly sing but the song choices are not my cup of tea - would like to hear something more modern.
10. Mary - Still a bit one dimensional for me.
11. John - Impressed with the singing but he's forgettable
12. Wagner - Stayed in time, good on him! But you know, that's not something you should be praising someone who's made it this far...
13. Paije - Still missing something...
14. Diva Fever - I really don't believe there's much of a market for them in the real world.
TreyC Cohen - 4/10 (Yes, she is a fairly good singer, but she lacks originality to the point where she is completely irrelevant. I don't get it I'm afraid)
Paije Richardson - 6/10 (Pretty good but not entirely memorable. I think he isn't going to last as long as I initially hoped)
One Direction - 6/10 (For a boyband it was actually pretty good. They are clealy going to be one of the favourites. I still want to knock the curly haired one out)
Cher Lloyd - 6/10 (Second week running I actually somewhat liked it, despite the fact that it was shit of course)
John Adeleye - 8/10 (Keep doing this son and you'll be alright. I hope he gets votes because he can actually sing)
Diva Fever - 3/10 (I like them, but the songs have to be MORE camp. Where was Wham?)
Rebecca Ferguson - 6/10 (Getting there, slowly but surely...)
Aiden Grimshaw - 4/10 (Oh dear. Last week he was immense and I called him as the winner. This week it was just odd.)
Wagner - 2/10 (Love him, but it's completely shit)
Katie Waissel - 4/10 (Better. I fear that however good she is in the coming weeks the span of this show will not be enough to turn around public opinion)
Belle Amie - 2/10 (Awful awful awful. The tall girl on the end is DEEPLY annoying with her overperformance and the whole thing just didn't work. I suspect they will be in bother tonight)
Mary Byrne - 6/10 (Pretty good. I think the weekly tears and applause thing must stop though)
Matt Cardle - 8/10 (Along with John a million miles above everything else. Love his voice and the fact that he can seemingly win everything. If he doesn't finish second I'll eat my hat)
TreyC Cohen - 6/10 Wrong song for a soul voice, pitched too high and it's been done better before
Paije Richardson - 3/10 Just bad. Give him a proper bloke's song please
One Direction - 5/10 Better than last week.
Cher Lloyd - 5/10 Good idea but showed the problems with he singing voice as she couldn't reach all the notes
John Adeleye - 8/10 Best singing performance, not sure Louis has got the image right though
Diva Fever - 6/10 The new Wham - at least they don't take themselves too seriously
Rebecca Ferguson - 5/10 Was it only me that heard her get the tune on the last line of every verse wrong?
Aiden Grimshaw - 4/10 Could do better
Wagner - 3/10 At least he made me laugh
Katie Waissel - 3/10 Try hard. Not got the chops to take on Etta James IMO
Belle Amie - 6/10
Mary Byrne - 5/10 Not keen, to much shouting/belting for that song
Matt Cardle - 8/10 Better than last week
TreyC Cohen - 5/10. Medicore, I expected a lot more from Treyc
Paije Richardson - 6/10. Not bad, but not that good either. A bit meh to be honest.
One Direction - 2/10. It was all over the place.
Cher Lloyd - 0/10. I hated it. I am damned if she deserves a point for that.
John Adeleye - 7/10. Quite good but again forgettable.
Diva Fever - 2/10. One word, Rubbish, how can they be a duo when it seems that only one of them sings
Rebecca Ferguson - 8/10. Really good.
Aiden Grimshaw - 4/10. A let down after last week.
Wagner - 1/10. As I expected, cheesy and naff.
Katie Waissel - 7/10. The suprise of the night for me.
Belle Amie - 5/10. Awkward.
Mary Byrne - 8/10. Again a stand out performance.
Matt Cardle - 9/10. Best of the night by far.
2. Matt
3. Mary
4. Rebecca
These are the only 4 I can really place, the next few were probably all the same for me, just meh
5. One Direction
6. Paije
7. Treyc
8. Katie
9. Belle Amie
10. Storm
11. Diva Fever
12. Wagner
Aiden and Cher bottom two for me, I just don't get them!
13. Aiden
14. Cher...can't stand her!
Storm - 6/10. Liked his performance, he's just himself, vocals weren't amazing though.
Treyc - 5/10. Something I don't really like about her... also she was just shouting...
One Direction - 7/10. Weird song for them but did well.
Paije - 3/10. I swear down his singing is so ****. It sounded like out of tune and everything.
Cher - 10/10. Uniqueness.
Diva Fever - 8/10. So fun and entertaining. Have nice voices too. Also funny sweet guys.
John - 9/10. Actually great. He had a good song, and sang it amazing.
Rebecca - 8/10. Well good vocals and love the tone of her voice.
Aiden - 7/10. Sorta messed up, was still good though.
Wagner - 1/10. Just utter ****. He so needs to go.
Katie - 8/10. Real good song for her and she sang it well.
Belle Amie - 4/10. Better than last week but nothing special.
Mary - 2/10. She was purely shouting.. don't like the sound of her voice either.
Matt - 9/10. Great tonight! Loved the song too.
TreyC Cohen - 5 Points - OK but not great
Paije Richardson - 7 Points - liked it but needs a bit more polish
One Direction - 3 Points - could be any boyband, nothing unique, girlies will keep em in
Cher Lloyd - 5 Points - a bit strange
John Adeleye - 7 Points - liked him, had soul
Diva Fever - 6 Point, good camp fun
Rebecca Ferguson - 8 Points - very good:)
Aiden Grimshaw - 5 Points - patchy, probably in bottom 3, very nervous
Wagner - 5 Points - a novelty, probably bottom 3
Katie Waissel - 7 Points - much better this week
Belle Amie - 4 Points - could be any girl group, nothing unique
Mary Byrne - 7 Points - good version
Matt Cardle - 8 Points - very good
TreyC Cohen - 4/10
Paije Richardson - 6/10
One Direction - 2/10
Cher Lloyd - 2/10
John Adeleye - 8/10
Diva Fever - 1/10
Rebecca Ferguson - 9/10
Aiden Grimshaw - 7/10
Wagner - 1/10
Katie Waissel - 3/10
Belle Amie - 1/10
Mary Byrne - 9/10
Matt Cardle - 9/10
TreyC Cohen - 5/10 belted it out too much. No light & shade
Paije Richardson - 5/10 listening back, he wasn't all that good
One Direction - 5/10 just manufactured pretty boys
Cher Lloyd - 3/10 agreed with Dannii's comments
John Adeleye - 6/10 well sung but a bit boring
Diva Fever - 2/10 less said the better!
Rebecca Ferguson - 7/10 enjoyed this far more than last week
Aiden Grimshaw - 5/10 agreed with his own critique
Wagner - 2/10 think he's a joke. Hope he goes this week.
Katie Waissel - 4/10 better than last week. Still don't like her.
Belle Amie - 4/10 a bit meh! Hated the costumes/makeup.
Mary Byrne - 5/10 Sounds like my aunt after a few drinks!
Matt Cardle - 8/10 best of a bad bunch this week. Not liking Dannii's song choices for him.
TreyC Cohen - 7/10 - Good Vocal but i much preferred Ruth or Danyl's Versions!
Paije Richardson - 3/10 - Dull and to be honest i think he is in trouble !!
One Direction - 4/10 - It was Ok
Cher Lloyd - 6/10 - She's good but wasn't sure i liked it
John Adeleye - 3/10 - Good Vocal i just don't think he is strong enough to win as a whole artist
Diva Fever - 2/10 - Oh dear lord
Rebecca Ferguson - 8/10 - Really good Version of the song
Aiden Grimshaw - 5/10 - Ok
Wagner - 0/10 - Didn't bother to rate it utterly appalling
Katie Waissel - 8/10 - Love IT
Belle Amie - 7/10 - Really liked it and i thought i would of hated it
Mary Byrne - 6/10 - Predictable
Matt Cardle - 4/10 - I thought he really did struggle
TreyC Cohen - 9/10 (Amazing performance again by TreyC!)
Paije Richardson - 2/10 (Disliked)
One Direction - 3/10 (Kelly Clarkson, musical hero?)
Cher Lloyd - 0/10 (Danii was right with her comments.)
John Adeleye - 7/10 (Good Performance)
Diva Fever - 3/10 (Think they were more interested in making noises than actually singing.)
Rebecca Ferguson - 7/10 (Pretty good.)
Aiden Grimshaw - 5/10 (Bit of a let-down from last week.)
Wagner - 1/10 (No..Just..No...)
Katie Waissel - 8/10 (Considering all the controversy of her being put through, I think she put in a decent performance.)
Belle Amie - 6/10 (Meh, they were ok.)
Mary Byrne - 9/10 (Speechless!)
Matt Cardle - 6/10 (Didn't think much of it really.)
TreyC Cohen - 5/10
Paije Richardson - 3/10
One Direction - 6/10
Cher Lloyd - 1/10
John Adeleye - 2/10
Diva Fever - 2/10
Rebecca Ferguson - 5/10
Aiden Grimshaw - 1/10
Wagner - 10/10
Katie Waissel - 4/10
Belle Amie - 6/10
Mary Byrne - 9/10
Matt Cardle - 7/10