Options

€100k to be spent on Longwave survey

Maggie_KingMaggie_King Posts: 381
Forum Member
I see that the Irish Department of Foreign Affairs is to spend €100k on doing a survey of Longwave 252 listeners in the uk. Is it just me or is this a crazy amount of money for country that was recently Insolvent to be spending on this ? http://www.irishpost.co.uk/news/rte-longwave-campaigners-to-make-voices-heard-again-in-broadcasters-survey
«134567

Comments

  • Options
    Phil DoddPhil Dodd Posts: 3,975
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    I see that the Irish Department of Foreign Affairs is to spend €100k on doing a survey of Longwave 252 listeners in the uk. Is it just me or is this a crazy amount of money for country that was recently Insolvent to be spending on this ? http://www.irishpost.co.uk/news/rte-longwave-campaigners-to-make-voices-heard-again-in-broadcasters-survey

    So that's £76,000. The article says that "thousands" of people in Britain petitioned to get the service kept operational until 2017. That suggests a survey would spend £10 per interviewee.

    Then decide how the survey is to be carried out. Advertising in relevant newspapers ? A team of researchers targeting pubs, clubs, and cafes in places like Kilburn and clubs around the UK ? Emails to relevant people asking them to complete web forms ?

    The money sounds a lot, but could well be soon eaten up. And at the end of it, someone has to produce a report with recommendations...

    Anyway, let's hope that our Irish friends manage to keep the radio that they need and want, unlike so much national radio in Britain that is radio that faceless commercial concerns decide to force upon us...
  • Options
    TUCTUC Posts: 5,105
    Forum Member
    So, in an era when we can listen to radio stations across the world online, there's a need for a survey to check whether long wave is needed anymore ...?
  • Options
    swb1964swb1964 Posts: 4,700
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    75, 000 is chicken feed in the great scheme of things even in a smaller economy like Ireland.

    RTE needs to come up with a long term plan orthe two years will be up and we will be no further forward.
  • Options
    swb1964swb1964 Posts: 4,700
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    TUC wrote: »
    So, in an era when we can listen to radio stations across the world online, there's a need for a survey to check whether long wave is needed anymore ...?

    Yes because many older rte listeners aren't online. And because in car internet radio is in its infancy.
  • Options
    AmaraAmara Posts: 5,384
    Forum Member
    I really fail to see the point of LW when anyone who wants to listen to Irish radio stations in the UK can do so online with much better sound quality.
  • Options
    swb1964swb1964 Posts: 4,700
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Amara wrote: »
    I really fail to see the point of LW when anyone who wants to listen to Irish radio stations in the UK can do so online with much better sound quality.

    See my post above yours
  • Options
    BrightonelectriBrightonelectri Posts: 181
    Forum Member
    swb1964 wrote: »
    See my post above yours
    RTE Radio can be heard in the UK via Astra, Virgin Media Cable or on-line. In car it
    is normally available only on 252 and while reception is good in Wales and most of
    Northern England, it is almost impossible in the south east of England.
    The Irish Government could make more money out of its long wave allocation by finding
    a non-government commercial station to take it over or to rent it out to the WRN, World
    Radio Network.
  • Options
    AmaraAmara Posts: 5,384
    Forum Member
    The signal strength is a fraction of what it was in Atlantic 252 days.
  • Options
    Gerry1Gerry1 Posts: 4,228
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Move it to 261. There's nothing on that channel, so obtaining clearance ought to be straightforward.

    Stop thinking of it as a duplicated domestic service; stop thinking it's only for elderly offline expatriates. Start thinking of an external service promoting Ireland, tourism and culture; start thinking outside the box.

    Turn the wick up, give it a punchy name such as 'Emerald 261'. Have some some unique programming aimed at the UK together with some promotions and competitions.
  • Options
    russellellyrussellelly Posts: 11,689
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    Gerry1 wrote: »
    Move it to 261. There's nothing on that channel, so obtaining clearance ought to be straightforward.

    Stop thinking of it as a duplicated domestic service; stop thinking it's only for elderly offline expatriates. Start thinking of an external service promoting Ireland, tourism and culture; start thinking outside the box.

    Turn the wick up, give it a punchy name such as 'Emerald 261'. Have some some unique programming aimed at the UK together with some promotions and competitions.

    Oh come on. An external service promoting Ireland on a wavelength few modern radios even support? Promoting Ireland via TV or a website would be far more effective. It's 2015.

    The thing I don't get with this one, is that 252LW isn't a legacy service for RTE. It was Atlantic 252, offering nothing Irish-specific until the early 2000s. It's not like 198LW for Radio 4 that's been around forever.
  • Options
    wavy-davywavy-davy Posts: 7,122
    Forum Member
    Moving it to 261 would certainly help as the Algeria signal wipes it out at night over most of the UK.

    Or 279 for that matter..
  • Options
    hanssolohanssolo Posts: 22,750
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    RTE Radio can be heard in the UK via Astra, Virgin Media Cable or on-line. In car it
    is normally available only on 252 and while reception is good in Wales and most of
    Northern England, it is almost impossible in the south east of England.
    The Irish Government could make more money out of its long wave allocation by finding
    a non-government commercial station to take it over or to rent it out to the WRN, World
    Radio Network.
    RTE say they are still committed to start. winding down the hours in 2016 with a complete closure of 252 in 2017. So presumably the survey will look at who is still using 252 and why they can't use Freesat (maybe with an FM mini TX), cable or the internet, and what can be done to help them transition to Freesat or internet.

    The BBC world service is now basically a internet or sattelite service to most of Europe. So is possible although it has still some FM and DAB+ relays in some cities.

    The 252 service took over from 567 mw which was the RTE legacy service to provide a better daytime service, 253 should have shut when the UK sport station closed, some in RTE thought 252 worth keeping to replace 567, but few sets now have LW and domestic interefernce affects LW, so the survey may confirm this?

    RTE could have linked with ONFM in London which was a missed opertunity. Also WRN did relay some of it's partner stations programmes on London Spectrum 558 and DAB, but for some reason no longer, so doubt if it could afford to take over 252?
  • Options
    Maggie_KingMaggie_King Posts: 381
    Forum Member
    Amara wrote: »
    The signal strength is a fraction of what it was in Atlantic 252 days.

    A few months ago they reduced the power down to 150kw from 300Kw. Atlantic 252 was running at 500kw.
  • Options
    swb1964swb1964 Posts: 4,700
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    A few months ago they reduced the power down to 150kw from 300Kw. Atlantic 252 was running at 500kw.

    Yes that was very noticable today around dusk when driving on the A38 in the English Midlands. RTE 252 was only just audible above Algeria 252. OK with a portable it might have been possible to null Algeria a bit, but even so, reception was much worse than Atlantic..
  • Options
    Bandspread199Bandspread199 Posts: 4,917
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    few sets now have LW

    I have yet to find one which doesn't. It may not have a LW band, but tunes from the high end of AM.
  • Options
    Colin_LondonColin_London Posts: 12,729
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    I have yet to find one which doesn't. It may not have a LW band, but tunes from the high end of AM.

    Well you can't be looking very hard.

    Last three cars did not have LW. No amount of tuning about on the AM band was going to make LW miraculously appear.

    Maybe you only buy French cars?
  • Options
    Maggie_KingMaggie_King Posts: 381
    Forum Member
    Has this survey commenced yet ?
  • Options
    hanssolohanssolo Posts: 22,750
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Has this survey commenced yet ?
    Probably overshadowed by the 48k DAB+ application for D2 for 70% UK coverage to replace 252? May mean some buying new sets for about £30 http://www.currys.co.uk/gbuk/audio/radios/radios/sony-xdrs40dbpb-portable-dab-radio-black-21342685-pdt.html, other listeners reverting to Freesat or internet outside the D2 area.
    http://listen2digital.co.uk/stations/
    If listen2digital does not win the bid UTV/Bauer have uncommitted space on their bid.
  • Options
    Isambard BrunelIsambard Brunel Posts: 6,598
    Forum Member
    I'll do it for €90,000.
  • Options
    Maggie_KingMaggie_King Posts: 381
    Forum Member
    hanssolo wrote: »
    Probably overshadowed by the 48k DAB+ application for D2 for 70% UK coverage to replace 252? May mean some buying new sets for about £30 http://www.currys.co.uk/gbuk/audio/radios/radios/sony-xdrs40dbpb-portable-dab-radio-black-21342685-pdt.html, other listeners reverting to Freesat or internet outside the D2 area.
    http://listen2digital.co.uk/stations/
    If listen2digital does not win the bid UTV/Bauer have uncommitted space on their bid.

    How much would the carriage on dab+ cost RTE ? funny thing is, rte ran a very badly worded closedown message on 252lw last september which made some people think that the service was available on dab in the uk and The irish post newpaper got letters saying " I don't want to use a digital radio to listen to Donnacha on saturday nights because Im 75".
  • Options
    hanssolohanssolo Posts: 22,750
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    How much would the carriage on dab+ cost RTE ?
    The costs are not in the bid, but DAB+ on D2 will be much cheaper than D1 which was about £1m PA, and probably a lot cheaper than all the costs of running 252?.
  • Options
    swb1964swb1964 Posts: 4,700
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    With the power reductions 252 has already become unlistenable on the car radio, in Derby, in daylight. It simply mush-es with Algeria 252.

    They should have kept it at full power until someone decided what to do......
  • Options
    MikeBrMikeBr Posts: 7,907
    Forum Member
    swb1964 wrote: »
    With the power reductions 252 has already become unlistenable on the car radio, in Derby, in daylight. It simply mush-es with Algeria 252.

    They should have kept it at full power until someone decided what to do......

    RTE said words to the effect that the survey would not affect their plans, they have always left the door open to the Government financing the longwave service themselves using the same diaspora funding that they have which is being used for this survey.
  • Options
    Hybrid telliesHybrid tellies Posts: 1,580
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Reception is much worse now that Algeria has come back on air and since RTE have gone to reduced power.
  • Options
    hanssolohanssolo Posts: 22,750
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    MikeBr wrote: »
    RTE said words to the effect that the survey would not affect their plans, they have always left the door open to the Government financing the longwave service themselves using the same diaspora funding that they have which is being used for this survey.
    If RTE get a slot on D2 then wonder if they will still need funding from the Government as the D2 cost will probably far less than keeping 252? But perhaps more cost for the UK based Irish listeners who will have to spend about £30 on new DAB+ or more for internet or Freesat sets?
Sign In or Register to comment.