The Saturdays - rate vocally from best to worst

soapgirlhere · 31/07/10 - 15:37

After watching many of their acoustic songs on youtube, I would say -

Vanessa
Una
Rochelle
Mollie
Frankie

BTW, if anyone else is interested, I'll give some links ('cause I'm nice like that

):
Forever Is Over
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uPmZwYvvBHM&feature=related

Issues
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-EO4vHJ3VfI&NR=1

Deeper
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8XJhaD2WGM4&feature=related

Chasing Lights
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nPE8x39ji4U&feature=related

Justin Bieber's Baby (minus Mollie)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EC05Y9PuaH0

GlassBalloon · 31/07/10 - 15:47

Vanessa
Rochelle
Una
Mollie
Frankie

[Deleted User] · 31/07/10 - 15:53

Vanessa
Rochelle
Mollie
Una
Frankie

[Deleted User] · 31/07/10 - 16:22

Vanessa, obviously.

Rochelle and Una are always fantastic live. I love the way Una changes the style of her lyrics and her ad libs are always great.

Mollie's voice is weak but when she's got confidence she's always pretty good.

Frankie is poor.

Sometimes she's pretty good with certain songs but when harmonising she's always the loud one who sounds out of tune.

cnbcwatcher · 31/07/10 - 18:12

Vanessa
Una
Rochelle
Mollie
Frankie

[Deleted User] · 31/07/10 - 18:18

Vanessa
Una
Mollie
Rochelle
Frankie

SpiderMan 83 · 31/07/10 - 18:23

Vanessa
Rochelle
Una
Mollie
Frankie

[Deleted User] · 31/07/10 - 23:25

Vanessa
Rochelle
Una
Frankie
Mollie

[Deleted User] · 31/07/10 - 23:56

Vanessa
Una
Rochelle
Frankie
Mollie

Ethereal · 01/08/10 - 00:09

Vanessa - amazing voice! Her tone is very unique and she is a great belter.
Una - lovely husky tone and stands out.
Rochelle - good voice but nothing special or distinct.
Frankie - not a particularly strong singer but is decent and can sound good at times.
Mollie - ok at harmonising but awful when she sings on her own IMO. Very nasal and just not good.

trawets09 · 01/08/10 - 13:09

Anyone who puts Mollie above Rochelle or Una is obviously either deluded or deaf

[Deleted User] · 01/08/10 - 13:24

Ethereal wrote: »

Vanessa - amazing voice! Her tone is very unique and she is a great belter.
Una - lovely husky tone and stands out.
Rochelle - good voice but nothing special or distinct.
Frankie - not a particularly strong singer but is decent and can sound good at times.
Mollie - ok at harmonising but awful when she sings on her own IMO. Very nasal and just not good.

Agreed.

[Deleted User] · 01/08/10 - 14:32

Vanessa - always consistently good.
Rochelle - versatile, has a good range.
Una - nice tone.
Frankie - not great, she sounds awful live on If This Is Love but on other tracks fine
Mollie - sorry she is the weakest and she seems like a lovely girl but sometimes I wonder what she's doing there, but she has the odd good vocal and good harmonies.

[Deleted User] · 01/08/10 - 14:37

Vanessa
Una
Rochelle
Frankie
Mollie

soapgirlhere · 01/08/10 - 22:23

Found another vid, this most certainly shows them all at their best -
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wGeJ7D_iI6g

Star_Bright · 01/08/10 - 22:29

I want to see videos so I can see them at their worst. Anyone got any links?

PeteJB · 01/08/10 - 22:29

Vanessa

Una
Rochelle

Mollie

Frankie

[Deleted User] · 01/08/10 - 22:35

Vanessa >> Rochelle >>>>> Una >>>>>>>>>>Mollie >>>>>>>>>>>> Frankie

cashloot147 · 01/08/10 - 23:34

Anyone who doesn't think Mollie is a good singer needs to watch this video.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U4U1fxfV5t0

She might not be the best, but she has a good voice.

MikePJB · 02/08/10 - 01:52

Vanessa
Rochelle
Una
Frankie
Mollie

soapgirlhere · 02/08/10 - 09:22

cashloot147 wrote: »

Anyone who doesn't think Mollie is a good singer needs to watch this video.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U4U1fxfV5t0

She might not be the best, but she has a good voice.

Agreed, I certainly think she's better than Frankie.
Her voice sounds really good there, and it's good that she's clearly musical and can do more than just sing, but why the lisp !?