Options

Your All Time Ranking of the Housemates 2014 [Results Thread]

1192022242538

Comments

  • Options
    yohinnchildyohinnchild Posts: 52,532
    Forum Member
    So the Housemates who've made it to the top 75 are..

    Remaining Housemates

    BB1

    Craig Phillips (BB1)
    Anna Nolan (BB1)
    Melanie Hill (BB1)
    Nick Bateman (BB1)

    BB2

    Brian Dowling (BB2)
    Helen Adams (BB2)
    Dean O'Laughlin (BB2)

    BB3
    Kate Lawler (BB3)
    Alex Sibley (BB3)
    Sophie Pritchard (BB3)
    Spencer Smith (BB3)
    Allison Hammond (BB3)

    BB4
    Ray Shah (BB4)
    Jon Tickle (BB4)
    Anouska Golebiewski (BB4)

    BB5
    Nadia Almada (BB5)
    Daniel Bryan (BB5)
    Shell Jubin (BB5)
    Stuart Wilson (BB5)
    Michelle Bass (BB5)
    Victor Ebuwa (BB5)

    BB6
    Eugene Sully (BB6)
    Makosi Musambasi (BB6)
    Kinga Karolczak (BB6)
    Kemal Shahin (BB6)
    Science (BB6)
    Roberto Conte (BB6)

    BB7
    Pete Bennett (BB7)
    Glyn Wise (BB7)
    Aisleyne Horgan-Wallace (BB7)
    Nikki Grahame (BB7)
    Imogen Thomas (BB7)

    BB8
    Sam Marchant (BB8)
    Amanda Marchant (BB8)
    Liam McGough (BB8)
    Gerry Stergiopoulos (BB8)
    Nicky Maxwell (BB8)
    Lesley Brain (BB8)

    BB9
    Rachel Rice (BB9)
    Sara Folino (BB9)
    Rex Newmark (BB9)
    Lisa Appleton (BB9)
    Stephanie McMichael (BB9)

    BB10

    Sophie Reade (BB10)
    Siavash Sabbashpour (BB10)
    Rodrigo Lopes (BB10)
    Marcus Akin (BB10)
    Freddie Fisher (BB10)
    Hira Habibshah (BB10)
    Noirin Kelly (BB10)
    Angel McKenzie (BB10)

    BB11
    Sam Pepper (BB11)
    Corin Forshaw (BB11)
    Benjamin Duncan (BB11)
    Shabbby Kathadourian (BB11)
    Sunshine Martyn (BB11)

    BB12
    Aaron Allard-Morgan (BB12)
    Faye Palmer (BB12)
    Harry Blake (BB12)
    Maisy James (BB12)

    BB13
    Luke Anderson (BB13)
    Adam Kelly (BB13)
    Deana Uppal (BB13)
    Lauren Carre (BB13)
    Lydia Louisa (BB13)
    Benedict Garrett (BB13)

    BB14
    Dexter Koh (BB14)
    Gina Rio (BB14)
    Charlie Travers (BB14)
    Hazel O'Sullivan (BB14)
    Dan Neal (BB14)

    BB15
    Ashleigh Coyle (BB15)
    Christopher Hall (BB15)
    Chris Wright (BB15)
    Matthew Davies (BB15)
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 68,508
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    99 (93) = Tom O’Connell (BB12) = 7799pts
    BB12's Tom also continues to climb back up the rankings and retains his top 100 position. He is also in front of best friend Alex for the first time.
    I think Tom was miles better as a housemate than Alex. She was a waste of a housemate place as far as I'm concerned.
    Barracute wrote: »
    Surprised to see Tania in the top 100, nothing particularly memorable about her
    a) The inch thick layer of blusher she put on her face all the time;
    b) The boutique she worked in, which she claimed attracted one customer a day;
    c) Her transparently genuine joy and happiness when she was evicted.
    One of the most entertaining though. Certainly better than C4's favourite Charley.

    HELL yes, Chanelle, for all that she was a bit of a spoilt tantrum queen was actually quite amusing. Charley was just a dreary nuisance.
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 68,508
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    kimotag wrote: »
    First of my top 20 gone!:(

    Mark was my number 3. :cry: Obviously only appeals to elite tastes. For some reason which I can't imagine, some people did not appreciate his masturbation competition with Jay.
  • Options
    kimotagkimotag Posts: 11,064
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    77 (69) = Darnell Swallow (BB9) = 8723pts
    Ranking History (X-X-18-41-50-64-48-69-77)
    Ranking Performance (-0.95%)


    01-10.......... 1
    11-20.......... 5
    21-30......... 3
    31-40......... 4
    41-50......... 3
    51-60......... 1
    61-70......... 5
    71-80......... 3
    81-90......... 5
    91-100....... 4
    111-120....... 1
    131-140...... 3
    181-190...... 2
    191-200...... 1
    201-210...... 2
    211-220...... 2
    221-230...... 1
    241-250...... 3
    251-253...... 1

    Lowest Ranking = 252
    Highest Ranking = 9

    After a big drop last year, this year Darnell registers just a small fall down the rankings.

    2nd of my top 20 to go
  • Options
    kimotagkimotag Posts: 11,064
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    Mark was my number 3. :cry: Obviously only appeals to elite tastes. For some reason which I can't imagine, some people did not appreciate his masturbation competition with Jay.

    :D Can't think why either!
  • Options
    CelticMythCelticMyth Posts: 3,090
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    We reach the top 75! 33 of my top 75 remain.
  • Options
    meglosmurmursmeglosmurmurs Posts: 35,109
    Forum Member
    I gave Paul his lowest ranking. Yey me.
    I blame him for me not liking BB2 very much. He managed to combine being incredibly boring and arrogant in equal measure, and surviving eviction after eviction over more interesting people certainly didn't help. The public didn't even like him that much, it was just his romance with Helen keeping him in.

    Meanwhile, someone who did delusion the correct way...
    Danielle was one of the few things keeping my interest in BB15. It doesn't help that she fell victim to what was probably the worst twist during the worst week of the series.
    Since she was never evicted by public vote the way BB is supposed to be, I like to imagine I'm in Danielle's crazy world and she's actually the winner of the series.
  • Options
    SourGrapesSourGrapes Posts: 4,310
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Maysoon so doesnt deserve to be top 100, especially as we had so many more deserving HMs exit before her. I checked my own ranking and I had her at 107 and i was like huh, how did I rank her so highly but I guess many people did the same, had her somewhere in the middle as she wouldn't be anyones absolute favourite but too bland to be hateable.

    I gave Maysoon her highest ranking! Not a classic housemate I guess but a really likeable one from one of my favourite series
    79 (NEW) = Danielle McMahon (BB15) = 8634pts.

    Not a bad ranking for Danielle, certainly one of the best housemates this year and my favourite in the opening weeks - shame she fell victim to the awful Armageddon twists.


    I've just got Coirin and Gina left from my bottom 20 now. 9 or my top 10 still in tact - pleased to see Hazel and Shabby still hanging in there
  • Options
    AlexosAlexos Posts: 17,697
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    dan_ wrote: »
    I gave Richard his Lowest Ranking

    Twins :3

    Just checked and only one of my top 20 out (RIP Toya). Unfortunately two of my bottom 20 still linger. Get Gerry and Liam out!
  • Options
    marsha_Cutiepiemarsha_Cutiepie Posts: 9,721
    Forum Member
    SourGrapes wrote: »
    I gave Maysoon her highest ranking! Not a classic housemate I guess but a really likeable one from one of my favourite series

    Dont get me wrong she definitely was a nice girl (and stunning too) but I felt just didn't add a lot as a HM, differrent strokes though! :D
  • Options
    meglosmurmursmeglosmurmurs Posts: 35,109
    Forum Member
    91 (80) = Grace Adams-Short (BB7) = 8131pts
    Ranking History (92-100-95-92-86-88-62-80-91)
    Ranking Performance (-1.78%)

    I never like it when people have unnecessary levels of hatred for someone who doesn't seem to be doing anything to deserve it. Grace was calling Lea, Richard, Aisleyne, Sam.....all sorts of names while they were thinking they were okay with her.

    The way Grace treated Susie finally brought out her childish behaviour for the house to see and I think they were pretty shocked by it. Richard had seen a couple of glimpses of it when Aisleyne entered and was disappointed by it, but I think he was going to dismiss it as a one-off occurrence until Susie came in.

    Grace's demise coming at the hands of a newbie was very fitting given the way she had treated all of the newbies that had entered.
    I put her and Adele in the same category, where I feel like they were far too intelligent to fall into the bitchy and resentful trap they fell into and suffered the consequences for.
    100 (94) = Darren Ramsay (BB1) = 7741pts
    Ranking History (30-46-63-58-70-71-90-94-100)
    Ranking Performance (+0.64%)


    01-10.......... 1

    Lowest Ranking = 201
    Highest Ranking = 9

    I gave Darren his highest ranking.
    I especially enjoyed watching him turn around his fear of chickens and developing it into a connection with feathery delight Marjorie. *sniff sniff*

    Plus I liked his well-meaning but sometimes cringeworthy clumsiness - from his unbearable nomination reasons (wanting someone to leave so they will be able to see their family *bleurgh*) to the house over-hearing his nominations and trying in vain some serious damage-control to mend his relationship with Mel.
  • Options
    VeriVeri Posts: 96,996
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Barracute wrote: »
    Surprised to see Tania in the top 100, nothing particularly memorable about her

    I think Tania is one of the most memorable HMs there's been.
    94 (79) = Tania do Nascimento (BB4) = 8082pts
    Ranking History (45-60-48-60-61-70-87-79-94)
    Ranking Performance (-3.39%)


    01-10......... 1 <--- me :)
    11-20......... 1
    21-30........ 2
    31-40......... 1
    41-50........ 3
    51-60........ 2
    61-70......... 1
    71-80......... 2
    81-90......... 3
    91-100....... 4
    101-110...... 6
    111-120...... 5
    121-130...... 2
    131-140...... 2
    141-150...... 4
    151-160...... 1
    161-170...... 4
    171-180...... 4
    191-200..... 2

    Lowest Ranking = 200
    Highest Ranking = 10 <--- me again :)

    Tania continues to yo-yo in the rankings, this year taking a fall down (after a climb last year and a fall the year before)

    How many people voted this year, and in those years?
  • Options
    VerenceVerence Posts: 104,589
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭✭
    I would agree - Ahmed was a classic HM, he just worked well in the madhouse that was BB5 and had some great moments. I had him @ 44, retrospectively would have put him even a little higher.

    Excited for top 100! :D

    One of the funniest things about Ahmed was how he went to bed early on Fight Night and managed to sleep through the whole kerfuffle
    Barracute wrote: »
    I didn't like the way Jale turned against Chris - for no real reason

    I think if asked she would say the reason was him refusing to admit that he was the secret PHM even after the shouting over the wall. She claimed to someone at the time (might have been Helen) that he (Chris) had blackmailed her over the matter.
  • Options
    Pete CallanPete Callan Posts: 24,399
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Still got 41 of my top 75 but two of my bottom five still in. As always, you awful people have ranked Freddie and Siavash way, way too high!
  • Options
    VeriVeri Posts: 96,996
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    I never like it when people have unnecessary levels of hatred for someone who doesn't seem to be doing anything to deserve it. Grace was calling Lea, Richard, Aisleyne, Sam.....all sorts of names while they were thinking they were okay with her.

    The way Grace treated Susie finally brought out her childish behaviour for the house to see and I think they were pretty shocked by it. Richard had seen a couple of glimpses of it when Aisleyne entered and was disappointed by it, but I think he was going to dismiss it as a one-off occurrence until Susie came in.

    Grace's demise coming at the hands of a newbie was very fitting given the way she had treated all of the newbies that had entered.

    That makes little sense, especially the "newbie" part, since the loathsome Susie's "newbie" status was irrelevant, and the part about Richard (who was btw ok with Grace weeks after the Susie stuff). (Note btw how no one seemed shocked by the water-throwing except Aisleyne. Richard and Jennie liked re-enacting it, later on; R even asked Aisleyne if she'd like to try, and described it as liberating.)
  • Options
    VeriVeri Posts: 96,996
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Barracute wrote: »
    Ahmed should be top 100
    I would agree - Ahmed was a classic HM, he just worked well in the madhouse that was BB5 and had some great moments. I had him @ 44, retrospectively would have put him even a little higher.

    Excited for top 100! :D

    Ahmed was a poor HM, imo (like all HMs over 40), and finished as high as he did only because he was in one of the better series -- though in the recap above bb10 had more HMs left. :p
  • Options
    VeriVeri Posts: 96,996
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    85 (83) = Caoimhe Guilfoyle (BB11) = 8374pts
    Ranking History (X-X-X-X-62-69-70-83-86)
    Ranking Performance (+1.87%)


    11-20......... 4
    21-30......... 2
    31-40......... 7
    41-50......... 3
    51-60......... 4
    61-70......... 4
    71-80......... 2
    91-100....... 2
    111-120...... 2
    121-130...... 1
    131-140...... 2
    141-150...... 2
    151-160...... 2
    161-170...... 2
    181-190...... 2
    191-200...... 1
    211-220...... 2
    221-230...... 1
    231-240...... 3
    241-250...... 2

    Lowest Ranking = 246
    Highest Ranking = 12 <--- me :)

    Caoimhe takes a small climb up the rankings; a shame when she walked in BB11 especially as it started a revolving door couple of weeks with HMs coming and going.

    Another I gave their highest ranking.
  • Options
    meglosmurmursmeglosmurmurs Posts: 35,109
    Forum Member
    Veri wrote: »
    That makes little sense, especially the "newbie" part, since the loathsome Susie's "newbie" status was irrelevant, and the part about Richard (who was btw ok with Grace weeks after the Susie stuff).

    Makes perfect sense to me, being my opinion and all.

    Susie was a new person entering the house, so she was a newbie, just like Aisleyne and Sam. Who were all treated with contempt by Grace, not sure if it was a coincidence or not but 3 out of 3 is a pretty good record.

    I don't think Susie deserves being called loathsome at all. She could be a little bit superior and bossy, but she was as painfully polite as a housemate could be.
  • Options
    VeriVeri Posts: 96,996
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    251 (232) = Alexandra De-Gale (BB9) = 1412pts
    Ranking History (X-X-143-165-186-201-217-232-251)
    Ranking Performance (-0.06%)


    61-70........... 1
    141-150........ 1
    161-170........ 1
    211-220....... 2
    221-230...... 2
    231-240...... 9
    241-250...... 23
    251-253.......11

    Bottom Rankings = 3
    Highest Ranking = 65

    So for a third year, the bottom 3 remains unchanged as Alexandra takes bronze at the bottom of the rankings, despite some low entries this year from some HMs, the bottom 3 was seemingly unshakeable.

    :confused:

    I had her at 26. So how is her highest rating 65?

    :confused:
  • Options
    VeriVeri Posts: 96,996
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Makes perfect sense to me, being my opinion and all.

    Do you think opinions necessarily make sense, just because they're opinions? :confused:
    Susie was a new person entering the house, so she was a newbie, just like Aisleyne and Sam. Who were all treated with contempt by Grace, not sure if it was a coincidence or not but 3 out of 3 is a pretty good record.

    I didn't say the loathsome Susie wasn't a "newbie"; but the twist that allowed Susie to pick who faced the vote had no real connection with her being new as such.
    I don't think Susie deserves being called loathsome at all. She could be a little bit superior and bossy, but she was as painfully polite as a housemate could be.

    Calling her "loathsome" is an opinion, if you like.
  • Options
    VeriVeri Posts: 96,996
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    220 (205) = Sandy Cumming (BB3) = 4042pts
    Ranking History (91-108-134-136-155-182-177-205-220)
    Ranking Performance (+0.22%)


    31-40.......... 2
    51-60.......... 1
    101-110........ 1
    121-130...... 2
    131-140...... 2
    141-150...... 5
    151-160...... 3
    161-170...... 4
    181-190...... 4
    191-200...... 4
    201-210...... 4
    211-220...... 5
    221-230...... 5
    231-240...... 2
    241-250...... 5
    251-253...... 1

    Lowest Ranking = 251
    Highest Ranking = 32 <--- me :)

    Sandy took a big drop down the rankings last year, this year he basically stands still in the rankings. Possibly best remembered for weeing into the kitchen bin before escaping from the house.

    Seems I gave Sandy his highest ranking, assuming my votes are being counted -- as they didn't seem to be for Alexandra.
  • Options
    meglosmurmursmeglosmurmurs Posts: 35,109
    Forum Member
    BB5 - 9 out of 13 = 69.23%
    BB1 - 7 out of 11 = 63.64%
    BB2 - 7 out of 11 = 63.64%
    BB4 - 8 out of 13 = 61.54%
    BB8 - 13 out of 23 = 56.52%
    BB6 - 9 out of 16 = 56.25%
    BB11 - 11 out of 21 = 52.38%
    BB3 - 7 out of 14 = 50.00%
    BB7 - 11 out of 22 = 50.00%
    BB9 - 10 out of 21 = 47.62%
    BB13 - 8 out of 17 = 47.06%
    BB12 - 7 out of 15 = 46.67%
    BB15 - 8 out of 19 = 42.11%
    BB10 - 9 out of 22 = 40.91%
    BB14 - 6 out of 15 = 40.00%

    Another update of the % of housemates remaining from each series.
    Interesting comparing it to above (done just before the halfway point I think).
    Now only the more popular housemates remain....

    BB5 - 6 out of 13 = 46.15%
    BB6 - 6 out of 16 = 37.50%
    BB1 - 4 out of 11 = 36.36%
    BB10 - 8 out of 22 = 36.36%
    BB3 - 5 out of 14 = 35.71%
    BB13 - 6 out of 17 = 35.29%
    BB14 - 5 out of 15 = 33.33%
    BB2 - 3 out of 11 = 27.27%
    BB12 - 4 out of 15 = 26.67%
    BB8 - 6 out of 23 = 26.09%
    BB9 - 5 out of 21 = 23.81%
    BB11 - 5 out of 21 = 23.81%
    BB4 - 3 out of 13 = 23.08%
    BB7 - 5 out of 22 = 22.73%
    BB15 - 4 out of 19 = 21.05%
  • Options
    sangrealsangreal Posts: 20,901
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Verence wrote: »
    I think if asked she would say the reason was him refusing to admit that he was the secret PHM even after the shouting over the wall. She claimed to someone at the time (might have been Helen) that he (Chris) had blackmailed her over the matter.


    Yes. What part of "secret" did she not understand? When she was on Couch Potatoes a few weeks back, we told her that BB had told Chris he was the secret power housemate and that there'd be serious consequences if he told anyone. She went quiet...for about 5 seconds...before changing the subject. Boy, can she talk! Dr Detroit hardly got a word in edgeways, lol.
  • Options
    VeriVeri Posts: 96,996
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Another update of the % of housemates remaining from each series.
    Interesting comparing it to above (done just before the halfway point I think).
    Now only the more popular housemates remain....

    BB5 - 6 out of 13 = 46.15%
    BB6 - 6 out of 16 = 37.50%
    BB1 - 4 out of 11 = 36.36%
    BB10 - 8 out of 22 = 36.36%
    BB3 - 5 out of 14 = 35.71%
    BB13 - 6 out of 17 = 35.29%
    BB14 - 5 out of 15 = 33.33%
    BB2 - 3 out of 11 = 27.27%
    BB12 - 4 out of 15 = 26.67%
    BB8 - 6 out of 23 = 26.09%
    BB9 - 5 out of 21 = 23.81%
    BB11 - 5 out of 21 = 23.81%
    BB4 - 3 out of 13 = 23.08%
    BB7 - 5 out of 22 = 22.73%
    BB15 - 4 out of 19 = 21.05%

    Thanks! :)

    What strikes me most about those stats is how many are left from bb10. It generally seems to be considered one of the poorer BBs, yet it has more of the "more popular houemates" than any other series.

    I don't think that can just be put down to BB10 having so may HMs in total.
  • Options
    VeriVeri Posts: 96,996
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Re Govan --
    Alicey wrote: »
    Not a fan of Govan, but have never really understood his huge unpopularity!
    ...
    And someone I feel even sorrier for. Whatever did Govan do wrong? He was a bit of a gossip, a bit young for his age maybe, and not someone to confide your darkest secrets in, but he seemed a sweet young man to me.
    ABCZYX wrote: »
    ...
    To me, he seemed to enjoy bitching behind people's backs. The bitching reminded me of BB9's Luke. Luke himself, even commented on his Twitter page that people had said that there was a similarity with them both.
    ...
    I don't really agree, which is why I used the expression 'liked a gossip' rather than 'bitched'. The bitchy group in that house was overwhelmingly the Ben/ Dave/ Mario group, who seemed made of pure teflon, the way they could sit and bitch for hours without criticism. The Govan/ Josie/ smokers group was gossipy and giggly rather than actually bitchy. At that stage, they hadn't really got anyone to bitch about until they fell out with Sunshine. And Govan was absolutely a follower, not a leader.

    I have a disquieting feeling that the forum and voters are often pretty savage about men who don't strike them as particularly masculine; Tom in BB12 got some of the same visceral contempt on here. (I once counted the number of posts that called him a weasel, and it ran into the hundreds. Why? Because, it would seem, he was a bit small and a bit camp.) Govan never looked like a winner, but I hated his massively hostile eviction. He seemed a harmless, slightly silly young man to me.
    ...
    .
    SourGrapes wrote: »
    So, turns out I'm Govan's biggest fan. I thought he was OK - better than most of the finalists that year!
    ...
    For those wondering about Govan, I gave him his lowest ranking. Everyone bitches, but the way he did it just rubbed me up the wrong way. Zero empathy and all about himself. He took pleasure in it. He was a silly little boy, who hopefully has grown up a bit since leaving the house.
    ...

    I think Wonkey is right that it was gossip, more than bitching.

    But Govan had a peculiar -- and perhaps unique -- talent for seeming much more sly and bitchy than his actual words would suggest. He was poison, since it made the HM(s) he was talking with seem very sly and bitchy too. It was one of the reasons why Rachael was disliked and evicted, and it worked strongly against Shabby and Co too, once they began gossiping with him.

    He also brought about one of the most strange, in a way quite dismaying, events in BB history: BB inventing a rule, and punishing HMs for "breaking" it, because of an outcry on the forums. Govan and Shabby were discussing who to save, or maybe who to use as the replacement, in the upcoming save and replace task, and for some reason Govan thought he had to be secretive and referred to Mario as "pasta" rather than using his name.

    There was outrage in the forums that they weren't being punished, because people thought the rule against discussing nominations should apply, and Govan and Shabby were discussing who would face the vote. But BB explained that it didn't, because they weren't discussing nominations. Outrage continued. BB caved in and punished them for using a code.

    However, there wasn't actually a general rule against using code. The rules that mention codes are about communication with the outside (which this wasn't) and discussing nominations (which this wasn't and BB had already said it wasn't).

    Of course, BB can change the rules at any time, but BB didn't say they'd changed the rules, nor did they change the rules on the website. (Sneaking in a rule change without changing the website is what got them in trouble with the regulator when they let Nikki back. Really.)

    Also, "codes" such as "Adams Family" had regularly been used in bb11 discussions that could have been considered violations of the rule against discussing nominations.
Sign In or Register to comment.