Do you like Comedy VT's or do you prefer training video clips?
Mrs BBV
Posts: 3,003
Forum Member
✭✭✭
Just curious.
I just wonder if the SCD production give us what we want or what they think we want?
I just wonder if the SCD production give us what we want or what they think we want?
Comedy VT's or Training Clips 80 votes
Comedy VT's.
3%
3 votes
Training Clips.
85%
68 votes
A combination of the two.
11%
9 votes
0
Comments
The "comedy" VTs are generally so far removed from being funny, they are painful to watch (and offer no insight into the training).
Judy Murray's VT on Halloween week was funny. I like those kind. Especially if it's for a panto comedy contestant.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p0110gvs
I remember a naturally funny moment with Vincent and his partner (sorry can't remember her name) She couldn't understand if he was telling her to pause or pose - the more he tried to say it right the funnier it got.
Much prefer something spontaneous to anything contrived.
However, I think they underestimate their audience. To sit through weeks and weeks of a show based on dancing, viewers must surely find some 'entertainment' value and interest in the actual dancing, not JUST the fun side? And therefore would be more interested in training clips - with perhaps the occasional comedy clip thrown in for good measure?
I'm not sure - the camera is set up in the training rooms anyway and we are allowed to see teasers on ITT - so any addition to that is going to potentially cost more not less?
Can Carol Smilie have a word and tell a couple of contestants how popular Carol Cam was
I would rather see how couples are doing in training.
Its a lot cheaper to have someone on job experience think up funny ideas for a VT and then throw those together as cheaply as possible.
Plus - now that it is much less of a real dance contest and more of an arranged 'happening', there is less reason for the participants to be committed and get emotional about it, so there is likely to be less raw material from training. If you are doing a Paso to Rumba music after flying in on a crane sitting on a bicycle, it doesn't really matter what you do.
Yes, but a lot of the time the comedy VT involves filming at other locations - various sporting venues, theme parks, clubs and pubs and the like - I would have thought the cost of setting that up outweighed finding a normal training clip - especially when the person doing the filming could point them in the right direction - and someone is obviously doing it for ITT anyway.
Maybe.
The other element is unpredictability.
With the VT, you have total control of it.
With a training based VT, you depend on there being raw data.
Louise Rainbow seems to me like someone who doesn't like to feel there is an element of chance involved in keeping her job.