Nichole ditches two good singers for Rylan????

jules1000 · 30/09/12 - 20:26

Crazy:(:(

He cannot sing what is the point.

Unigal07 · 30/09/12 - 20:26

It's more obvious than ever before that the judges just read from a script. I don't believe any of them do the choosing.

Vodka_Drinka · 30/09/12 - 20:27

Ridiculous. I was hoping we'd be free of the joke acts this year but they just can't help themselves can they?

[Deleted User] · 30/09/12 - 20:28

Unigal07 wrote: »

It's more obvious than ever before that the judges just read from a script. I don't believe any of them do the choosing.

Agree, and how over the top is Rylan!!!

[Deleted User] · 30/09/12 - 20:28

Is Rylan the Essex guy who broke down when she put him through? I don't know any of their names lol

jules1000 · 30/09/12 - 20:28

Vodka_Drinka wrote: »

Ridiculous. I was hoping we'd be free of the joke acts this year but they just can't help themselves can they?

The two guys that she let go were really good it just dos'nt make any sense.....:mad:

oscardelahoya · 30/09/12 - 20:29

I guess that's that guy who's just this second been on? First time I've watched X Factor this year and switched on just in time for that! Don't think I'll bother

What a knob.

I'm sure I've seen him on snog, marry, avoid, or maybe everyone just looks the same now.

docman · 30/09/12 - 20:29

You mean she ditched a bunch of forgettable also runs for the superstar that is Rylan the magnificent!!!

sj3000 · 30/09/12 - 20:30

Ridiculous. We all knew how contrived the show is - they couldn't make it any more obvious with this move.

I hope somebody organises a campaign to get him to win - the whole show is a farce...

sattekop · 30/09/12 - 20:30

and just all that to get a little crying game "good television" from Rylan....... Nicole is doing a louis???

[Deleted User] · 30/09/12 - 20:31

Does seem a bit odd. Personally I think he was lucky to get past the fist audition. Seems like a lovely lad, but he was easily the worst singer in that category, yes, his judges house audition was better than he had done previously, but it still wasn't as good as the other acts

[Deleted User] · 30/09/12 - 20:31

docman wrote: »

You mean she ditched a bunch of forgettable also runs for the superstar that is Rylan the magnificent!!!

true tale more people are gonna remember him than other two! who people will forget about by next week!

pepipop · 30/09/12 - 20:31

Unigal07 wrote: »

It's more obvious than ever before that the judges just read from a script. I don't believe any of them do the choosing.

Precisely, it's all devised by the producers beforehand. I don't think Nicole, Cheryl, etc.. would have the 'nerve' or could sleep at night if they had to make the choices themselves, and then fell flat on their faces.

PJ1893 · 30/09/12 - 20:32

Looking at the category though... Rylan's the most watchable out of the three boys

(when he's not breaking down

)

Cranberryapple · 30/09/12 - 20:33

What an embarrassment he is:o

jules1000 · 30/09/12 - 20:33

bluehill wrote: »

true tale more people are gonna remember him than other two! who people will forget about by next week!

Well that depends on whether one wants to hear singers or novelty acts that cannot sing but are soooooooooo SHUTUP...

:(

docman · 30/09/12 - 20:36

jules1000 wrote: »

Well that depends on whether one wants to hear singers or novelty acts that cannot sing but are soooooooooo SHUTUP...:(

Different strokes. If it was all "credible" singers nobody would watch. See "The Voice" for evidence.

[Deleted User] · 30/09/12 - 20:36

jules1000 wrote: »

Well that depends on whether one wants to hear singers or novelty acts that cannot sing but are soooooooooo SHUTUP...:(

I don't know what he did before Judges houses but yesterday he put in a really decent performance vocally. I wanted him through, I don't care about his attitude he can sing.

yesman2012 · 30/09/12 - 20:38

further discrediting this show as a 'singing contest'

lol at some of the people flaming me for my shallowness in my thread about no fit girls

[Deleted User] · 30/09/12 - 20:39

jules1000 wrote: »

Crazy:(:(

He cannot sing what is the point.

He gets through and Eddie String doesn't even get to the judges 'arses , crazy . Wot are they finking ?

jules1000 · 30/09/12 - 21:00

Sheechiibii wrote: »

I don't know what he did before Judges houses but yesterday he put in a really decent performance vocally. I wanted him through, I don't care about his attitude he can sing.

He really cannot sing wait for the live shows to prove me right..He is bland with nothing real or unique to offer.

[Deleted User] · 30/09/12 - 21:04

jules1000 wrote: »

He really cannot sing wait for the live shows to prove me right..He is bland with nothing real or unique to offer.

Maybe, I don't know, like I said I've only seen him the once. But from his performance yesterday I thought he was good enough to go through and if he's capable of pulling of singing well once I'm sure he can do it again.

jules1000 · 30/09/12 - 21:05

Sheechiibii wrote: »

Maybe, I don't know, like I said I've only seen him the once. But from his performance yesterday I thought he was good enough to go through and if he's capable of pulling of singing well once I'm sure he can do it again.

:D Lets see...Bring this thread up when the time comes.:p

dirrrty · 30/09/12 - 21:05

Well so did Tulisa. I mean Lucy ....

[Deleted User] · 30/09/12 - 21:06

Nah, she ditched two dullards for somebody with a bit of personality.

[Deleted User] · 30/09/12 - 21:07

I don't think he is as bad as people are saying. Obviously he isn't the best vocalist in the competition, and his OTT personality will surely grate after a while. But I don't think he is a bad vocalist, at all.

I do agree, however, that Adam and Nathan were better then him and perhaps either of them should have made it over Rylan.

Hey there!

Quick Links

Nichole ditches two good singers for Rylan????

Comments