Worst song choices of the series
![[Deleted User]](https://w9.vanillicon.com/v2/9746b7e56439f45751696d95d4a67ccb.svg)
[Deleted User]
Posts: 336 Forum Member
✭
Which song choices do you think the mentors got totally wrong?
0
[Deleted User]
Posts: 336 [Deleted User]
Posts: 336 [Deleted User]
Posts: 336 [Deleted User]
Posts: 336
Comments
Matt - Bleeding Love
Nicolo - Just Dance
All of John's song choices were awful
I do agree, for him personally. But funny how he got the top votes on that week.
I know - especially after Cher's ridiculously over hyped pimp slot performance that week.
Storm's
The non uptempo ones of Rebecca's
It maybe suggests that a critical percentage of voters voted with their groins instead of their ears and brains. Or maybe there's another explanation.
Other's worth a mention:
Mary - There You'll Be - that song needs a soft vocal.
Katie - Sex on Fire
Cher - Imagine
Belle Amie - Airplanes (love the song but it doesnt suit a group)
TreyC - Relight my Fire
All of Storms
Diva Fever - Duck sauce - they were given a song that hardly had any lyrics to it.
Mary - There You'll Be
Katie - Sex is on Fire
Dear lord, I was so looking forward to that and it was a complete mess. Awfulll.
Diva Fever seemed bitter about it too. In their F Factor interview, they were asked something along the lines of what song they'd sing next week if they were still in (I may be completely wrong about the question...) but they said "something with more than three notes...thanks, Simon"
or maybe people thought that he was so good, even with a poor song (and I hate that song) he was better than the competition. IMO only perhaps half a dozen performances of any of the other acts came close to even Matt's worst song choices, a couple of Chers, a couple of Aiden's and a couple of Rebecca's.
That said the week he did Bleeding Love, Cher did Stay, which, for me was the only week that his performance was not the best on the night and whilst as he was my favourite act, I did vote for him, I voted for Cher too.
I actually liked that one
Me too! The short one actually had a good voice.
John - Zoom
Belle Amie - Airplanes
Treyc - Relight My Fire
Katie - Saturday Night's Alright for Fighting
Matt - Come Together
Aiden - Rocketman
Also during rock week he really had the pick of virtually every rock song ever written to showcase what he could do in that genre- and what did he get lumbered with? "I love Rock and Roll". OK, he did a great job with it but I was expecting something amazing- With or Without You by U2 or something like that (Although of course he also sang NIWS that night which was superb).
They're prob not stricly the worst choices, but they stand out for me cos I was disappointed in them as Matt was/is my complete favourite.
What was Danni thinking?! :mad:
I say this as someone who doesn't vote, but I could perceive that's how voters would act.
Then there is a totally different kind of voter who just votes once each week for whatever they think is the best performance, but it feels as though the majority of votes are just for the voter's favourite act altogether.
Ditto
Diva Fever - Barbra Streisand
Matt - Come Together
Cher - Imagine
Katie - Sex on Fire/Saturday Night's All Right For Fighting
Mary - There You'll Be (not so much for the song but the fact she struggled with so much of it)