Options
Rochelle Wiseman (from The Saturdays) would be a great X Factor judge!
![[Deleted User]](https://w1.vanillicon.com/v2/1926b7b684cbbcaad5542d5450b16a0f.svg)
[Deleted User]
Posts: 3,445 Forum Member
✭✭✭
I was just thinking she would be great. Her and Tulisa have a great relationship and are great friends outside of work. (You just have to look at Twitter to see that)
She is opinionated, she is now the best singer of The Saturdays. She is also getting married to Marvin from JLS meaning she'll be in the papers a lot.
She would make a great replacement for Kelly Rowland.
She is opinionated, she is now the best singer of The Saturdays. She is also getting married to Marvin from JLS meaning she'll be in the papers a lot.
She would make a great replacement for Kelly Rowland.
0
Comments
They could try and get someone from a successful girl group - not one thats been struggling for some years now
Why???
Probably been mentioned before, so I apologise.
Rochelle would be a good choice. Posted this in another thread the other day, but just posting it again rather than repeating myself and missing stuff out haha. She seems the most vocal and least camera shy out of The Saturdays too. Out of the rest of the girls, she's the most distinctive and has the most 'star quality' I think (if anyone hasn't seen her.. here she is! Haha http://www.hellomagazine.com/imagene...lli-lau--a.jpg). She's marrying to Marvin from JLS this summer so she'll be all over the papers there too, and she has a constant media presence regardless what with being in The Saturdays, who've done relatively well - over 3 million records sold since 2008, 11 top 10 singles, 3 top 10 albums, 3 headline tours and so on etc. She's very business savvy when it comes to the group and driven too.
She's been in the media industry, especially music and TV, since her early teens, as she was in S Club Juniors, who sold over 1 million records or so during their rather short time on the market and had 6 top 10 singles etc so she has plenty of experience, she's had to graft and work hard from the bottom and she has plenty of extensive knowledge in the industry and knows what it takes. She's current and relevant, which Simon always bangs on about.
She'd be a good choice IMO. She's a nice girl, relatable to the teen girls and sweet. She seems really down to Earth, classy, grounded, gorgeous but she still seems a tough cookie, confident, can be a bit gobby and loud, opinionated, fiesty and vocal. She's friends with Tulisa, supported Gary/Take That on their Circus tour with The Sats, Louis knows of her... she'd fit in well. She caters to the main XF audience, and the press would lap her up - she's already got a high 'showbiz' profile but it'd really kick off if she got on the panel. And that can only be a good thing for the show. She's a laugh and has the most personality and talent from The Saturdays too IMO. She has a face and personality for TV.
And the girl *can* actually sing!
Rochelle should get a shot and have a chance, she'd work out well on the show I think. But it's not up to me, but they should consider her!
Typical that the link I post to the pic of her looking her best is broken... here's a better link: http://i46.tinypic.com/2c0qc7.jpg (obviously she's the one on the left
Of course everyone thought I was going crackers but now even papers are saying she could do it. Plus look how happy Rochelle and Tulisa are together...
http://pappzd.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/01/rochelle-vs-tulisa.jpg
http://www.mirror.co.uk/incoming/article687739.ece/ALTERNATES/s615/Tulisa+hanging+with+The+Saturdays+band+member+Rochelle+in+LA
http://nowmagazine.media.ipcdigital.co.uk/11140%7C00001be72%7C6016_orh100000w360_Rochelle-Wiseman-and-Tulisa-Contostavlos-2.jpg
http://media.zenfs.com/en-GB/blogs/the-bike-shed/Rochelle-Wiseman-Tulisa-LA.jpg
http://l.yimg.com/bt/api/res/1.2/df11LmGPv9F_wYEdHf3ORw--/YXBwaWQ9eW5ld3M7Zmk9aW5zZXQ7aD00NzM7cT04NTt3PTYzMA--/http://l.yimg.com/os/289/2012/01/13/rochelle-tulisa-1_131521.jpg
I would be nice to have two female judges which were really good friends instead of hating each other.
I think another member of Girls Aloud would be great or Keisha/Mutya from the Sugababes.
The same could have been said for Tulisa, and even Dannii, and they got on the panel just fine - didn't affect them being able to judge others and pick out talent. Besides, it can be more than 'judging others to be successful' - if they've an eye for talent and are enthusiastic about nurturing and helping new talent why shouldn't Rochelle or Frankie have a chance? They have a good profile in the UK, their single sales are fine, several of which have outsold Girls Aloud who you seem to be praising. The Sats struggle with albums, yes, but even so - not everyone is going to shift albums like they do singles and 11 top 10 singles (out of 13 singles released), and over 3 million records shifted in 4 years shows they have been a moderate success whether you like them or not, BUT I do get where you're coming from with albums wise.
Yes, they may not be a meteoric success but just because they haven't doesn't mean they can't spot talent. Bit of a ridiculous assumption. I like them a lot and I think Rochelle especially would be great on the panel. She has plenty of knowledge and experience about talent and music itself, what's good or not, techniques and so on - she's been in the bloody industry since she was 12 in S Club Juniors! None of the others in Girls Aloud would be decent - Nicola, Kimberley, Nadine - snooze, I like Sarah's personality but she wouldn't be upto much as a judge. Speaking of Keisha, she would be good too!
but wouldnt want her as a judge, she in the saturday, they are not really a successful girl group
i can imagine someone who gets a 'no' from her, just criticisng her for miming like example did
She doesn't mime anymore. In fact she's the Saturdays strongest and new lead singer now!
Sorry bbbnbbb about the duplicate thread. I was sure there must have been another thread - I should have looked harder!
Perhaps we can get the threads merged. If not we have two threads to attract the powers that be!