1) Matt - Naturaly listen to rock so no objections to tonights more gritty vocal - same old story, if he only did the same thing every week he would be criticised for being a one trick pony, does something different and gets slagged for it - pathetic
2) Cher - Sang the song well IMHO and again don't get the critics about the lack of rapping
3) One Direction - Fpr the energy that they created out of nowhere for the 2nd part of the song a good effort and if they can learn to do that more often they really could be onto something
4) Mary - Too shouty otherwise would have been 2nd for me
5) Rebecca - I can see what she was trying to do but missed by some margin
6) Katie - Just too desperate, needs to go for her own mental well being
7) Paije - Must have been listening to a different show to most people, completely forgettable
8) Wagner. 10/10 for hippy hippy shake, war crime trial for Hey Jude.
Comments
2. Rebecca
3. Katie
Probably
Yes, I objectively preferred Cher's performance to Mary's. She's a natural performer. Mary is like a Shirley Bassey impersonator.
Paige
Cher
^^^^^^This^^^^^^
2) Cher - Sang the song well IMHO and again don't get the critics about the lack of rapping
3) One Direction - Fpr the energy that they created out of nowhere for the 2nd part of the song a good effort and if they can learn to do that more often they really could be onto something
4) Mary - Too shouty otherwise would have been 2nd for me
5) Rebecca - I can see what she was trying to do but missed by some margin
6) Katie - Just too desperate, needs to go for her own mental well being
7) Paije - Must have been listening to a different show to most people, completely forgettable
8) Wagner. 10/10 for hippy hippy shake, war crime trial for Hey Jude.
The worst were in my opinion, rather suprisingly, Matt and Rebecca.
It's like a complete flip, with the usual "worst" ones being the best and the "best" ones being the worst.
Agreed, Mary and Paije.