The Genius of Invention, BBC2&HD 9pm, 24 - 31 Jan, 7-14 Feb

12467

Comments

  • Doghouse RileyDoghouse Riley Posts: 32,491
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    saralund wrote: »
    I thought there was some interesting information, but it wasn't made more understandable by having someone cycling a bike in circles round a turbine hall. The three presenters looked ill-at-ease to me, which was surprising as two of them are used to being in front of the camera doing science shows. Michael Mosley's niche is medical stuff / biology, so perhaps he seemed an odd fit as lead presenter? Instead of listening to what they were saying, I found myself wondering if there had been a row between presenters, or among the production team, or if it was actually being filmed live! I think they might have been better off with just one presenter. With three of them, it became Blue Peter Explains Electricity

    The three of 'em did make a very determined effort to "engage" an audience at the beginning of the programme.

    However, I immediately detected that all this apparent "carefully rehearsed enthusiasm" was an indication of what level the rest was going to be pitched, which I think did it no favours.
  • snoweyowlsnoweyowl Posts: 1,922
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Bluepeterised is a perfect description of this very disappointing show.
  • Kolin KlingonKolin Klingon Posts: 4,296
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    I would think that his generator would be in the form of a dynamo (as opposed to an alternator). A dynamo makes use of a commutator (just like a dc motor) to switch the direction of current so that it doesn't alternate.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dynamo

    Dynamos were commonly used in cars for battery-charging purposes, until they eventually got replaced by alternators (this change being made possible by the advent of cheap solid-state rectifiers).

    Ah! Yep, I know about dynamos and commutators so that all makes perfect sense. Thanks for the info.

    In the power station featured they moved the magnets and kept the winding stationary. That is a lot easier as you don't get loses on rotating contact resistance and sparks! And the AC they get out is what they want anyway.

    :)
  • gomezzgomezz Posts: 44,474
    Forum Member
    Shame no mention of Tesla and his competing DC system.
  • The WizardThe Wizard Posts: 11,071
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    snoweyowl wrote: »
    Bluepeterised is a perfect description of this very disappointing show.

    I really can't believe how totally snobby and hard people are about this good little programme. It's primetime on BBC2 smack bang in the 'light entertainment' slot so it has to appeal to the masses, most of whom may need things explaining in layman's terms.

    You want the nerdy stuff for university graduates and people who already have a keen interest and knowledge on the subject then turn to BBC4.

    Personally I'd much rather watch stuff like this than half the brain dead stuff that's on most of the time. Bluepeter is a bit harsh. It's no worse than Dara's Science Club or an episode of Bang. Just science for the mass population.
  • Doghouse RileyDoghouse Riley Posts: 32,491
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    The Wizard wrote: »
    I really can't believe how totally snobby and hard people are about this good little programme. It's primetime on BBC2 so it has to appeal to the masses, most of whom may need things explaining in layman's terms.

    You want the nerdy stuff for university graduates and people who already have a keen interest and knowledge on the subject then turn to BBC4.

    Personally I'd much rather watch stuff like this than half the brain dead stuff that's on most of the time.

    Perhaps you are younger than some of those who are complaining about it.
    It is their belief that there's been a progressive dumbing down of documentaries. It's all about ratings, getting as many people to watch and so for some, making it a lesser programme.

    I always use the analogy of an old rhyming ditty, containing a lot of alliteration, about a Dutch ship's captain and his cargoes of sacks of rice, which were always contaminated with mouse droppings.

    He argued reasonably, that he appreciated there was no way he could avoid having the mouse droppings, but why couldn't they be put all in the same sack?

    If you scroll back you'll see my post about the ridiculous lengths to which they went, to explain what was a "third."

    A classic example of total dumbness.
  • technologisttechnologist Posts: 13,312
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    I agree it was a very good Programme - on BRITISH Inventors ....

    How some people can turn it into Blue Peterising how to make electricity or complain that a Serbian American was not featured puzzles me greatly ..

    Did not they start by saying what they were going to cover and then showing little films demos and interviews on each pone??

    Some of the antics of the Presenters were a bit Gross - but where else would you hear why Patents stop innovation - or the Role of Matthew Boulton in making Watt a success.
    and all the inserts were good!!!!
  • gomezzgomezz Posts: 44,474
    Forum Member
    I agree it was a very good Programme - on BRITISH Inventors ....

    How some people can turn it into Blue Peterising how to make electricity or complain that a Serbian American was not featured puzzles me greatly ..
    How did Edison make the cut then? :confused:
  • Doghouse RileyDoghouse Riley Posts: 32,491
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    I agree it was a very good Programme - on BRITISH Inventors ....

    How some people can turn it into Blue Peterising how to make electricity or complain that a Serbian American was not featured puzzles me greatly ..

    Did not they start by saying what they were going to cover and then showing little films demos and interviews on each pone??

    Some of the antics of the Presenters were a bit Gross - but where else would you hear why Patents stop innovation - or the Role of Matthew Boulton in making Watt a success.
    and all the inserts were good!!!!

    The problem with this programme, was that for much of the time, it had more style than substance.


    There have been patent wars since the beginning of....well..... patents.
  • wazzyboywazzyboy Posts: 13,345
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    Wazzy agress with Wizzy. When it comes to factual progs, if you want 'em full on, watch specialist progs or channels. Simples.
  • lundavralundavra Posts: 31,790
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    gomezz wrote: »
    How did Edison make the cut then? :confused:

    Wasn't he mentioned in the context of Joseph Swan?

    Swan invented the incandescent light bulb but Edison patented it and made a fortune from it.
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 643
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    The trailer for this programme is driving me nuts!!! It's on all the time; can't wait for Thursday to arrive so perhaps it will stop.
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 87,224
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    bumped for tonight!
  • ednwirelandednwireland Posts: 170
    Forum Member
    bumped for tonight!
    really enjoy this show, forgot it was on, used to work in rolls royce after graduating great company
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 87,224
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    That demo of how Trevithick made his boilers more efficient worked well, and the effectiveness of cylindrical boilers.
  • sandydunesandydune Posts: 10,986
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    Glad they aren't watching the kettles as it won't boil if they do.:D
  • Rodney McKayRodney McKay Posts: 8,143
    Forum Member
    It's amazing how many of our inventors we forget about.
  • Rodney McKayRodney McKay Posts: 8,143
    Forum Member
    She drinks pints, my kinda girl :)
  • LostFoolLostFool Posts: 90,623
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    I was born in Darlington. Anyone who grew up there would understand the need to invent something so that people could leave as quickly as possible ;)
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 87,224
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    I didn't realise that Otto couldn't get a patent for his engine.
  • Rodney McKayRodney McKay Posts: 8,143
    Forum Member
    Frank Whittle another genius shafted by our tosser politicians.
  • LostFoolLostFool Posts: 90,623
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Enjoying hearing Cassie talking about sucking, banging and blowing....;)
  • Ed R.MarleyEd R.Marley Posts: 9,116
    Forum Member
    This demonstration of a jet engine is toe-curlingly awful. This sort of dumb shite should be on CBBC, not 9pm on BBC2:yawn:
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 87,224
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Charlie Brooker now, then Question Time.
    Not a bad night's telly!
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 961
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    Charlie Brooker now, then Question Time.
    Not a bad night's telly!

    Yes if you like childrens TV:eek: Dom joly on QT wtf.
Sign In or Register to comment.