The Judges

Comments

• Options

  dwiseman Posts: 4,011

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  16/10/11 - 11:36 #2

  I was disappointed in them last night -they've reverted to the usual tired old cliches sadly -Gary Barlow at least tells it more like it is but not for his own acts - though he's clearly a poor liar -as it was obvious that even he couldnt muster up any genuine enthusiasm for Frankie last night.

  0
• Options

  BrunoStreete Posts: 7,180

  Forum Member

  ✭

  16/10/11 - 12:53 #3

  Rosie Red wrote: »

  When will see one of the judges/mentors have the balls to actually slate one of their own acts.
  
  Don't they realise that they make themselves look clueless when they praise someone who is blatantly awful?
  
  Are they so arrogant that they think the public have no conception of what's good?
  
  They may end up losing one of their acts if they did find the guts to be honest, but they wouldn't lose their own credibility.

  
  If the alternative is to destroy the confidence of their act then they are right to praise them.

  0
• Options

  Nobody Knows Posts: 1,910

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  16/10/11 - 12:56 #4

  I was just about to post a thread asking why the 'judges' never seem to give any proper feedback (especially not negative) to the acts, but now I've found this...
  
  Maybe they think that telling the acts the truth will trigger a Britney-style meltdown?

  0