who was your fave Charmed One in "Charmed"?

TheSlayer10 · 28/12/10 - 19:30

Mine is definetly either Prue or Piper as imo they wiped the floor with Milano and McGowan in the acting stakes.

[Deleted User] · 28/12/10 - 19:36

TheSlayer10 wrote: »

Mine is definetly either Prue or Piper as imo they wiped the floor with Milano and McGowan in the acting stakes.

Milano :-)
She's an Ok actress - But I wasn't watching just for her acting abilities.

Second has to be Holly Marie Combes She was lovely.

nats18 · 28/12/10 - 21:39

I liked Prue then changed to Piper. I did like Phoebe in early series but when they changed her into just walking boobs and all her storylines just who she was sleeping with I got bored. Paige was just there

LightningIguana · 28/12/10 - 21:43

Piper. Girl could act.

Matt D · 28/12/10 - 21:49

For a moment there I thought that this was going to be yet another "misterpoll.com" thread from Mufftown, 'till I saw the thread-starter!

[Deleted User] · 28/12/10 - 21:50

I've been watching Charmed a lot lately, and it has always been Piper. But Paige has always been a close second. When I was younger it was Phoebe but as the show progressed I think they really messed up her character. I blame Cole's introduction, he took all the fun out of her and she was never the same again.

And while I liked Prue and Shannen is an amazing actress, I think she was always too much of a leader to be my favourite if that makes any sense.

TheSlayer10 · 28/12/10 - 21:53

nats18 wrote: »

Paige was just there

Agree

Check this out, the majority prefer Prue over Paige anyday

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tnxGsw_2Y0o

[Deleted User] · 28/12/10 - 23:21

Prue, she was really the only character who had something about her. And I always associate her with the best Seasons. God what a silly (or sillier you could argue) show it became from S5 onwards.

007Fusion · 29/12/10 - 09:55

My favorite was Piper. I liked that she was quitely confident and how Leo brought out the best in her in early seasons. My second was Phoebe but i eventually moved onto Paige as the seasons progressed.

natalie77 · 29/12/10 - 10:13

Piper was definitely my favourite character I really liked her & Leo's story through the show. I would probably say Prue was my least favourite & I wasn't all that bothered when she left

Lobelia Overhil · 29/12/10 - 15:39

Prue

and after she left, Piper.

Phoebe always annoyed me intensely...

[Deleted User] · 29/12/10 - 18:56

Prue by a mile, she was gorgeous in Playboy and you gotta love a girl who get's kidnapped and tied up by some male model/gangster and the the first thing she does when released is jump his bones.

Phoboe/Alyssa is also hot, especially her nude scenes in The Outer Limits. Phoboe nude/nypmho seemed to be a favourite storyline in Charmed

Piper is also hot, the prettiest of them all although kinda flat-chested.

Used to like Rose but heard she was a fenian b*tch in real life so went off her

[Deleted User] · 29/12/10 - 19:06

Phoebe then Piper, Prue........Paige - very far under Prue

[Deleted User] · 29/12/10 - 19:42

Phoebe was always my favourite (especially in seasons 1-5) not so much in the latter seasons, agree the character was ruined

I guess it was piper in seasons 6,7 and 8 although i hated the amount of focus season 7 placed on leo

Prue was always my least favourite especially as season 1 was all about her

Agree with the other comments that paige was just... there (but i did like her friend with benefits glen

)

TWS · 29/12/10 - 20:49

Always Piper for me then probably Pheobe followed by Prue then Paige

Harris_07 · 29/12/10 - 20:54

Piper was my favourite overall, but I thought that Paige was the sexiest.

ker · 29/12/10 - 20:55

Piper from the first episode. Prue comes second, Phoebe third then Paige last.

I think part of what made me like Piper was she was always the down to earth one, more conservative in dress and was in love with Leo for practically the whole 8 seasons.

rianne · 29/12/10 - 20:56

Piper has been my favourite throughout the seasons, especially with storylines involving leo. She's lovely

I know shes not part of the charmed ones but i hated Billie in S8. I think the introduction of her character runied it!:mad:

[Deleted User] · 30/12/10 - 01:14

Piper for me as well.

Was never a fan of Paige, much preferred the earlier seasons with Pru. I gave up on the show when it was originally aired after suffering through a season of Paige and have only recently watched the seasons I missed. She wasn't as bad as I remembered, but still not a patch on Pru.

circlebro2019 · 30/12/10 - 09:35

piper i guess but she kinda got annoying near the end,paige was a good addition and far better than prue,i felt charmed was in its peak s4-6

but cole/balthezar was the best character by far imo

Neighbours_Fan · 30/12/10 - 10:02

Piper.

[Deleted User] · 30/12/10 - 10:27

Prue without a doubt had the best chest too.

Paige always looked so anemic!

[Deleted User] · 30/12/10 - 12:03

rianne wrote: »

Piper has been my favourite throughout the seasons, especially with storylines involving leo. She's lovely

I know shes not part of the charmed ones but i hated Billie in S8. I think the introduction of her character runied it!:mad:

They should still a do a Charmed joke on Big Bang Theory some time:D

[Deleted User] · 30/12/10 - 14:04

Piper. By far.

[Deleted User] · 30/12/10 - 15:00

Prue for S1 to 3 and Piper 4 to 8, liked Phoebe but could never warm to Paige. Just found her so annoying.

[Deleted User] · 30/12/10 - 20:01

piper

Hey there!

Quick Links

who was your fave Charmed One in "Charmed"?

Comments