Options
Survivor: Enemies & Adversaries Round Three
Rita's Kabin
Posts: 36,447 Forum Member
✭
Thanks to everyone who voted in Round Two. 
First up is the first of three evictees from Season One in this round. It will come as no surprise to you to learn that the Jagrafess polled the most votes with 65.71% of you selecting it for eviction.
We have a tie in second place with the first evictee from Season Three:- the Pig Slaves getting votes from 45.71% of you along with the second evictee from Season One:- Christmas Tree
Rounding off our block of four is another option from Season One. It's those "quite cute" (according to Revenga) Metal Spiders from "The Enemy Of The World" who polled votes from 28.57% of you.
Well done to Katinka_k8 and Lily_Rose who both picked the four evictees from the round.
Remember that you can now send your votes into the following round automatically. Just type "auto" with your choices & your choices will automatically be carried forward into the following round(s).
And here's the Round Three Question:-
+ The Reapers
+ Satan
+ The Host
+ Robina Redmond
+ Adam Mitchell
i) The first four (above) didn't receive any votes in the last round. Which of them (plus Adam) would you like to see return to the series (if any)?
ii) Leaving aside your own personal opinions about the above characters & the episodes that they appeared in, if you had to pick one of the above five to return which do you think would be the best choice purely from a script point of view (ie: who's return would provide a suitable sequel in which the character(s) could be developed & could make a suitable impact?)
Anyway, on with the game......
As with the last round you need to select which SIX of the characters listed below you like the least and submit your choices either on this thread or via PM. The four characters with the most votes will be evicted from the game.
No votes will be accepted after the deadline
Recurring:
01) The Daleks (various episodes)
02) The Cybermen (various episodes)
03) The Ood (various episodes)
04) Dalek Caan (various episodes)
05) Cassandra (Zoe Wannamaker) (various episodes)
Season One:
06) Rose: The Autons / Nestene Intelligence
07) The Unquiet Dead: The Gelth
08) Father's Day: The Reapers
09) The Empty Child/The Doctor Dances - The Tula Zombies
10) Bad Wolf / The Parting Of The Ways: Emperor Dalek & Fleet
11) The Christmas Invasion: The Sycorax
12) The Christmas Invasion: Robot Santas
13) Dalek: Henry Van Statten (Corey Johnson)
14) Dalek: The Lone Dalek (various)
15) The Long Game: The Editor (Simon Pegg)
16) Boom Town: Margaret Blaine (Annette Badland)
17) Bad Wolf / The Parting Of The Ways: Anne Droid (Anne Robinson)
18) The Christmas Invasion: Sycorax Leader (Sean Gilder)
Season Two:
19) New Earth: The Sisters Of Plentiude
20) New Earth: Diseased Patients
21) Tooth & Claw: The Monks
22) Tooth & Claw: Werewolf
23) School Reunion: The Krillitanes
24) The Girl In The Fireplace: Clockwork Droids
25) The Impossible Planet / The Satan Pit: Satan
26) The Runaway Bride: Roboforms
27) School Reunion: Mr. Finch (Anthony Stewart Head)
28) Rise Of The Cybermen / Age Of Steel: John Lumic (Roger Lloyd Pack)
29) The Idiot's Lantern: The Wire (Maureen Lipman)
30) The Idiot’s Lantern: Mr. Magpie (Ron Cook)
31) The Impossible Planet / The Satan Pit: Toby Zed (Will Thorp)
32) Love And Monsters: The Hoix (Paul Kasey)
33) Army Of Ghosts / Doomsday: Black Dalek (various)
34) Army Of Ghosts / Doomsday: Cyberleader (various)
35) The Runaway Bride: Empress of the Racnoss (Sarah Parish)
Season Three:
36) Smith & Jones: The Judoon
37) The Shakespeare Code: Carrionites: {Mothers Doomfinger / Bloodtide plus “swarm” at the end}
38) Gridlock: The Macra
39) 42: Ship Saboteurs ~ Korwin (Matthew Chambers) & Ashton (Gary Powell)
40) Human Nature / The Family Of Blood: The Family Of Blood
41) Human Nature / The Family Of Blood: Scarecrow Soldiers
42) Blink: The Weeping Angels
43) Utopia: The Futurekind
44) The Sound Of Drums / Last Of The Timelords: The Toclafane
45) Voyage Of The Damned: The Hosts
46) Smith & Jones: Miss Finnegan (Anne Reid)
47) The Shakespeare Code: Lilith (Christina Cole)
48) Daleks In Manhattan / Evolution Of The Daleks: Mr. Diagoras (Eric Loren)
49) Daleks In Manhattan / Evolution Of The Daleks: Dalek Sec (various)
50) The Lazarus Experiment: Professor Lazarus (Mark Gatiss)
51) Utopia: The Master (Derek Jacobi)
52) The Sound Of Drums / Last Of The Timelords: Harold Saxon / The Master (John Simm)
53) Voyage Of The Damned: Max Capricorn (George Costigan)
Season Four:
54) The Fires Of Pompeii: The Pyroviles
55) The Doctor's Daughter: The Hath
56) Silence In The Library / Forest Of The Dead: Vashta Nerada {shadows / skeletons in spacesuits}
57) The Next Doctor: Cybershades
58) Partners In Crime: Miss Foster (Sarah Lancashire)
59) The Fires Of Pompeii: Lucius (Phil Davies)
60) Planet Of The Ood: Mr. Halpen (Tim McInnery)
61) Planet Of The Ood: Commander Kess (Roger Griffiths)
62) The Sontaran Strategem / The Poison Sky: General Staal (Christopher Ryan)
63) The Sontaran Strategem / The Poison Sky: Luke Rattigan (Ryan Sampson)
64) The Doctor's Daughter: General Cobb (Nigel Terry)
65) The Unicorn & The Wasp: Reverend Golightly (Tom Goodman-Hill)
66) The Unicorn & The Wasp: Robina Redmond (Felicity Jones)
67) Midnight: The possessed Sky Silvestry (Lesley Sharp)
68) Turn Left: Fortune Teller (Chipo Chung)
69) Turn Left: Time Beetle (various)
70) The Stolen Earth / Journey's End: Davros (Julian Bleach)
71) The Next Doctor: Miss Hartigan (Dervla Kirwan)
72) The Next Doctor: The Cyberking (Paul Kasey)
Voting closes at 8pm on Monday April 27th
First up is the first of three evictees from Season One in this round. It will come as no surprise to you to learn that the Jagrafess polled the most votes with 65.71% of you selecting it for eviction.
We have a tie in second place with the first evictee from Season Three:- the Pig Slaves getting votes from 45.71% of you along with the second evictee from Season One:- Christmas Tree
Rounding off our block of four is another option from Season One. It's those "quite cute" (according to Revenga) Metal Spiders from "The Enemy Of The World" who polled votes from 28.57% of you.
Well done to Katinka_k8 and Lily_Rose who both picked the four evictees from the round.
Remember that you can now send your votes into the following round automatically. Just type "auto" with your choices & your choices will automatically be carried forward into the following round(s).
And here's the Round Three Question:-
+ The Reapers
+ Satan
+ The Host
+ Robina Redmond
+ Adam Mitchell
i) The first four (above) didn't receive any votes in the last round. Which of them (plus Adam) would you like to see return to the series (if any)?
ii) Leaving aside your own personal opinions about the above characters & the episodes that they appeared in, if you had to pick one of the above five to return which do you think would be the best choice purely from a script point of view (ie: who's return would provide a suitable sequel in which the character(s) could be developed & could make a suitable impact?)
Anyway, on with the game......
As with the last round you need to select which SIX of the characters listed below you like the least and submit your choices either on this thread or via PM. The four characters with the most votes will be evicted from the game.
No votes will be accepted after the deadline
Recurring:
01) The Daleks (various episodes)
02) The Cybermen (various episodes)
03) The Ood (various episodes)
04) Dalek Caan (various episodes)
05) Cassandra (Zoe Wannamaker) (various episodes)
Season One:
06) Rose: The Autons / Nestene Intelligence
07) The Unquiet Dead: The Gelth
08) Father's Day: The Reapers
09) The Empty Child/The Doctor Dances - The Tula Zombies
10) Bad Wolf / The Parting Of The Ways: Emperor Dalek & Fleet
11) The Christmas Invasion: The Sycorax
12) The Christmas Invasion: Robot Santas
13) Dalek: Henry Van Statten (Corey Johnson)
14) Dalek: The Lone Dalek (various)
15) The Long Game: The Editor (Simon Pegg)
16) Boom Town: Margaret Blaine (Annette Badland)
17) Bad Wolf / The Parting Of The Ways: Anne Droid (Anne Robinson)
18) The Christmas Invasion: Sycorax Leader (Sean Gilder)
Season Two:
19) New Earth: The Sisters Of Plentiude
20) New Earth: Diseased Patients
21) Tooth & Claw: The Monks
22) Tooth & Claw: Werewolf
23) School Reunion: The Krillitanes
24) The Girl In The Fireplace: Clockwork Droids
25) The Impossible Planet / The Satan Pit: Satan
26) The Runaway Bride: Roboforms
27) School Reunion: Mr. Finch (Anthony Stewart Head)
28) Rise Of The Cybermen / Age Of Steel: John Lumic (Roger Lloyd Pack)
29) The Idiot's Lantern: The Wire (Maureen Lipman)
30) The Idiot’s Lantern: Mr. Magpie (Ron Cook)
31) The Impossible Planet / The Satan Pit: Toby Zed (Will Thorp)
32) Love And Monsters: The Hoix (Paul Kasey)
33) Army Of Ghosts / Doomsday: Black Dalek (various)
34) Army Of Ghosts / Doomsday: Cyberleader (various)
35) The Runaway Bride: Empress of the Racnoss (Sarah Parish)
Season Three:
36) Smith & Jones: The Judoon
37) The Shakespeare Code: Carrionites: {Mothers Doomfinger / Bloodtide plus “swarm” at the end}
38) Gridlock: The Macra
39) 42: Ship Saboteurs ~ Korwin (Matthew Chambers) & Ashton (Gary Powell)
40) Human Nature / The Family Of Blood: The Family Of Blood
41) Human Nature / The Family Of Blood: Scarecrow Soldiers
42) Blink: The Weeping Angels
43) Utopia: The Futurekind
44) The Sound Of Drums / Last Of The Timelords: The Toclafane
45) Voyage Of The Damned: The Hosts
46) Smith & Jones: Miss Finnegan (Anne Reid)
47) The Shakespeare Code: Lilith (Christina Cole)
48) Daleks In Manhattan / Evolution Of The Daleks: Mr. Diagoras (Eric Loren)
49) Daleks In Manhattan / Evolution Of The Daleks: Dalek Sec (various)
50) The Lazarus Experiment: Professor Lazarus (Mark Gatiss)
51) Utopia: The Master (Derek Jacobi)
52) The Sound Of Drums / Last Of The Timelords: Harold Saxon / The Master (John Simm)
53) Voyage Of The Damned: Max Capricorn (George Costigan)
Season Four:
54) The Fires Of Pompeii: The Pyroviles
55) The Doctor's Daughter: The Hath
56) Silence In The Library / Forest Of The Dead: Vashta Nerada {shadows / skeletons in spacesuits}
57) The Next Doctor: Cybershades
58) Partners In Crime: Miss Foster (Sarah Lancashire)
59) The Fires Of Pompeii: Lucius (Phil Davies)
60) Planet Of The Ood: Mr. Halpen (Tim McInnery)
61) Planet Of The Ood: Commander Kess (Roger Griffiths)
62) The Sontaran Strategem / The Poison Sky: General Staal (Christopher Ryan)
63) The Sontaran Strategem / The Poison Sky: Luke Rattigan (Ryan Sampson)
64) The Doctor's Daughter: General Cobb (Nigel Terry)
65) The Unicorn & The Wasp: Reverend Golightly (Tom Goodman-Hill)
66) The Unicorn & The Wasp: Robina Redmond (Felicity Jones)
67) Midnight: The possessed Sky Silvestry (Lesley Sharp)
68) Turn Left: Fortune Teller (Chipo Chung)
69) Turn Left: Time Beetle (various)
70) The Stolen Earth / Journey's End: Davros (Julian Bleach)
71) The Next Doctor: Miss Hartigan (Dervla Kirwan)
72) The Next Doctor: The Cyberking (Paul Kasey)
Voting closes at 8pm on Monday April 27th
0
Comments
To answer the question, I would like to see Satan again, but none of the others, especially that little g*t Adam.
The reapers from father's day? God, I have no idea how the hell they become part of a canon storyline, they sound like they've been ripped out of some bad fan fiction! They've contradicted everything we've seen before regarding time-altering and everything after, with the only feasible explainations involving the phrase 'Timey wimey'. They shouldn't just not appear again, their very appearance should be retconned.
It would be nice to see the Unicorn again, and I definitely feel there's some possibilities of a crossover with Michelle Ryan's character, seeing as there are huge similarities between them - it is a time travel show, after all! If it wasn't for her ridiculous (and predictable) OTT pantomime reveal as a baddie, I would be gunning for her to return.
The Host were a good villain for the occasion, but I don't know if I'd want them back - it'd have to be a very convincing story.
I would have been open for Adam to return in Series 2, but I feel that too much time has passed now - some characters have to remain relevant to the audience who haven't been long term viewers.
Votes to come tomorrow
S1
07) The Unquiet Dead: The Gelth
19) The Long Game: The Editor (Simon Pegg)
S2
23) New Earth: Diseased Patients
35) Love And Monsters: The Hoix (Paul Kasey)
S3
61) Voyage Of The Damned: Max Capricorn (George Costigan)
S4
69) Turn Left: Time Beetle (various)
My name in lights yet again ...! And quoted, too. I feel very privileged!!!
As for the questions ... I'd like to see Satan return, fantastic episodes and a great story, imo. Very much scope there to explore. Robina Redmond would be good for a return, too, I loved the Unicorn and the Wasp and I think another 1920s episode would be great, a fantastic period of time to explore. Not much of a backstory, so a lot could be added.
Will give my votes shortly
19) New Earth: The Sisters Of Plentiude - Cat people. 'Nuff said.
20) New Earth: Diseased Patients - Just boring zombies.
29) The Idiot's Lantern: The Wire (Maureen Lipman) - "HUNGRY!!" shut up!
32) Love And Monsters: The Hoix (Paul Kasey) - Interesting design, had potential, but pretty inconsequential.
38) Gridlock: The Macra - pointless? The whole episode was just a way of getting Boe back.
plus
The Reapers
Diseased Patients
The Macra
If so here are my votes:
26) The Runaway Bride: Roboforms (bit dull)
38) Gridlock: The Macra (not really a big part of the story)
45) Voyage Of The Damned: The Hosts (they're the autons/robot santas except shiny)
53) Voyage Of The Damned: Max Capricorn (George Costigan) (just didn't like him)
57) The Next Doctor: Cybershades (not used to any sort of full advantage)
59) The Fires Of Pompeii: Lucius (Phil Davies) (don't like Phil Davies, it's Steptoe born again)
38) The Runaway Bride: Empress of the Racnoss (Sarah Parish)
39) 42: Ship Saboteurs ~ Korwin (Matthew Chambers) & Ashton (Gary Powell)
54) The Lazarus Experiment: Professor Lazarus (Mark Gatiss)
57) Voyage Of The Damned: Max Capricorn (George Costigan)
68) The Doctor's Daughter: General Cobb (Nigel Terry)
As to the question, I wouldn't mind seeing Robina return, but I would really like to see the Host return. I have a thing for Christmassy stuff which turns deadly, I guess!
My votes:
05) Cassandra (Zoe Wannamaker) (various episodes)
07) The Unquiet Dead: The Gelth
16) Boom Town: Margaret Blaine (Annette Badland)
57) The Next Doctor: Cybershades
36) Smith & Jones: The Judoon
64) The Doctor's Daughter: General Cobb (Nigel Terry) - bad news from the getgo until he killed Jenny. Very true to life.
AUTO
OK from the last round:
58) The Lazarus Experiment: Professor Lazarus (Mark Gatiss)
65) The Next Doctor: Cybershades
47) 42: Ship Saboteurs ~ Korwin (Matthew Chambers) & Ashton (Gary Powell)
And my new ones:
33) Rise Of The Cybermen / Age Of Steel: John Lumic (Roger Lloyd Pack) - the actor's voice really puts me off. I didn't like him in Harry Potter either. I think that has affected my view on the villain.
34) The Idiot's Lantern: The Wire (Maureen Lipman) - I got tired of the constant 'HUNGRY'.
45) Gridlock: The Macra - they did show why the cars were going missing but we didn't really see much of them and I don't think they added that much to the storyline
Thanks RK
Reverend Golightly
Time Beetle
The Cyberking
Mr. Diagoras
Robot Santas
29) The Idiot's Lantern: The Wire (Maureen Lipman)
30) The Idiot’s Lantern: Mr. Magpie (Ron Cook)
48) Daleks In Manhattan / Evolution Of The Daleks: Mr. Diagoras (Eric Loren)
53) Voyage Of The Damned: Max Capricorn (George Costigan)
64) The Doctor's Daughter: General Cobb (Nigel Terry)
30) The Idiot’s Lantern: Mr. Magpie (Ron Cook)
38) Gridlock: The Macra
39) 42: Ship Saboteurs ~ Korwin (Matthew Chambers) & Ashton (Gary Powell)
54) The Fires Of Pompeii: The Pyroviles
57) The Next Doctor: Cybershades
For me this time please. Answer to the question coming later
Ta RK
The Idiot’s Lantern: Mr. Magpie (Ron Cook)
Love And Monsters: The Hoix (Paul Kasey)
The Runaway Bride: Roboforms
Voyage Of The Damned: Max Capricorn (George Costigan)
The Next Doctor: The Cyberking (Paul Kasey)
I'd quite like to see Satan back, but in such a way that the Doctor doesn't recognise him at first and thinks in passing could that have been ...
Here's my votes for who I liked the least:
Recurring:
05) Cassandra (Zoe Wannamaker) (various episodes)
Season One:
12) The Christmas Invasion: Robot Santas
15) The Long Game: The Editor (Simon Pegg)
Season Two:
23) School Reunion: The Krillitanes
28) Rise Of The Cybermen / Age Of Steel: John Lumic (Roger Lloyd Pack)
Season Three:
53) Voyage Of The Damned: Max Capricorn (George Costigan)
+ The Reapers
+ Satan
+ The Host
+ Robina Redmond
+ Adam Mitchell
I think I'd choose the Host, they were the most exciting out of anyone...but there might be a better storyling with The Reapers
Season One:
21) Tooth & Claw: The Monks
30) The Idiot’s Lantern: Mr. Magpie (Ron Cook)
31) The Impossible Planet / The Satan Pit: Toby Zed (Will Thorp)
32) Love And Monsters: The Hoix (Paul Kasey)
39) 42: Ship Saboteurs ~ Korwin (Matthew Chambers) & Ashton (Gary Powell)
65) The Unicorn & The Wasp: Reverend Golightly (Tom Goodman-Hill)
anne droid
diseased patients
mr magpie
macra (naff cgi crabs)
scarecrow soldiers
would love to see the reapers again
05) Cassandra (Zoe Wannamaker) (various episodes)
22) Bad Wolf / The Parting Of The Ways: Anne Droid (Anne Robinson)
59) The Doctor's Daughter: The Hath
43) 42: Ship Saboteurs ~ Korwin (Matthew Chambers) & Ashton (Gary Powell)
And the new ones.....
15) The Long Game: The Editor (Simon Pegg)
19) New Earth: The Sisters Of Plentiude
As for who I would like to or could see a return of is Satan or Adam.....both I think have some potential if the story is properly told...
Satan was basically shown as an idea type of alien....so has a lot psychological scare type potential.....I wouldn't like to see the CGI body of it again though...
Adam....even though he was an annoying A level student....I think the idea of him having to stay hidden...and being as intelligent as he was....could have potential some mean business...
Oh same here....he was one of the good things about series 1 TW
The Idiot’s Lantern: Mr. Magpie (Ron Cook)
Love And Monsters: The Hoix (Paul Kasey)
The Runaway Bride: Roboforms
Voyage Of The Damned: Max Capricorn (George Costigan)
The Next Doctor: The Cyberking (Paul Kasey)
So left from the first round:
63) The Doctor's Daughter: The Hath
And from last round:
43) 42: Ship Saboteurs ~ Korwin (Matthew Chambers) & Ashton (Gary Powell)
And four new ones:
12) The Christmas Invasion: Robot Santas
30) The Idiot’s Lantern: Mr. Magpie (Ron Cook)
45) Gridlock: The Macra
57) The Next Doctor: Cybershades
In answer to the question I would most like Adam or Satan to reappear, but only if there was a good enough story to have them back.
55) The Doctor's Daughter: The Hath
thank you