Options

Rate the Matt Smith stories

2

Comments

  • Options
    king yrcanosking yrcanos Posts: 2,145
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Yes,sorry I didn't put that there, it's jut that I was on holiday when it was broadcast and I went to a lot of trouble to find it. it has a promising start but it soon falters.
  • Options
    CELT1987CELT1987 Posts: 12,358
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    The Eleventh Hour 8/10
    The Beast Below 7/10
    Victory of the Daleks 6/10
    Time of the Angels 9/10
    Flesh and Stone 8/10
    Vampires of Venice 7/10
    Amy's Choice 8/10
    The Hungry Earth 5/10
    Cold Blood 5/10
    Vincent and the Doctor 9/10
    The Lodger 7/10
    The Pandorica Opens 8/10
    The Big Bang 9/10

    A Christmas Carol 5/10
    The Impossible Astronaut 7/10
    Day of the Moon 5/10
    The Curse of the Black Spot 6/10
    The Doctor's Wife 10/10
    The Rebel Flesh 5/10
    The Almost People 7/10
    A Good Man Goes to War 6/10
    Let's Kill Hitler 6/10
    Night Terrors 8/10
    The Girl Who Waited 10/10
    The God Complex 7/10
    Closing Time 7/10
    The Wedding of River Song 9/10
    The Doctor,The Widow and the Wadrobe 5/10
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 12
    Forum Member
    The Eleventh Hour 10/10
    The Beast Below 6/10
    Victory of the Daleks 5/10
    Time of the Angels 9/10
    Flesh and Stone 9/10
    Vampires of Venice 6/10
    Amy's Choice 8/10
    The Hungry Earth 5/10
    Cold Blood 5/10
    Vincent and the Doctor 7/10
    The Lodger 7/10
    The Pandorica Opens 10/10
    The Big Bang 9/10

    A Christmas Carol 7/10

    The Impossible Astronaut 8/10
    Day of the Moon 8/10
    The Curse of the Black Spot 7/10
    The Doctor's Wife 10/10
    The Rebel Flesh 6/10
    The Almost People 6/10
    A Good Man Goes to War 10/10
    Let's Kill Hitler 8/10
    Night Terrors 3/10
    The Girl Who Waited 8/10
    The God Complex 6/10
    Closing Time 8/10
    The Wedding of River Song 9/10

    The Doctor,The Widow and the Wardrobe 4/10
  • Options
    Granny McSmithGranny McSmith Posts: 19,622
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    The Eleventh Hour 8/10
    The Beast Below 3/10
    Victory of the Daleks 4/10
    Time of the Angels 6/10
    Flesh and Stone 6/10
    Vampires of Venice 7/10
    Amy's Choice 7/10
    The Hungry Earth 4/10
    Cold Blood 4/10
    Vincent and the Doctor 8/10
    The Lodger 6/10
    The Pandorica Opens 9/10
    The Big Bang 4/10

    A Christmas Carol 7/10

    The Impossible Astronaut 9/10
    Day of the Moon 9/10
    The Curse of the Black Spot 5/10
    The Doctor's Wife 9/10
    The Rebel Flesh 4/10
    The Almost People 4/10
    A Good Man Goes to War 8/10
    Let's Kill Hitler 8/10
    Night Terrors 5/10
    The Girl Who Waited 8/10
    The God Complex 8/10
    Closing Time 4/10
    The Wedding of River Song 8/10

    The Doctor,The Widow and the Wardrobe 0/10[/QUOTE]

    That last one is 0 (nothing) not a typo for 10.:D
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 208
    Forum Member
    The Eleventh Hour - 8/10
    The Beast Below - 7/10
    Victory of the Daleks - 6.5/10
    Time of the Angels - 9.5/10
    Flesh and Stone - 9.5/10
    Vampires in Venice - 7.5/10
    Amy's Choice - 9.5/10
    The Hungry Earth - 6/10
    Cold Blood - 6/10
    Vincent and the Doctor - 8/10
    The Lodger - 7/10
    The Pandorica Opens - 10/10
    The Big Bang - 10/10

    The Impossible Austronaut - 10/10
    Day of the Moon - 10/10
    Curse of the Black Spot - 7/10
    The Doctors Wife - 8.5/10
    Rebel Flesh - 5/10
    The Almost People - 6/10 (half of that for the last five minutes alone!)
    A Good Man Goes To War - 10/10
    Let's Kill Hitler - 9.5/10
    Night Terrors - 7.5/10
    The Girl Who Waited - 9.5/10
    The God Complex - 8/10
    Closing Time - 6/10 (again, half of that goes to the ending!)
    The Wedding of River Song - 10/10

    The Doctor, The Widow and the Wardrobe - 7.5/10
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 37
    Forum Member
    The Eleventh Hour 10/10
    The Beast Below 5/10
    Victory of the Daleks 4/10
    Time of Angels 8/10
    Flesh and Stone 9/10
    Vampires of Venice 7/10
    Amys Choice 9/10
    The Hungry Earth 3/10
    Cold Blood 3/10
    Vincent and the Doctor 10/10
    The Lodger 8/10
    The Pandorica Opens 10/10
    The Big Bang 10/10
    A Christmas Carol 2/10
    The Impossible Astronaut 9/10
    Day of the Moon 9/10
    The Curse of the Black Spot 4/10
    The Doctors Wife 10/10
    The Rebel Flesh 2/10
    The Almost People 5/10
    A Good Man Goes to War 8/10
    Lets Kill Hitler 9/10
    Night Terrors 6/10
    The Girl Who Waited 9/10
    The God Complex 9/10
    Closing Time 8/10
    The Wedding of River Song 10/10
    The Doctor The Widow and the Wardroble 1/10
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 1,038
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Let's Kill Hitler is by far the worst episode ever


    Love and Monsters
  • Options
    Whovian1109Whovian1109 Posts: 1,812
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Hello all!! :)

    The Eleventh Hour 10/10
    The Beast Below 8/10
    Victory of the Daleks 6/10
    The Time of Angels 9/10
    Flesh and Stone 9/10
    Vampires of Venice 8/10
    Amy's Choice 7/10
    The Hungry Earth 7/10
    Cold Blood 8/10
    Vincent and the Doctor 7/10
    The Lodger 7/10
    The Pandorica Opens 10/10
    The Big Bang 9/10

    A Christmas Carol 8/10

    The Impossible Astronaut: 10/10
    Day of the Moon: 9/10
    Curse of the Black Spot: 7/10
    The Doctor's Wife: 7/10
    The Rebel Flesh 8/10
    The Almost People: 8/10
    A Good Man Goes To War: 7/10
    Let's Kill Hitler 9/10
    Night Terrors: 5/10
    The Girl Who Waited: 8/10
    The God Complex: 8/10
    Closing Time: 7/10
    The Wedding of River Song 9/10

    The Doctor, The Widow and The Wardrobe: 3/10

    In retrospect, I may be being a bit harsh on the last Christmas special but then it was THAT awful. Overall, two excellent seasons, slightly preferred 5 over 6 but my two favourite seasons :D
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 509
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    The Eleventh Hour 10/10 Seriously, just about my favourite episode ever.
    The Beast Below 4/10
    Victory of the Daleks 6/10
    Time of the Angels 8/10
    Flesh and Stone 9/10 Loved it all apart from the Angels moving. And the boring voice of Angel Bob.
    Vampires of Venice 7/10
    Amy's Choice 9/10
    The Hungry Earth 5/10 Seemed better last time I rewatched compared to the original broadcast.
    Cold Blood 6/10
    Vincent and the Doctor 10/10 Sensational episode.
    The Lodger 8/10 Heartwarming.
    The Pandorica Opens 9/10
    The Big Bang 9/10

    A Christmas Carol 8/10

    The Impossible Astronaut 8/10
    Day of the Moon 9/10
    The Curse of the Black Spot 5/10
    The Doctor's Wife 8/10
    The Rebel Flesh 5/10
    The Almost People 6/10
    A Good Man Goes to War 8.5/10
    Let's Kill Hitler 8.5/10
    Night Terrors 8/10 Better than a lot of people make out, IMO.
    The Girl Who Waited 9/10 Nearly made me cry first time I watched it, that's quite an achievement.
    The God Complex 8/10
    Closing Time 7/10 If you ignore the ending it's pretty good, but not quite up to the standards of The Lodger.
    The Wedding of River Song 8/10

    The Doctor, The Widow and the Wardrobe: 3/10 It had Matt Smith playing the Doctor in it, that's some points automatically, but beyond that it's hard to think of redeeming features. The actress playing Madge gave it a good go, I guess. And I loved the last 5 minutes...
  • Options
    DavetheScotDavetheScot Posts: 16,623
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    kupo_nut wrote: »
    Love and Monsters

    The Impossible Astronaut/Day of the Moon is the worst for me, but I know not many here will agree.
  • Options
    AbominationAbomination Posts: 6,483
    Forum Member
    The Eleventh Hour 8/10
    The Beast Below 8/10
    Victory of the Daleks 6/10
    Time of the Angels 7/10
    Flesh and Stone 7/10
    Vampires of Venice 8/10
    Amy's Choice 8/10
    The Hungry Earth 5/10
    Cold Blood 6/10
    Vincent and the Doctor 9/10
    The Lodger 8/10
    The Pandorica Opens 8/10
    The Big Bang 8/10

    A Christmas Carol 9/10

    The Impossible Astronaut 7/10
    Day of the Moon 7/10
    The Curse of the Black Spot 7/10
    The Doctor's Wife 9/10
    The Rebel Flesh 6/10
    The Almost People 6/10
    A Good Man Goes to War 6/10
    Let's Kill Hitler 9/10
    Night Terrors 7/10
    The Girl Who Waited 9/10
    The God Complex 8/10
    Closing Time 6/10

    The Wedding of River Song 7/10 Ridiculous finale (half the length of the opener) but good fun in places.

    The Doctor, The Widow and the Wardrobe: 3/10 One of the weakest episodes of Nu-Who altogether.
  • Options
    gboygboy Posts: 4,989
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    The Eleventh Hour 9/10
    The Beast Below 7/10
    Victory of the Daleks 4/10
    The Time of Angels 9/10
    Flesh and Stone 9/10
    Vampires of Venice 5/10
    Amy's Choice 6/10
    The Hungry Earth 7/10
    Cold Blood 5/10
    Vincent and the Doctor 9/10
    The Lodger 7/10
    The Pandorica Opens 8/10
    The Big Bang 7/10
    A Christmas Carol 7/10
    The Impossible Astronaut: 8/10
    Day of the Moon: 8/10
    Curse of the Black Spot: 6/10
    The Doctor's Wife: 3/10
    The Rebel Flesh 7/10
    The Almost People: 7/10
    A Good Man Goes To War: 6/10
    Let's Kill Hitler 7/10
    Night Terrors: 4/10
    The Girl Who Waited: 7/10
    The God Complex: 7/10
    Closing Time: 7/10
    The Wedding of River Song 8/10
    The Doctor, The Widow and The Wardrobe: 7/10
  • Options
    king yrcanosking yrcanos Posts: 2,145
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    The Impossible Astronaut/Day of the Moon is the worst for me, but I know not many here will agree.
    I didn't enjoy those two episodes much either.
  • Options
    AbominationAbomination Posts: 6,483
    Forum Member
    The Impossible Astronaut/Day of the Moon is the worst for me, but I know not many here will agree.

    I'd agree with that, which is a real shame as it became so integral to the whole of Series 6. I just felt The Silence were disappointing, there was a distinct lack of resolution, it made all the episodes that followed it seem inferior and the finale was a single-story episode which meant we had an introduction over twice as long as the resolution.
  • Options
    Tiggs99Tiggs99 Posts: 279
    Forum Member
    The Eleventh Hour 8/10
    The Beast Below 4/10
    Victory of the Daleks 3/10
    The Time of Angels 6/10
    Flesh and Stone 6/10
    Vampires of Venice 7/10
    Amy's Choice 8/10
    The Hungry Earth 6/10
    Cold Blood 8/10
    Vincent and the Doctor 8/10
    The Lodger 9/10
    The Pandorica Opens 8/10
    The Big Bang 5/10

    A Christmas Carol 6/10

    The Impossible Astronaut: 9/10
    Day of the Moon: 8/10
    Curse of the Black Spot: 7/10
    The Doctor's Wife: 7/10
    The Rebel Flesh 7/10
    The Almost People: 7/10
    A Good Man Goes To War: 6/10
    Let's Kill Hitler 8/10
    Night Terrors: 5/10
    The Girl Who Waited: 10/10
    The God Complex: 5/10
    Closing Time: 2/10
    The Wedding of River Song 4/10

    The Doctor, The Widow and The Wardrobe: 6/10
  • Options
    bbll22bbll22 Posts: 527
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    The Eleventh Hour: 10/10
    The Beast Below: 8/10
    Victory of the Dalek:s 5/10
    The Time of Angels: 9/10
    Flesh and Stone: 9/10
    Vampires of Venice: 7/10
    Amy's Choice: 9/10
    The Hungry Earth: 8/10
    Cold Blood: 8/10
    Vincent and the Doctor: 9/10
    The Lodger: 7/10
    The Pandorica Opens: 10/10
    The Big Bang: 10/10

    A Christmas Carol: 9/10
    The Impossible Astronaut: 10/10
    Day of the Moon: 10/10
    Curse of the Black Spot: 7/10
    The Doctor's Wife: 9/10
    The Rebel Flesh: 7/10
    The Almost People: 7/10
    A Good Man Goes To War: 9/10
    Let's Kill Hitler: 9/10
    Night Terrors: 6/10
    The Girl Who Waited: 10/10
    The God Complex: 8/10
    Closing Time: 6/10
    The Wedding of River Song: 8/10

    The Doctor, The Widow and The Wardrobe: 7/10
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 55
    Forum Member
    I don't think the Matt Smith era has produced very good stories so far - the stories lack something - some episodes look a bit cheap (like the classic series) - although the stories are'nt the worst and the cast themselves are top notch particularly Matt Smith.
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 509
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    I just felt The Silence were disappointing,

    Why? What was wrong with them?
    there was a distinct lack of resolution

    Personally I thought the big reveal of 'You should kill us all on sight!" followed by the massive cinematic shoot-out in which all the bad guys die was a pretty good resolution. What else should there have been?
    it made all the episodes that followed it seem inferior

    Are you sure it's not just that Curse of the Black Spot just isn't very good? ;)
    and the finale was a single-story episode which meant we had an introduction over twice as long as the resolution.

    I agree that the finale should have been a two parter, but I'm not sure what's inherently wrong about having more build-up than resolution.

    Obviously I'm not saying you're wrong to have your opinion; that would be absurd. I just find it a bit unfathomable.
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 23
    Forum Member
    The Eleventh Hour 10/10
    The Beast Below 7/10
    Victory of the Daleks 5/10
    Time of the Angels 7/10
    Flesh and Stone 6/10
    Vampires of Venice 6/10
    Amy's Choice 9/10
    The Hungry Earth 6/10
    Cold Blood 7/10
    Vincent and the Doctor 8/10
    The Lodger 7/10
    The Pandorica Opens 9/10
    The Big Bang 9/10

    A Christmas Carol 2/10

    The Impossible Astronaut 9/10
    Day of the Moon 8/10
    The Curse of the Black Spot 8/10
    The Doctor's Wife 7/10
    The Rebel Flesh 6/10
    The Almost People 7/10
    A Good Man Goes to War 10/10
    Let's Kill Hitler 7/10
    Night Terrors 5/10
    The Girl Who Waited 10/10
    The God Complex 8/10
    Closing Time 6/10
    The Wedding of River Song 9/10

    The Doctor,The Widow and the Wardrobe 7/10
  • Options
    DavetheScotDavetheScot Posts: 16,623
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    Fire Host wrote: »
    Are you sure it's not just that Curse of the Black Spot just isn't very good? ;)

    I liked that far better than it really deserved just because it showed that the whole series wouldn't be like the opening two-parter.
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 24,080
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    my fave era of the show :)

    The Eleventh Hour: 10/10
    The Beast Below: 9/10
    Victory of the Daleks 8/10
    The Time of Angels: 10/10
    Flesh and Stone: 10/10
    Vampires of Venice: 8/10
    Amy's Choice: 10/10
    The Hungry Earth: 8/10
    Cold Blood: 9/10
    Vincent and the Doctor: 10/10
    The Lodger: 9/10
    The Pandorica Opens: 10/10
    The Big Bang: 10/10

    A Christmas Carol: 9/10
    The Impossible Astronaut: 10/10
    Day of the Moon: 10/10
    Curse of the Black Spot: 8/10
    The Doctor's Wife: 10/10
    The Rebel Flesh: 9/10
    The Almost People: 9/10
    A Good Man Goes To War: 10/10
    Let's Kill Hitler: 10/10
    Night Terrors: 8/10
    The Girl Who Waited: 10/10
    The God Complex: 9/10
    Closing Time: 9/10
    The Wedding of River Song: 10/10

    The Doctor, The Widow and The Wardrobe: 7/10
  • Options
    king yrcanosking yrcanos Posts: 2,145
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Sorry, but you voted too late. You can still rate the Patrick Troughton stories .
    Sorry.
  • Options
    bananashakebananashake Posts: 2,635
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Not sure if its to late to vote, but here's my vote anyway :L

    The Eleventh Hour 7/10
    The Beast Below 6/10
    Victory of the Daleks 5/10
    Time of the Angels 9/10
    Flesh and Stone 8/10
    Vampires of Venice 6/10
    Amy's Choice 7/10
    The Hungry Earth 6/10
    Cold Blood 7/10
    Vincent and the Doctor 0/10
    The Lodger 5/10
    The Pandorica Opens 9/10
    The Big Bang 8/10

    A Christmas Carol 3/10
    The Impossible Astronaut 9/10
    Day of the Moon 8/10
    The Curse of the Black Spot 5/10
    The Doctor's Wife 10/10
    The Rebel Flesh 7/10
    The Almost People 6/10
    A Good Man Goes to War 8/10
    Let's Kill Hitler 7/10
    Night Terrors 7/10
    The Girl Who Waited 9/10
    The God Complex 7/10
    Closing Time 8/10
    The Wedding of River Song 8/10
    The Doctor,The Widow and the Wadrobe 4/10
  • Options
    bigheatherbigheather Posts: 694
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    The Eleventh Hour 5/10
    The Beast Below 4/10
    Victory of the Daleks 7/10
    Time of the Angels 8/10
    Flesh and Stone 7/10
    Vampires of Venice 5/10
    Amy's Choice 5/10
    The Hungry Earth 2/10
    Cold Blood 2/10
    Vincent and the Doctor 10/10
    The Lodger 6/10
    The Pandorica Opens 10/10
    The Big Bang 9/10

    A Christmas Carol 7/10
    The Impossible Astronaut 8/10
    Day of the Moon 7/10
    The Curse of the Black Spot 6/10
    The Doctor's Wife 8/10
    The Rebel Flesh 2/10
    The Almost People 1/10
    A Good Man Goes to War 8/10
    Let's Kill Hitler 6/10
    Night Terrors 3/10
    The Girl Who Waited 9/10
    The God Complex 6/10
    Closing Time 5/10
    The Wedding of River Song 4/10

    The Doctor,The Widow and the Wadrobe 3/10
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 455
    Forum Member
    I can't rate them really, they all have something brilliant about them. Some more than others, granted, but naming them would just be picky!:p
Sign In or Register to comment.