Why have they pitched Ella so low??

Comments

• [Deleted User] Posts: 768

  Forum Member

  ✭✭

  27/10/12 - 21:12 #2

  Gave her a crap song as well

  0
• pepipop Posts: 4,099

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  27/10/12 - 21:12 #3

  Still, a classic performance.

  0
• XFactorFanatic1 Posts: 1,784

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  27/10/12 - 21:12 #4

  I agree. She's my favourite but I think that song was too big for her. I could only really see Melanie smashing that song. Weren't a keen fan on the arrangement.

  0
• [Deleted User] Posts: 151

  Forum Member

  ✭

  27/10/12 - 21:12 #5

  Agree. love that song, but her version sounded odd.

  0
• fluffybunyip Posts: 4,909

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  27/10/12 - 21:13 #6

  pepipop wrote: »

  Still, a classic performance.

  
  I don't agree, sorry. I think it was disappointing, she could've done it so much better.

  0
• lkhere Posts: 1,035

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  27/10/12 - 21:13 #7

  agreeing with Nicole there as was her weakest performance unfortunately

  0
• [Deleted User] Posts: 3,267

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  27/10/12 - 21:13 #8

  She has no range, no personality and no character. If it was higher she couldn't have reached that last note which is at the very top of her range.
  
  Emperor's New Clothes syndrome in absolutely full swing. She is DULL.

  0
• EvilLlamaThingy Posts: 6,667

  Forum Member

  ✭

  27/10/12 - 21:15 #9

  Honestly I'm guessing it was because they had to. I don't think they would have done it otherwise. It's a shame really.

  0
• shackfan Posts: 15,461

  Forum Member

  ✭✭

  27/10/12 - 21:15 #10

  PG30 wrote: »

  Gave her a crap song as well

  
  Totally disagree. Absolute classic.

  0
• [Deleted User] Posts: 151

  Forum Member

  ✭

  27/10/12 - 21:16 #11

  Silent Scream wrote: »

  She has no range, no personality and no character. If it was higher she couldn't have reached that last note which is at the very top of her range.
  
  Emperor's New Clothes syndrome in absolutely full swing. She is DULL.

  
  I am starting to agree that she is a bit one dimensional. An album of hers would be a load of samey tempo and pitch with a bit of growling chucked in. Disappointed as she was so promising.

  0
• abrightyz Posts: 24,559

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  27/10/12 - 21:16 #12

  agree with nicole. but love how gracious ella is...:)

  0
• rsefitpro07 Posts: 2,636

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  27/10/12 - 21:17 #13

  The high note at the end saved her, not my favourite of performances!. I get the fact she's 16! (it keeps being pointed out on the show?)

  0
• oxygenjj Posts: 18,290

  Forum Member

  ✭✭

  27/10/12 - 21:17 #14

  fluffybunyip wrote: »

  I don't agree, sorry. I think it was disappointing, she could've done it so much better.

  
  have to agree a missed opportunity

  0
• Glinny Posts: 4,426

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  27/10/12 - 21:17 #15

  The live shows have ruined her.
  
  Far, far better when she was in the auditions and she sang her own song. Thought she was a winner then but not anymore.
  
  Tulisa a good mentor - no don't think so.

  0
• andersonsonson Posts: 6,454

  Forum Member

  ✭

  27/10/12 - 21:19 #16

  Shes overrated

  0
• Scarlet O'Hara Posts: 6,933

  Forum Member

  ✭

  27/10/12 - 21:20 #17

  I agree with OP and Nicole, it was too low and gave her nowhere to go, which killed the song's epic, dramatic quality.
  
  On a more general note, I need to hear Ella control her voice a bit more now, not just welly out her power vocal throughout every song. We need to see that she can do 'soft' and restrain the vocal sometimes, tell a story, be light and dark, big and small. She's no Leona yet.

  0
• advid Posts: 609

  Forum Member

  ✭✭

  27/10/12 - 21:21 #18

  honkhonk wrote: »

  I am starting to agree that she is a bit one dimensional. An album of hers would be a load of samey tempo and pitch with a bit of growling chucked in. Disappointed as she was so promising.

  
  ...that's exactly what happened to Leona Lewis and her first album..too samey..
  Ella is the best female voice since Leona in my opinion...let's hope her first album (I'm sure she'll do one) is not too 'samey'...

  0