Mel B is the biggest flop... Ugh, can she just get away from X Factor, seriously She'll be the end of X Factor. How can the show be taken seriously with her as a judge? I'd rather just have Louis, Simon and Cheryl tbh.
They need a positive judge to complete the panel; you only need one overly harsh critique otherwise the show becomes laboured. The Australian panel works because all four judges can criticise without coming across as nasty - Simon cannot do this (or chooses not to) so he needs light-hearted accomplices to take away the sting.
Mel B is the biggest flop... Ugh, can she just get away from X Factor, seriously She'll be the end of X Factor. How can the show be taken seriously with her as a judge? I'd rather just have Louis, Simon and Cheryl tbh.
I don't think it'll be the end, she was arguably the star (against Geri) of the most successful girl group in history, that alone makes her qualified to judge a show based on The X Factor (if it were The Voice you'd have big point), Cheryl & Louis on the panel have taken all the creditability away from the show it had left (if it had any left that is)
Can't stand the sight of her. She is one of those people that five minutes is just about the toleration limit. The idea of her being on the series as a full time judge is just awful !!
Can't stand the sight of her. She is one of those people that five minutes is just about the toleration limit. The idea of her being on the series as a full time judge is just awful !!
Completely agree. She will ruin this series and ratings will be dire. I guarantee it.
Completely agree. She will ruin this series and ratings will be dire. I guarantee it.
She is a vile woman and I do not believe TV audiences will warm to her in the slightest. A big mouth who loves the sound of her own voice and with the exception of Geri, Posh, and Baby, the most fortunate former pop star on the planet.
Comments
She is good as a guest but as a full time judge you will be sick of her in 3 weeks
I've always liked her anyway so for me not an issue, can see how she is prob too much for others tho
I don't think it'll be the end, she was arguably the star (against Geri) of the most successful girl group in history, that alone makes her qualified to judge a show based on The X Factor (if it were The Voice you'd have big point), Cheryl & Louis on the panel have taken all the creditability away from the show it had left (if it had any left that is)
Completely agree. She will ruin this series and ratings will be dire. I guarantee it.
She is a vile woman and I do not believe TV audiences will warm to her in the slightest. A big mouth who loves the sound of her own voice and with the exception of Geri, Posh, and Baby, the most fortunate former pop star on the planet.