Do you think Christina would win X Factor?

Comments

• molybecks Posts: 14,553

  Forum Member

  ✭✭

  11/12/10 - 22:19 #2

  Yeah probably.
  
  She has such a huge poweful voice then when you see the little lady standing there with a very different look to what you'd expect her to sound like, it's very perculiar.
  
  Love the aggers

  0
• CMcKinley Posts: 3,980

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  11/12/10 - 22:21 #3

  ItsBritneyBitch wrote: »

  I think she would win it hands down.
  
  I mean if she hadn't already made it on her own.

  
  Depends who she was up against, there's plenty out there, past and present who would blow her off the stage.

  0
• wkdstepmother Posts: 6,563

  Forum Member

  ✭

  11/12/10 - 22:23 #4

  I really don't think she would. She has one of the best voices I have ever heard but she doesn't have the "likeability factor" LOL people would moan about how arrogant she is
  
  which of course demonstrates what a ridiculous competition it is

  0
• [Deleted User] Posts: 7,283

  Forum Member

  ✭

  11/12/10 - 22:24 #5

  She has an arrogance and diva like sense of style that makes me think.. no.

  0
• KieranDS Posts: 16,545

  Forum Member

  ✭✭

  11/12/10 - 22:25 #6

  I think she's great. She doesn't look like she could sing as well as she does.

  0
• gav016 Posts: 5,836

  Forum Member

  ✭

  11/12/10 - 22:26 #7

  I forgot how powerful and strong her voice was until tonight. She was incredible.

  0
• [Deleted User] Posts: 7,168

  Forum Member

  ✭

  11/12/10 - 22:26 #8

  no way....shes far to sexy, pretty, so what if she has a stunning voice, get her off!!!

  0
• ItsBritneyBitch Posts: 1,106

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  11/12/10 - 22:30 #9

  SummerRain wrote: »

  She has an arrogance and diva like sense of style that makes me think.. no.

  
  I thinkat arrogance and dive like sense has come from her worldwide mega stardom, if she hadn't of made it she would be likeable.

  0
• Anika Hanson Posts: 15,629

  Forum Member

  ✭✭

  11/12/10 - 22:30 #10

  CMcKinley wrote: »

  Depends who she was up against, there's plenty out there, past and present who would blow her of the stage.

  
  There is no-one in the present who could blow her off the stage. She is in a league of her own vocally in this generation. Only Mariah and Whitney and prehaps Celine would outsing her when they were in their prime.
  
  I think she would win easily.

  0
• [Deleted User] Posts: 7,283

  Forum Member

  ✭

  11/12/10 - 22:31 #11

  Anika Hanson wrote: »

  There is no-one present who could blow her off the stage. She is in a league of her own vocally in this generation. Only Mariah and Whitney and prehaps Celine would outsing her when they were in their prime.
  
  I think she would win easily.

  
  Beyonce?

  0
• Ash's Man Posts: 7,165

  Forum Member

  ✭

  11/12/10 - 22:31 #12

  She has an incredible voice, that is undeniable, but she wasn't great tonight IMO. I'm actually really let down because I rate Xtina and was expecting another Beyonce/Alexandra moment. Unfortunately, both of her performances were weak in different ways. Not impressed.

  0
• yawalloper Posts: 6,561

  Forum Member

  ✭

  11/12/10 - 22:32 #13

  No way...she'd get the same treatment as Danyl. (I think that was his name anyway)

  0
• Dix Posts: 79,142

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  11/12/10 - 22:35 #14

  ItsBritneyBitch wrote: »

  I think she would win it hands down.
  
  I mean if she hadn't already made it on her own.

  
  She would if she sang naked.

  0
• CMcKinley Posts: 3,980

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  11/12/10 - 22:39 #15

  Anika Hanson wrote: »

  There is no-one in the present who could blow her off the stage. She is in a league of her own vocally in this generation. Only Mariah and Whitney and prehaps Celine would outsing her when they were in their prime.
  
  I think she would win easily.

  
  Barbara Streisand
  Aretha Franklin
  Mariah Carey
  Randy Crawford
  Shirley Bassey
  Tina Turner
  Shania Twain
  Annie Lennox
  Agnetha Folkstog
  Tracy Chapman
  Tori Amos
  Leona Lewis
  Lady GaGa
  The Cheeky Girls
  
  How do you think she'd do? granted some are past

  0
• [Deleted User] Posts: 117

  Forum Member

  ✭

  11/12/10 - 22:40 #16

  she would hands down. never thought she was that increadible until tonight. but then i was like woww

  0
• blowup Posts: 1,850

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  11/12/10 - 22:43 #17

  Yes, I think she would win. I don't think being beautiful is always a handicap, but for those who think it is, well I consider her to have an attractive character face rather than obviously stunning.
  I think her voice is too good and she puts emotion into a song and people would vote for that.

  0
• floopy123 Posts: 6,003

  Forum Member

  ✭

  11/12/10 - 22:46 #18

  No cos she's American and us Brits wouldn't vote for a Yank to win!
  
  
  
  Shirley Bassey would easily rival Christina Ag-can'tspellhersurname for power!
  
  " I don't think being beautiful is always a handicap, "
  
  Yes, it must be terrible. Being born ugly is so much better.

  0
• ItsBritneyBitch Posts: 1,106

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  12/12/10 - 02:26 #19

  CMcKinley wrote: »

  Depends who she was up against, there's plenty out there, past and present who would blow her off the stage.

  
  Only Leona could match her.

  0