Amy 'simultaneously' pregnant
![[Deleted User]](https://wd.vanillicon.com/v2/d353a5e491085cb7b59bdc292f19f913.svg)
[Deleted User]
Posts: 509 Forum Member
✭✭
Was reading about Amy Pond on Wikipedia and it states that she's 'simultaneously' pregnant on the Doctor's scanner, which I took to meaning as she's both pregnant and non-pregnant at the same time? Is it possible that we're taking the scanner continually flashing 'pregnant' 'not pregnant' just meaning it's currently scanning for a result or could it be possible that Amy exists as pregnant and not pregnant at the same time?
Mind boggling I know lol.
Mind boggling I know lol.
0
Comments
2) I think it's that she's both. I still think it goes back to Idris being able to say things/ see things that would be in the future and thefore knows Amy will be pregnant soon but isn't yet, and gets confused.
Or events that make her pregnant (in her past) have not yet happened, and are therefore still in flux.
This makes more sense
Well, there was a large crack in it last year:D
The image on the scanner - the "X-ray" for want of a better description - never moves so it needn't be a real-time scan of Amy. What if it's a scan of the pregancy that gave rise to Amy? The one thing that might possibly point to that (apart from the potentially ambigous wording in the scanner) is the use of her full name "Amelia Pond". The Doctor has generally used "Amelia" to refer to young Amy and - despite the Doctor's semi-teasing habit of calling her and Rory "Pond", the Tardis ought to get it right.
Like I say - not really a serious suggestion but I have this idea that won't go away. The following is not something I know for a fact- just a theory - but I'll spoiler tag it because it might suggest an outcome for the series with a very big twist...
If you watch the scanner, it flashes between pregnant and not-pregnant slowly at first, then quickly. Then in The Rebel Flesh it follows the same pattern, but begins to slow down again, then speed up.
It is almost definitely showing the actual readings - not that it's currently scanning and has yet to come up with something. With the technology that makes up the TARDIS, it's very hard to imagine that a scan like that wouldn't come up with something instantly.
It is much more likely that the actual pregnancy is in flux because of some hither-to unknown action or recourse affecting the state of the unoverse, and that the fluctuating state of the pregnancy is an early clue (in my mind, the pregnancy is merely a macguffin that will be resolved, and is only a clue to the real happening itself).
nice theory
Ewww
That's a good idea which explains why the scanner is having trouble. It finds a positive and then forgets so carries on scanning.
My god, if one of those Silents can pull a girl like Amy there's hope for us all
Yea I wish lol. I'm gonna stick with it's two timelines running simultaneous to eachother. And if it turns out the doctor goo is the one to die on the beach then SM better get another job.
Well you know what they say, big fingers big.....:D
Without going into details - she'd know by now because young women generally get an all-clear every month.
Either she's not pregnant or she's keeping something secret.
i be so annoyed if thats the case:mad:
1. Amy/Amelia occupies two parallel universes at the same time - a result of living next to the crack for so long. In one universe she is pregnant - the other not pregnant. There´s something fishy about the way the Dr refers to her as Amy or Amelia on different occasions.
2. She is pregnant with a Silent baby which the Tardis sees in the scan then forgets - hence "Positive" and "Negative" results.
What Amy is a scientologist?
I agree , and she was with the silents for 4 days .
I started a thread (Amy's Pregnancy) on this possibility a while ago....
http://forums.digitalspy.co.uk/showthread.php?t=1473092&highlight=
She was Amelia when she was little and it may just be the same way that parents (and wives
I have my own theory on the scan and pregnancy - http://forums.digitalspy.co.uk/showthread.php?t=1480028