Options

If America had not been "discovered"

RubusRooRubusRoo Posts: 10,262
Forum Member
✭✭
& raped/destroyed/ethnically cleansed of its native population...

What it have become now?
«1

Comments

  • Options
    mathertronmathertron Posts: 30,083
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    We were trading with the natives long before columbus turned up.
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 11,934
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    Well, we wouldn't have any chips to go with our fish, or even tomato ketchup.
    Of course, vinegar is better, but I wouldn't fancy fish and parsnips.
  • Options
    The SnakesThe Snakes Posts: 8,940
    Forum Member
    How would it not have been "discovered"? You'd basically have to ask what would happen were we in Europe advanced enough to make ships capable of sailing that far. Because America is too large to miss once you start travelling the globe.
  • Options
    Richard46Richard46 Posts: 59,834
    Forum Member
    The Snakes wrote: »
    How would it not have been "discovered"? You'd basically have to ask what would happen were we in Europe advanced enough to make ships capable of sailing that far. Because America is too large to miss once you start travelling the globe.

    Your quite right, but I do always wonder how Japan China etc managed not to find Australia.
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 36,630
    Forum Member
    flobadob wrote: »
    Well, we wouldn't have any chips to go with our fish, or even tomato ketchup.
    Of course, vinegar is better, but I wouldn't fancy fish and parsnips.

    Chips were invented by the French apparently.

    It was on TV the other day :D
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 36,630
    Forum Member
    The Snakes wrote: »
    How would it not have been "discovered"? You'd basically have to ask what would happen were we in Europe advanced enough to make ships capable of sailing that far. Because America is too large to miss once you start travelling the globe.

    The Chinese, Indians, Japanese, Malaysian indigenous people were all sea faring yet they managed to miss a land mass the size of Australia.
  • Options
    LyricalisLyricalis Posts: 57,958
    Forum Member
    Richard46 wrote: »
    Your quite right, but I do always wonder how Japan China etc managed not to find Australia.

    We had better ships than they did until they got a chance to study Western ship designs. Japan built up a very impressive fleet for WW2 after all. Besides, there are plenty of places between Australia and Japan which would have been much more interesting at the time, but many were controlled by European powers.

    Did China and Japan have any great explorers? You hear a lot about European and US ones, but I can't recall hearing about any from that part of the world. India either. I'm sure they did have explorers at some point otherwise there would be no people there at all. There were also established trade routes between China and the Mediterranean region going back further than recorded history, and someone must have started those, though I guess it wouldn't have been recorded ;).
  • Options
    LyricalisLyricalis Posts: 57,958
    Forum Member
    The Chinese, Indians, Japanese, Malaysian indigenous people were all sea faring yet they managed to miss a land mass the size of Australia.

    Sailing south east is more difficult than sailing west I guess. Probably harder to navigate.
  • Options
    subversivesubversive Posts: 2,969
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    no casinos
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 36,630
    Forum Member
    Lyricalis wrote: »
    Sailing south east is more difficult than sailing west I guess. Probably harder to navigate.

    You could be right, perhaps ancient seafarers simply sailed the way the sun either rose or set.
  • Options
    NeilPostNeilPost Posts: 6,067
    Forum Member
    RubusRoo wrote: »
    & raped/destroyed/ethnically cleansed of its native population...

    What it have become now?

    It would have been raped/destroyed/ethnically cleansed of its native population by your choice of other possible empires who have come and gone

    - Chinese
    - Arab
    - Central and South american (presumably your axe grinding is restricted to USA/Canada)
    - Russian - They did afterall own alaska for years

    Perhaps downlaod the full set of Podcasts to date of the BBC's fantastic A History of the World in 100 Objects

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/podcasts/series/ahow

    and you might realise how shitty people have been to each other all over the world to each other since population's started to accumulate in larger settlements after mankind turned from Hunter/Gatherers to farmers, and a administrative/leadership function started to live of the backs of the masses below them - inventing bureaucracy and religion to shore up their positions.
  • Options
    adopteradopter Posts: 11,937
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    The Chinese, Indians, Japanese, Malaysian indigenous people were all sea faring yet they managed to miss a land mass the size of Australia.

    The Malaysians were trading with Australia well before the Europeans arrived.
  • Options
    PencilPencil Posts: 5,700
    Forum Member
    It would be like Africa or parts of Russia are today.
  • Options
    NeilPostNeilPost Posts: 6,067
    Forum Member
    flobadob wrote: »
    Well, we wouldn't have any chips to go with our fish, or even tomato ketchup.
    Of course, vinegar is better, but I wouldn't fancy fish and parsnips.

    Yes, it is hard to imagine what the world would be like without 'basics' like tomato, potato, chilli, sweetcorn (?) etc No **** either :-)

    No peanuts, pumpkin, Turkey, Chocolate :eek:, cranberries, blueberries, beans (parp!)

    On the flip side, the ethnic Indian's would still be walking everywhere, due to no indiginous Horses in the America's.
  • Options
    LyricalisLyricalis Posts: 57,958
    Forum Member
    adopter wrote: »
    The Malaysians were trading with Australia well before the Europeans arrived.

    And when we discovered it we decided it would make an excellent place to send criminals. I guess we weren't too impressed with the place to start with! Perhaps that's why no one else apart from the Aborigines settled there? We do after all seem to have had a disproportionate number of thieving gits, whether they were poor (and sent to prison) or rich (and given knighthoods) throughout our history.
  • Options
    LyricalisLyricalis Posts: 57,958
    Forum Member
    NeilPost wrote: »
    Yes, it is hard to imagine what the world would be like without 'basics' like tomato, potato, chilli, sweetcorn (?) etc No **** either :-)

    No peanuts, pumpkin, Turkey, Chocolate :eek:, cranberries, blueberries, beans (parp!)

    On the flip side, the ethnic Indian's would still be walking everywhere, due to no indiginous Horses in the America's.

    We'd all be slimmer too :D.
  • Options
    Finlay ReaderFinlay Reader Posts: 1,231
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    impossible to answer, you could say that america are the native population or at least what's left of them and mot the Only they have the answer and they ain't gonna give it out any time soon:D
  • Options
    RubusRooRubusRoo Posts: 10,262
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    NeilPost wrote: »
    It would have been raped/destroyed/ethnically cleansed of its native population by your choice of other possible empires who have come and gone

    - Chinese
    - Arab
    - Central and South american (presumably your axe grinding is restricted to USA/Canada)
    - Russian - They did afterall own alaska for years

    Perhaps downlaod the full set of Podcasts to date of the BBC's fantastic A History of the World in 100 Objects

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/podcasts/series/ahow

    and you might realise how shitty people have been to each other all over the world to each other since population's started to accumulate in larger settlements after mankind turned from Hunter/Gatherers to farmers, and a administrative/leadership function started to live of the backs of the masses below them - inventing bureaucracy and religion to shore up their positions.

    I have no axe as such to grind sir. However, I appreciate your insights. I hate all humans equally & without prejudice.
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 36,630
    Forum Member
    NeilPost wrote: »
    Yes, it is hard to imagine what the world would be like without 'basics' like tomato, potato, chilli, sweetcorn (?) etc No **** either :-)

    No peanuts, pumpkin, Turkey, Chocolate :eek:, cranberries, blueberries, beans (parp!)

    On the flip side, the ethnic Indian's would still be walking everywhere, due to no indiginous Horses in the America's.

    We'd also still have red squirrels :)
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 4,138
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Lyricalis wrote: »
    We had better ships than they did until they got a chance to study Western ship designs. Japan built up a very impressive fleet for WW2 after all. Besides, there are plenty of places between Australia and Japan which would have been much more interesting at the time, but many were controlled by European powers.

    Did China and Japan have any great explorers? You hear a lot about European and US ones, but I can't recall hearing about any from that part of the world. India either. I'm sure they did have explorers at some point otherwise there would be no people there at all. There were also established trade routes between China and the Mediterranean region going back further than recorded history, and someone must have started those, though I guess it wouldn't have been recorded ;).

    The chinese admiral Zheng He (died 1430's) is possibly the greatest naval explorer.
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 3,939
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    RubusRoo wrote: »
    & raped/destroyed/ethnically cleansed of its native population...

    What it have become now?
    First off when you say America are you referring to the USA or the entire Western hemisphere? Of course regardless of your definition it was Europeans (English, French, Portuguese, and especially the Spanish) who did the vast majority of the raping, destroying and ethnic cleansing (since the native population fell by 80% from 1492 to 1650).

    Of course the Americas (or at least Greenland and parts of Canada) had been 'discovered' by Europeans during the 11th century.
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 2,518
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    You wouldn't have any popular culture to worship...it's all about American movies...music...TV...fashion and why is that? Madonna and Lady Gaga would be unheard of (that would actually be a good thing) and you would have never seen all the TV programs you watch...movies or listen to the music....maybe you would invest more in your own culture...
  • Options
    LyricalisLyricalis Posts: 57,958
    Forum Member
    bugloss wrote: »
    The chinese admiral Zheng He (died 1430's) is possibly the greatest naval explorer.

    Thanks for that, looked him up on Wikipedia.
    Zheng He's first voyage consisted of a fleet of 317 treasure ships (other sources say 200 ships) holding almost 28,000 crewmen (each ship housing up to 500 men).

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zheng_He

    He wasn't messing about was he? :D
  • Options
    LyricalisLyricalis Posts: 57,958
    Forum Member
    Mojorisin' wrote: »
    You wouldn't have any popular culture to worship...it's all about American movies...music...TV...fashion and why is that? Madonna and Lady Gaga would be unheard of (that would actually be a good thing) and you would have never seen all the TV programs you watch...movies or listen to the music....maybe you would invest more in your own culture...

    It's not quite that simple. A lot of that culture comes from Europe and other parts of the world. The US provided a safe haven and land of opportunity for these people. The UK has also provided the same (though we shout about it less), and benefited from it.
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 4,138
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    the moral is -don't say the Chinese are rubbish at anything. They probably got bored at it, whatever it is, about 1000 years ago :D
Sign In or Register to comment.