Sexiest Musketeer?

saralund · 02/04/14 - 21:14

a) Aramis
b) Athos
c) d'Artagnan
d} Porthos

Espresso · 02/04/14 - 21:19

Porthos

Of this current incarnation, Porthos is my pick.

Aramis is far too pretty, D'Artagnan looks about 12 and Athos is a grump. Porthos has got that extra something very appealing about him.

Avi8 · 02/04/14 - 21:47

Athos

Athos all the way. I like a troubled soul and Tom Burke does a lovely understated stare.

Aramis is gorgeous too.

D'Artagnan - I'll leave for the younger set.

Porthos - OK but not my type.

Kapellmeister · 02/04/14 - 22:14

Aramis

Aramis, by a mile. Then D'Artagnan. They make a nice couple actually.

fleet · 02/04/14 - 23:10

d'Artagnan

I like all of them!! But picked D'Artagnan.

Demizdeeroolz · 02/04/14 - 23:23

Athos

Athos.

saralund · 03/04/14 - 22:44

Athos

Well, I'm surprised. I thought Aramis would walk it, even though I voted for Athos.

They all make the King look like Austin Powers...

Avi8 · 04/04/14 - 08:53

Athos

saralund wrote: »

Well, I'm surprised. I thought Aramis would walk it, even though I voted for Athos.

They all make the King look like Austin Powers...

The king has an endearing smile. I thought he was without a redeeming feature until the episode with the woman educating other women when he said 'Ninon is so very pretty I could listen to her nonsense all day' and then grinned like a schoolboy. It was sweet.

As for Aramis v Athos: yes, Aramis was my choice for most of the series because he is so handsome and his character is very witty and chivalrous, but Athos gets under your skin. I think in real life Aramis would be the sort you would meet at a party and go home with, but he wouldn't last long mainly because he would be after the next woman by the next party, whereas Athos would take time to get to know but would be faithful. And I bet he knows some interesting tricks in bed too.

LudwigVonDrake · 04/04/14 - 09:10

Aramis

Kapellmeister wrote: »

Aramis, by a mile. Then D'Artagnan. They make a nice couple actually.

Couldn't agree more!

ValW · 04/04/14 - 11:12

Tom Burke's buffed up from the nerdy part he played in I Want Candy!

Tiggywink · 04/04/14 - 16:21

Aramis

Kapellmeister wrote: »

Aramis, by a mile. Then D'Artagnan. They make a nice couple actually.

Same for me - sometimes I can't decide between them - they are both so yummy..

Tiggywink · 04/04/14 - 16:24

Aramis

Nothing really to do with fancying but as we are talking about them - I see it like this:

d'Artagnan loves only one woman
Porthos loves who he can get - for a short while
Aramis loves all women
Athos cannot love again - he is porbably the biggest challenge

rachelgata · 04/04/14 - 16:27

d'Artagnan

i don't really watch it, I watched the first episode that's all, but have always liked Santiago Cabrera - is he Aramis? He is ridiculously good looking, in an obvious way. However, if it's sexiness we are talking about I would go for Luke Pasqualino - d'Artagnan if I remember right. I'm old enough to be his mother but who cares

Valerian · 04/04/14 - 18:00

I simply couldn't choose between them. I'll have to take them all

:D

Howardessex · 04/04/14 - 18:18

d'Artagnan

D Artagnan is Number 1 , with Aramis second . Surprised to see DArtagnan not doing so well in the poll , thought he would be way out front : (

Clarkie66 · 04/04/14 - 20:18

Aramis

Aramis is gorgeous with a lovely twinkle in his eye

mrprosser · 04/04/14 - 20:21

Dogtanian was the sexiest!

jabegy · 04/04/14 - 22:26

Athos

Athos for me, Tom Burke is gorgeous

[Deleted User] · 04/04/14 - 23:18

Athos

Avi8 wrote: »

Athos all the way. I like a troubled soul and Tom Burke does a lovely understated stare.

Aramis is gorgeous too.

D'Artagnan - I'll leave for the younger set.

Porthos - OK but not my type.

This to a tee!! (Avi, I seem to recall we used to agree on everything Merlin-related too!)

Avi8 · 04/04/14 - 23:33

Athos

MrsGeneHunt wrote: »

This to a tee!! (Avi, I seem to recall we used to agree on everything Merlin-related too!)

Hello! Glad you agreed with me here. We are twins separated at birth.

towers · 05/04/14 - 10:31

d'Artagnan

Avi8 wrote: »

Athos all the way. I like a troubled soul and Tom Burke does a lovely understated stare.

Aramis is gorgeous too.

D'artagnan - I'll leave for the younger set.

Porthos - OK but not my type.

It's D'artagnan for me and I'm a 37 year old woman, Lol.

Athos comes second.

I think Aramis and Porthas are handsome but I don't fancy them.

Avi8 · 05/04/14 - 11:34

Athos

towers wrote: »

It's D'artagnan for me and I'm a 37 year old woman, Lol.

Regretably for me, that makes you the younger set towers.

;-)

towers · 05/04/14 - 12:24

d'Artagnan

Howardessex wrote: »

D Artagnan is Number 1 , with Aramis second . Surprised to see DArtagnan not doing so well in the poll , thought he would be way out front : (

Luke is a pretty and sexy guy but probably just too young for many women, give him another 5 years - and a moustache - and he could be very handsome indeed.

towers · 05/04/14 - 12:27

d'Artagnan

Avi8 wrote: »

Regretably for me, that makes you the younger set towers. ;-)

That's nice to know, Lol

I'm actually 36 but just four weeks away from being 37 and I've felt 37 for about two months now......

xNATILLYx · 05/04/14 - 18:59

Porthos

aww not enough porthos love - something about him.

never got the obsession with Luke Pasquelino (sp?) i dont find tom burke attractive and santiago is ok but i dont go for conventional attractive guys i like something a bit different

Hey there!

Quick Links

Sexiest Musketeer?

Which Musketeer do you fancy most? 56 votes

Comments