Rank The Doctors
doctorwhofancal
Posts: 24,123 Forum Member
✭✭✭
Give every doctor a score out of 10, then I will find an average so we can have a Leaderboard.
*Please only post if you have seen at least 5 of the doctors.
William Hartnell (1st Doctor)
Patrick Troughton (2nd Doctor)
Jon Pertwee (3rd Doctor)
Tom Baker (4th Doctor)
Peter Davison (5th Doctor)
Colin Baker (6th Doctor)
Sylvester McCoy (7th Doctor)
Paul McGann (8th Doctor)
Christopher Eccleston (9th Doctor)
David Tennant (10th Doctor)
Matt Smith (11th Doctor)
*Please only post if you have seen at least 5 of the doctors.
William Hartnell (1st Doctor)
Patrick Troughton (2nd Doctor)
Jon Pertwee (3rd Doctor)
Tom Baker (4th Doctor)
Peter Davison (5th Doctor)
Colin Baker (6th Doctor)
Sylvester McCoy (7th Doctor)
Paul McGann (8th Doctor)
Christopher Eccleston (9th Doctor)
David Tennant (10th Doctor)
Matt Smith (11th Doctor)
0
Comments
Patrick Troughton 9/10
Jon Pertwee 10/10
Tom Baker 10/10
Peter Davison 9/10
Colin Baker 8/10
Sylvester McCoy 8.5/10
Paul McGann 5.5/10
Christopher Eccleston 8.5/10
David Tennant 10/10
Matt Smith 7/10
Patrick Troughton 7/10 (a good successor to Hartnell)
Jon Pertwee 5/10 (not bad in the role, but I'm not very keen on his era)
Tom Baker 10/10 (has to be top marks for Tom)
Peter Davison 9/10 (many of my favourite stories are in his era)
Colin Baker 4/10 (Nah!)
Sylvester McCoy 8/10 (generally underrated imo)
Paul McGann 9/10 (he's brilliant in the audios)
Christopher Eccleston 8/10 (ideal choice for the relaunch)
David Tennant 7/10 (good, but not great in the role)
Matt Smith 9/10 (an inspired choice)
Troughton 10/10
Pertwee 8/10
T Baker 10/10
Davison 8/10
C Baker 6/10
McCoy 7/10
McGann 8/10
Ecclestone 8/10
Tennant 8/10
Smith 10/10
Oh and just for a mention I'll give Peter Cushing a 7/10. (i know, I know).
Patrick Troughton 8/10
Jon Pertwee 7/10
Tom Baker 10/10
Peter Davison 9/10
Colin Baker 7/10
Sylvester McCoy 4/10
Paul McGann 7/10
Christopher Eccleston 9/10
David Tennant 8/10
Matt Smith 8/10
Troughton 9/10
Pertwee. 10/10
Baker T. 10/10
Davison. 7/10
Baker C. 5/10
McCoy. 3.5/10
McGann. 6.5/10
Eccleston. 7.5/10
Tennant. 7/10
Smith. 7/10
Patrick Troughton 9/10
Jon Pertwee- 4/10
Tom Baker- 9/10
Peter Davison 10/10
Colin Baker 9/10
Sylvester McCoy 8/10
Paul McGann 9/10
Christopher Eccleston 3/10
David Tennant 9/10
Matt Smith 9/10
Patrick Troughton- 10/10
Jon Pertwee- 8/10
Tom Baker- 4/10
Peter Davison- 6/10
Colin Baker- 8/10
Sylvester McCoy- 9/10
Paul McGann- 2/10
Christopher Eccleston- 6/10
David Tennant- 9/10
Matt Smith- 8/10
Troughton 9/10 (My personal favourite of the Classics)
Pertwee 7/10 (OK)
T.Baker 9/10 (Born for the role)
Davison 7/10 (OK)
C.Baker 7/10 (OK)
McCoy 7/10 (OK)
McGann 8/10 (Very good - love the audios)
Eccleston 6/10 (Tried hard to look as if he liked it)
Tennant 10/10 (The best Doctor of all time, ever. 10/10 quite apt, as well as deserved.
Smith 9/10 (Another one born for it)
Patrick Troughton 9/10
Jon Pertwee 9/10
Tom Baker 9/10
Peter Davison 7/10
Colin Baker 6/10
Sylvester McCoy 5/10
Paul McGann 8/10
Christopher Eccleston 8/10
David Tennant 9/10
Matt Smith 9/10
Patrick Troughton 9/10
Jon Pertwee 9/10
Tom Baker 9/10
Peter Davison 6/10
Colin Baker 6/10
Sylvester McCoy 5/10
Paul McGann 6/10
Christopher Eccleston 8/10
David Tennant 7/10
Matt Smith 9/10
Patrick Troughton - 10/10
Jon Pertwee - 7/10
Tom Baker - 9/10
Peter Davison - 6/10
Colin Baker - 4/10
Sylvester McCoy - 8/10
Paul McGann - 6/10
Christopher Eccleston - 4/10
David Tennant - 7/10
Matt Smith - 8/10
Patrick Troughton 8/10
Jon Pertwee 9/10
Tom Baker 10/10
Peter Davison 8/10
Colin Baker 5/10
Sylvester McCoy 4/10
Paul McGann 7/10
Christopher Eccleston 9/10
David Tennant 7/10
Matt Smith 9/10
Troughton: 10
Pertwee: 10
T. Bakkersby: 10
Davison: 2
C.Baker: 6
McCoy: 7
McGann: 8
Ecclestone: 6
Tendon: 4
Smith: 10
Patrick Troughton 9/10
Jon Pertwee 7/10
Tom Baker 8/10
Peter Davison 9/10
Colin Baker 4/10
Sylvester McCoy 7/10
Paul McGann 6/10
Christopher Eccleston 9/10
David Tennant 7/10
Matt Smith 10/10
Troughton 8
Pertwee 8
Baker 10
Davison 7
Baker 9
McCoy 7
McGann 9
Eccleston 6
Tennant 6
Smith 1
Patrick Troughton 9/10
Jon Pertwee 7/10
Tom Baker 8/10
Peter Davison 9/10
Colin Baker 6/10
Sylvester McCoy 7/10
Paul McGann 8/10
Chris Eccleston 9/10
David Tennant 8/10
Matt Smith 10/10
Patrick Troughton 9/10
Jon Pertwee 7/10
Tom Baker 8/10
Peter Davison 10/10
Colin Baker 5/10
Sylvester McCoy 6/10
Paul McGann 7/10
Christopher Eccleston 7/10
David Tennant 8/10
Matt Smith 8/10
eta: too late - but at least I added my opinion!
Patrick Troughton (2nd Doctor) 2/10
Jon Pertwee (3rd Doctor) 1/10
Tom Baker (4th Doctor) 10/10
Peter Davison (5th Doctor) 4/10
Colin Baker (6th Doctor) 3/10
Sylvester McCoy (7th Doctor) 8/10
Paul McGann (8th Doctor) 1/10
Christopher Eccleston (9th Doctor) 10/10
David Tennant (10th Doctor) 9.9/10
Matt Smith (11th Doctor) 9.9/10
William Hartnell: 8/10 (nice grandfather figure)
Patrick Troughton: 9/10 (A funny, safe 'uncle' figure)
Jon Pertwee: 5/10 (Nice character, but a bit bland and serious)
Tom Baker: 8/10 (Fun, alienesque, loud and brash!)
Peter Davison: 8/10 (Pleasant, jolly and vulnerable)
Colin Baker: 7/10 (Comical, dramatic and very vane!)
Sylvestor McCoy: 6/10 (Clown to start with, too mysterious by the end! Didn't seem 'friendly' enough)
Paul McGann: 6/10 (Nice new Doctor - but not enough time)
Chris Ecclestone: 8/10 (Brilliant comeback in 2005)
David Tennant: 10/10 (Brilliant regen. from Chris, and he boosted it further!)
Matt Smith: 7/10 (Loved the alien quirkiness - but it's wearing a bit thin now!) In fact might I be bold as to say - that is NOT acting!! He does the same mannersims when he is interviewed!
Patrick Troughton (2nd Doctor) 10/10
Jon Pertwee (3rd Doctor) 5/10
Tom Baker (4th Doctor) 10/10
Peter Davison (5th Doctor) 8/10
Colin Baker (6th Doctor) 6/10
Sylvester McCoy (7th Doctor) 8/10
Paul McGann (8th Doctor) 6/10
Christopher Eccleston (9th Doctor) 10/10
David Tennant (10th Doctor) 7/10
Matt Smith (11th Doctor) 10/10
Summary: I like Doctors.
and so say all of us...:D
or, to quote The Brig
"splendid fellows, all of them"
Patrick Troughton 10/10
Jon Pertwee 10/10
Tom Baker 10/10
Peter Davison 10/10
Colin Baker 10/10
Sylvester McCoy 10/10
Paul McGann 10/10
Christopher Eccleston 10/10
David Tennant 10/10
Matt Smith 10/10
What?