I don't like her. She is a bully. She did it with Wagner years ago .she did it with Raine this year and because she doesn't like Louis, she is picking on his acts. her behaviour on this show as a very well paid judge irritates me
I don't mind her, if you watch the show then we are all going to get peed off with one or the other of the judges as everyone's taste is different and they are not always going to support the act you like.
I don't like her. She is a bully. She did it with Wagner years ago .she did it with Raine this year and because she doesn't like Louis, she is picking on his acts. her behaviour on this show as a very well paid judge irritates me
Lbr, Wagner was undeserving of his place. Raign attracted negative criticism from 90% of the people watching the show, not just Cheryl. The only difference being that she was simply in the position to act upon it.. As for the last claim, both the boybands are/were all style & no substance, Blonde Electra don't even need an explanation, and Cheryl likes Only The Young.
I like her, I think a lot of people who have always disliked her are going to vote they like her less now, when in reality there feelings are probably unchanged.
I like her more just for her honesty. She gets what makes an act stand out as an artist. There's a heavy dollop of misogyny in the views the majority have on her I feel, a majority of the hatred, and it is hatred, really isn't warranted.
I love her and Mel and to suggest she is a worse judge or "meaner" that the rest is laughable.
Lbr, Wagner was undeserving of his place. Raign attracted negative criticism from 90% of the people watching the show, not just Cheryl. The only difference being that she was simply in the position to act upon it.. As for the last claim, both the boybands are/were all style & no substance, Blonde Electra don't even need an explanation, and Cheryl likes Only The Young.
I am referring to the situation with Wagner where Cheryl referred to a backstage situation when judging his performance which I felt to be really unprofessional at the time. I don't disagree that Wagner should have gone earlier than he did but people voted for him and that is a separate issue.
In regards to Raine, it was obvious that Cheryl didnt like it when Raine told her that she was only interested in Simon's opinion and can completely understand why she said no at the time. But she kept it as a grudge and surely as a judge, should have given constructive feedback that Raine needed to work on her attitude as she had the voice and creativity there rather than turn her head every time Raine appeared on stage
Cheryl criticised all Louis's acts tonight and fair enough, is her opinion, but interesting that it has also been reported that she doesn't like Louis either and look how she reacted when she was dropped from US Xfactor
In my opinion, therefore, I don't rate her as a judge and think they should get rid of her off the panel and maybe donate her salary to the midwives on the NHS
I think Simon likes to hold a grudge until he can act on it.
The whole episode with Raign was created and edited to make Cheryl look bad.
The Kermit comments are this year's version of Barlow's scripted "**** breath" comment in 2012 to undermine Tulisa.
I've never been a fan of Cheryl as I don't like the whole style over substance nature of her music. But I like Cowell less as he is a truly unsavoury character.
Maybe the "Opinion hasn't changed" should be split into "liked her before & opinion hasn't changed" and Didn't like her before & opinion hasn't changed".
I've always disliked her. She's only where she is because of her looks, and not because of any kind of talent. Fair play to her for being in the right place at the right time. I find her very unlikeable though and hard to warm to.
I don't know. She seems to be offering more constructive criticism this year, but on the other hand, she seems a bit more reserved, like she can't really be bothered.
i like her the same or more.
Mel B seems to have had a big impact on Cheryl she's more opinionated not holding back as more as she would. Her and Mel are teaming up against Simon sometimes. I've agreed with all of what Cheryl has said tonight she's been right.
Comments
Lbr, Wagner was undeserving of his place. Raign attracted negative criticism from 90% of the people watching the show, not just Cheryl. The only difference being that she was simply in the position to act upon it.. As for the last claim, both the boybands are/were all style & no substance, Blonde Electra don't even need an explanation, and Cheryl likes Only The Young.
I love her and Mel and to suggest she is a worse judge or "meaner" that the rest is laughable.
I am referring to the situation with Wagner where Cheryl referred to a backstage situation when judging his performance which I felt to be really unprofessional at the time. I don't disagree that Wagner should have gone earlier than he did but people voted for him and that is a separate issue.
In regards to Raine, it was obvious that Cheryl didnt like it when Raine told her that she was only interested in Simon's opinion and can completely understand why she said no at the time. But she kept it as a grudge and surely as a judge, should have given constructive feedback that Raine needed to work on her attitude as she had the voice and creativity there rather than turn her head every time Raine appeared on stage
Cheryl criticised all Louis's acts tonight and fair enough, is her opinion, but interesting that it has also been reported that she doesn't like Louis either and look how she reacted when she was dropped from US Xfactor
In my opinion, therefore, I don't rate her as a judge and think they should get rid of her off the panel and maybe donate her salary to the midwives on the NHS
Still think she is not a 'genuine' person
I will never forgive her for the way she treated wagner :-D
I thought she was spot on about Jay James and Only The Young tonight, I don't get what the other judges were on about.
The whole episode with Raign was created and edited to make Cheryl look bad.
The Kermit comments are this year's version of Barlow's scripted "**** breath" comment in 2012 to undermine Tulisa.
I've never been a fan of Cheryl as I don't like the whole style over substance nature of her music. But I like Cowell less as he is a truly unsavoury character.
Mel B seems to have had a big impact on Cheryl she's more opinionated not holding back as more as she would. Her and Mel are teaming up against Simon sometimes. I've agreed with all of what Cheryl has said tonight she's been right.