Options

102 Episodes of Nu-Who: Rate Them All

2»

Comments

  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 6,988
    Forum Member
    Rose - 3
    The End of the World - 2
    The Unquiet Dead - 3
    Aliens of London - 1
    World War Three - 1
    Dalek - 4
    The Long Game - 1
    Father's Day - 4
    The Empty Child - 5
    The Doctor Dances - 4
    Boom Town - 3
    Bad Wolf - 4
    The Parting of the Ways - 5

    The Christmas Invasion - 3

    New Earth - 2
    Tooth and Claw - 2
    School Reunion - 3
    The Girl in the Fireplace - 5
    Rise of the Cybermen - 2
    The Age of Steel - 2
    The Idiot's Lantern - 2
    The Impossible Planet - 4
    The Satan Pit - 4
    Love & Monsters - 1
    Fear Her - 1
    Army of Ghosts - 3
    Doomsday - 4

    The Runaway Bride - 3

    Smith and Jones - 3
    The Shakespeare Code - 3
    Gridlock - 3
    Daleks in Manhattan - 2
    Evolution of the Daleks - 2
    The Lazarus Experiment - 3
    42 - 2
    Human Nature - 5
    The Family of Blood - 5
    Blink - 5
    Utopia - 5
    The Sound of Drums - 4
    Last of the Time Lords - 1

    Voyage of the Damned - 1

    Partners in Crime - 4
    The Fires of Pompeii - 3
    Planet of the Ood - 3
    The Sontaran Stratagem - 2
    The Poison Sky - 2
    The Doctor's Daughter - 2
    The Unicorn and the Wasp - 3
    Silence in the Library - 5
    Forest of the Dead - 5
    Midnight - 5
    Turn Left - 5
    The Stolen Earth - 4
    Journey's End - 3

    The Next Doctor - 2
    Planet of the Dead - 2
    The Waters of Mars - 4
    The End of Time: Part One - 3
    The End of Time: Part Two - 2

    The Eleventh Hour - 5
    The Beast Below - 3
    Victory of the Daleks - 2
    The Time of Angels - 5
    Flesh and Stone - 5
    The Vampires of Venice - 3
    Amy's Choice - 5
    The Hungry Earth - 3
    Cold Blood - 3
    Vincent and the Doctor - 5
    The Lodger - 3
    The Pandorica Opens - 5
    The Big Bang - 4

    A Christmas Carol - 4

    The Impossible Astronaut - 5
    Day of the Moon - 4
    The Curse of the Black Spot - 2
    The Doctor's Wife - 5
    The Rebel Flesh - 3
    The Almost People - 3
    A Good Man Goes To War - 4
    Let's Kill Hitler - 4
    Night Terrors - 3
    The Girl Who Waited - 5
    The God Complex - 3
    Closing Time - 3
    The Wedding of River Song - 4

    The Doctor, The Widow and the Wardrobe - 3

    Asylum of the Daleks - 5
    Dinosaurs on a Spaceship - 2
    A Town Called Mercy - 2
    The Power of Three - 3
    The Angels Take Manhattan - 5
    The Snowmen - 4
    The Bells of Saint John - 4
    The Rings of Akhaten - 3
    Cold War - 4
    Hide - 4
    Journey to the Centre of the Tardis - 3
    The Crimson Horror - 4
    Nightmare in Silver - 3
    The Name of the Doctor - 5

    If I could give 0 then Last of the Timelords and Voyage of the Damned would get them
  • Options
    November_RainNovember_Rain Posts: 9,145
    Forum Member
    Rose - 4
    The End of the World - 3
    The Unquiet Dead - 4
    Aliens of London - 1
    World War Three - 1
    Dalek - 5
    The Long Game - 2
    Father's Day - 5
    The Empty Child - 4
    The Doctor Dances - 4
    Boom Town - 2
    Bad Wolf - 5
    The Parting of the Ways - 5

    The Christmas Invasion - 2

    New Earth - 2
    Tooth and Claw - 3
    School Reunion - 4
    The Girl in the Fireplace - 3
    Rise of the Cybermen - 4
    The Age of Steel - 4
    The Idiot's Lantern - 3
    The Impossible Planet - 4
    The Satan Pit - 4
    Love & Monsters - 1
    Fear Her - 1
    Army of Ghosts - 4
    Doomsday - 4

    The Runaway Bride - 2

    Smith and Jones - 3
    The Shakespeare Code - 3
    Gridlock - 4
    Daleks in Manhattan - 2
    Evolution of the Daleks - 2
    The Lazarus Experiment - 1
    42 - I don't remember this one so can't comment.
    Human Nature - 4
    The Family of Blood - 4
    Blink - 5
    Utopia - 5
    The Sound of Drums - 5
    Last of the Time Lords - 4

    Voyage of the Damned - 3

    Partners in Crime - 2
    The Fires of Pompeii - 4
    Planet of the Ood - See 42
    The Sontaran Stratagem - 4
    The Poison Sky - 4
    The Doctor's Daughter - 1
    The Unicorn and the Wasp - 3
    Silence in the Library - 5
    Forest of the Dead - 5
    Midnight - 5
    Turn Left - 5
    The Stolen Earth - 5
    Journey's End - 4

    The Next Doctor - 1
    Planet of the Dead - 3
    The Waters of Mars - 5
    The End of Time: Part One - 1
    The End of Time: Part Two - 2

    The Eleventh Hour - 3
    The Beast Below - 3
    Victory of the Daleks - 2
    The Time of Angels - 3
    Flesh and Stone - 3
    The Vampires of Venice - 3
    Amy's Choice - 4
    The Hungry Earth - 3
    Cold Blood - 3
    Vincent and the Doctor - 4
    The Lodger - 4
    The Pandorica Opens - 4
    The Big Bang - 4

    A Christmas Carol - 4

    The Impossible Astronaut - 4
    Day of the Moon - 4
    The Curse of the Black Spot - 4
    The Doctor's Wife - 4
    The Rebel Flesh - 3
    The Almost People - 3
    A Good Man Goes To War - 3
    Let's Kill Hitler - 2
    Night Terrors - 3
    The Girl Who Waited - 4
    The God Complex - 5
    Closing Time - 4
    The Wedding of River Song - 4

    The Doctor, The Widow and the Wardrobe - 2

    Asylum of the Daleks - 4
    Dinosaurs on a Spaceship - 3
    A Town Called Mercy - 4
    The Power of Three - 3
    The Angels Take Manhattan - 4
    The Snowmen - 4
    The Bells of Saint John - 4
    The Rings of Akhaten - 2
    Cold War - 5
    Hide - 4
    Journey to the Centre of the Tardis - 3
    The Crimson Horror - 4
    Nightmare in Silver - 2
    The Name of the Doctor - 3

    My memories a bit hazy about half of the above and I found it quite difficult to rate on a strict 1 to 5 basis, so those are to be taken with a pinch of salt.
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 3
    Forum Member
    Rose - 3
    The End of the World - 3
    The Unquiet Dead - 5
    Aliens of London - 2
    World War Three - 3
    Dalek - 5
    The Long Game - 4
    Father's Day - 4
    The Empty Child - 4
    The Doctor Dances - 4
    Boom Town - 3
    Bad Wolf - 4
    The Parting of the Ways - 4

    The Christmas Invasion - 4

    New Earth - 3
    Tooth and Claw - 5
    School Reunion - 4
    The Girl in the Fireplace - 5
    Rise of the Cybermen - 3
    The Age of Steel - 3
    The Idiot's Lantern - 2
    The Impossible Planet - 5
    The Satan Pit - 5
    Love & Monsters - 2
    Fear Her - 1
    Army of Ghosts - 5
    Doomsday - 5

    The Runaway Bride - 3

    Smith and Jones - 3
    The Shakespeare Code - 3
    Gridlock - 3
    Daleks in Manhattan - 2
    Evolution of the Daleks - 2
    The Lazarus Experiment - 2
    42 - 3
    Human Nature - 5
    The Family of Blood - 5
    Blink - 5
    Utopia - 5
    The Sound of Drums - 4
    Last of the Time Lords - 3

    Voyage of the Damned - 2

    Partners in Crime - 4
    The Fires of Pompeii - 5
    Planet of the Ood - 5
    The Sontaran Stratagem - 3
    The Poison Sky - 3
    The Doctor's Daughter - 3
    The Unicorn and the Wasp - 4
    Silence in the Library - 4
    Forest of the Dead - 4
    Midnight - 5
    Turn Left - 4
    The Stolen Earth - 4
    Journey's End - 3

    The Next Doctor - 2
    Planet of the Dead - 4
    The Waters of Mars - 4
    The End of Time: Part One - 3
    The End of Time: Part Two - 3

    The Eleventh Hour - 5
    The Beast Below - 3
    Victory of the Daleks - 3
    The Time of Angels - 5
    Flesh and Stone - 5
    The Vampires of Venice - 3
    Amy's Choice - 4
    The Hungry Earth - 3
    Cold Blood - 3
    Vincent and the Doctor - 2
    The Lodger - 3
    The Pandorica Opens - 5
    The Big Bang - 5

    A Christmas Carol - 5

    The Impossible Astronaut - 5
    Day of the Moon - 5
    The Curse of the Black Spot - 3
    The Doctor's Wife - 4
    The Rebel Flesh - 4
    The Almost People - 4
    A Good Man Goes To War - 5
    Let's Kill Hitler - 5
    Night Terrors - 3
    The Girl Who Waited - 5
    The God Complex - 3
    Closing Time - 3
    The Wedding of River Song - 4

    The Doctor, The Widow and the Wardrobe - 2

    Asylum of the Daleks - 5
    Dinosaurs on a Spaceship - 5
    A Town Called Mercy - 3
    The Power of Three - 3
    The Angels Take Manhattan - 4
    The Snowmen - 4
    The Bells of Saint John - 3
    The Rings of Akhaten - 3
    Cold War - 4
    Hide - 4
    Journey to the Centre of the Tardis - 5
    The Crimson Horror - 3
    Nightmare in Silver - 2
    The Name of the Doctor -5
  • Options
    gboygboy Posts: 4,989
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Rose - 4
    The End of the World - 3
    The Unquiet Dead - 4
    Aliens of London - 2
    World War Three - 3
    Dalek - 5
    The Long Game - 3
    Father's Day - 4
    The Empty Child - 4
    The Doctor Dances - 4
    Boom Town - 2
    Bad Wolf - 4
    The Parting of the Ways - 4

    The Christmas Invasion - 5

    New Earth - 2
    Tooth and Claw - 5
    School Reunion - 4
    The Girl in the Fireplace - 4
    Rise of the Cybermen - 4
    The Age of Steel - 5
    The Idiot's Lantern - 3
    The Impossible Planet - 5
    The Satan Pit - 5
    Love & Monsters - 2
    Fear Her - 1
    Army of Ghosts - 4
    Doomsday - 4

    The Runaway Bride - 4

    Smith and Jones - 4
    The Shakespeare Code - 4
    Gridlock - 3
    Daleks in Manhattan - 3
    Evolution of the Daleks - 2
    The Lazarus Experiment - 4
    42 - 4
    Human Nature - 4
    The Family of Blood - 4
    Blink - 5
    Utopia - 4
    The Sound of Drums - 4
    Last of the Time Lords - 4

    Voyage of the Damned - 5

    Partners in Crime - 4
    The Fires of Pompeii - 5
    Planet of the Ood - 5
    The Sontaran Stratagem - 4
    The Poison Sky - 4
    The Doctor's Daughter - 3
    The Unicorn and the Wasp - 5
    Silence in the Library - 4
    Forest of the Dead - 5
    Midnight - 5
    Turn Left - 4
    The Stolen Earth - 4
    Journey's End - 4

    The Next Doctor - 2
    Planet of the Dead - 4
    The Waters of Mars - 5
    The End of Time: Part One - 4
    The End of Time: Part Two - 4

    The Eleventh Hour - 4
    The Beast Below - 3
    Victory of the Daleks - 1
    The Time of Angels - 4
    Flesh and Stone - 4
    The Vampires of Venice - 3
    Amy's Choice - 3
    The Hungry Earth - 4
    Cold Blood - 4
    Vincent and the Doctor - 4
    The Lodger - 2
    The Pandorica Opens - 4
    The Big Bang - 4

    A Christmas Carol - 4

    The Impossible Astronaut - 5
    Day of the Moon - 5
    The Curse of the Black Spot - 2
    The Doctor's Wife - 2
    The Rebel Flesh - 3
    The Almost People - 4
    A Good Man Goes To War - 4
    Let's Kill Hitler - 4
    Night Terrors - 4
    The Girl Who Waited - 4
    The God Complex - 3
    Closing Time - 1
    The Wedding of River Song - 4

    The Doctor, The Widow and the Wardrobe - 3

    Asylum of the Daleks - 5
    Dinosaurs on a Spaceship - 3
    A Town Called Mercy - 4
    The Power of Three - 1
    The Angels Take Manhattan - 4
    The Snowmen - 4
    The Bells of Saint John - 4
    The Rings of Akhaten - 2
    Cold War - 4
    Hide - 5
    Journey to the Centre of the Tardis - 4
    The Crimson Horror - 4
    Nightmare in Silver - 4
    The Name of the Doctor -4
  • Options
    dancing.queendancing.queen Posts: 14,090
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    Rose - 2
    The End of the World - 4
    The Unquiet Dead - 1
    Aliens of London - 2
    World War Three - 3
    Dalek - 5
    The Long Game - 1
    Father's Day - 5
    The Empty Child - 3
    The Doctor Dances - 2
    Boom Town - 2
    Bad Wolf - 4
    The Parting of the Ways - 4

    Series as a whole: 3

    The Christmas Invasion - 2

    New Earth - 3
    Tooth and Claw - 2
    School Reunion - 4
    The Girl in the Fireplace - 1
    Rise of the Cybermen - 3
    The Age of Steel - 4
    The Idiot's Lantern - 3
    The Impossible Planet - 3
    The Satan Pit - 3
    Love & Monsters - 1
    Fear Her - 1
    Army of Ghosts - 4
    Doomsday - 5

    Series as a whole: 3

    The Runaway Bride - 5

    Smith and Jones - 1
    The Shakespeare Code - 1
    Gridlock - 4
    Daleks in Manhattan - 1
    Evolution of the Daleks - 1
    The Lazarus Experiment - 1
    42 - 3
    Human Nature - 1
    The Family of Blood - 1
    Blink - 4
    Utopia - 2
    The Sound of Drums - 3
    Last of the Time Lords - 3

    Series as a whole: 2

    Voyage of the Damned - 1

    Partners in Crime - 5
    The Fires of Pompeii - 2
    Planet of the Ood - 4
    The Sontaran Stratagem - 4
    The Poison Sky - 4
    The Doctor's Daughter - 1
    The Unicorn and the Wasp - 2
    Silence in the Library - 4
    Forest of the Dead - 5
    Midnight - 3
    Turn Left - 5
    The Stolen Earth - 5
    Journey's End - 5

    Series as a whole: 5

    The Next Doctor - 1

    Planet of the Dead - 5
    The Waters of Mars - 2
    The End of Time: Part One - 2
    The End of Time: Part Two - 4

    The Eleventh Hour - 5
    The Beast Below - 2
    Victory of the Daleks - 1
    The Time of Angels - 3
    Flesh and Stone - 4
    The Vampires of Venice - 2
    Amy's Choice - 5
    The Hungry Earth - 1
    Cold Blood - 1
    Vincent and the Doctor - 3
    The Lodger - 2
    The Pandorica Opens - 4
    The Big Bang - 5

    Series as a whole: 4

    A Christmas Carol - 1 (I still to this day have no clue what was going on in this episode)

    The Impossible Astronaut - 4
    Day of the Moon - 5
    The Curse of the Black Spot - 2
    The Doctor's Wife - 2
    The Rebel Flesh - 2
    The Almost People - 2
    A Good Man Goes To War - 5
    Let's Kill Hitler - 3
    Night Terrors - 4
    The Girl Who Waited - 5
    The God Complex - 2
    Closing Time - 4
    The Wedding of River Song - 5

    Series as a whole: 3

    The Doctor, The Widow and the Wardrobe - 3

    Asylum of the Daleks - 5
    Dinosaurs on a Spaceship - 4
    A Town Called Mercy - 2
    The Power of Three - 4
    The Angels Take Manhattan - 5
    The Snowmen - 5
    The Bells of Saint John - 5
    The Rings of Akhaten - 1
    Cold War - 2
    Hide - 1
    Journey to the Centre of the Tardis - 3
    The Crimson Horror - 2
    Nightmare in Silver - 1
    The Name of the Doctor - 5

    Series as a whole: 4
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 1,546
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Rose - 4
    The End of the World - 4
    The Unquiet Dead - 3
    Aliens of London - 3
    World War Three - 3
    Dalek - 4
    The Long Game - 2
    Father's Day - 5
    The Empty Child - 4
    The Doctor Dances - 4
    Boom Town - 5
    Bad Wolf - 3
    The Parting of the Ways - 5

    Average - 3.76

    The Christmas Invasion - 3

    New Earth - 4
    Tooth and Claw - 2
    School Reunion - 5
    The Girl in the Fireplace - 4
    Rise of the Cybermen - 3
    The Age of Steel - 3
    The Idiot's Lantern - 4
    The Impossible Planet - 4
    The Satan Pit - 5
    Love & Monsters - 5
    Fear Her - 0
    Army of Ghosts - 3
    Doomsday - 4

    Average - 3.14

    The Runaway Bride - 5

    Smith and Jones - 3
    The Shakespeare Code - 2
    Gridlock - 3
    Daleks in Manhattan - 1
    Evolution of the Daleks - 1
    The Lazarus Experiment - 2
    42 - 4
    Human Nature - 5
    The Family of Blood - 5
    Blink - 4
    Utopia - 5
    The Sound of Drums - 5
    Last of the Time Lords - 4

    Average 3.71

    Voyage of the Damned - 4

    Partners in Crime - 5
    The Fires of Pompeii - 3
    Planet of the Ood - 3
    The Sontaran Stratagem - 4
    The Poison Sky - 4
    The Doctor's Daughter - 3
    The Unicorn and the Wasp - 5
    Silence in the Library - 4
    Forest of the Dead - 4
    Midnight - 5
    Turn Left - 5
    The Stolen Earth - 5
    Journey's End - 5

    Average 4.21

    The Next Doctor - 3
    Planet of the Dead - 3
    The Waters of Mars - 3
    The End of Time: Part One - 4
    The End of Time: Part Two - 4

    Average 3.4


    The Eleventh Hour - 4
    The Beast Below - 1
    Victory of the Daleks - 2
    The Time of Angels - 2
    Flesh and Stone - 2
    The Vampires of Venice - 1
    Amy's Choice - 2
    The Hungry Earth - 1
    Cold Blood - 1
    Vincent and the Doctor - 1
    The Lodger - 5
    The Pandorica Opens - 4
    The Big Bang - 3

    Average 2.23

    A Christmas Carol - 2

    The Impossible Astronaut - 5
    Day of the Moon - 5
    The Curse of the Black Spot - 1
    The Doctor's Wife - 5
    The Rebel Flesh - 1
    The Almost People - 1
    A Good Man Goes To War - 3
    Let's Kill Hitler - 3
    Night Terrors - 5
    The Girl Who Waited - 1
    The God Complex - 1
    Closing Time - 5
    The Wedding of River Song - 4

    Average 3

    The Doctor, The Widow and the Wardrobe - 1

    Asylum of the Daleks - 4
    Dinosaurs on a Spaceship - 3
    A Town Called Mercy - 1
    The Power of Three - 5
    The Angels Take Manhattan - 3
    The Snowmen - 3
    The Bells of Saint John - 5
    The Rings of Akhaten - 0
    Cold War - 4
    Hide - 2
    Journey to the Centre of the Tardis - 1
    The Crimson Horror - 5
    Nightmare in Silver - 3
    The Name of the Doctor - 5

    Average 3.21
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 9
    Forum Member
    Rose - 3
    The End of the World - 3
    The Unquiet Dead - 4
    Aliens of London - 2
    World War Three - 2
    Dalek - 4
    The Long Game - 3
    Father's Day - 3
    The Empty Child - 4
    The Doctor Dances - 4
    Boom Town - 2
    Bad Wolf - 4
    The Parting of the Ways - 5

    The Christmas Invasion - 5

    New Earth - 3
    Tooth and Claw - 3
    School Reunion - 4
    The Girl in the Fireplace - 4
    Rise of the Cybermen - 3
    The Age of Steel - 4
    The Idiot's Lantern - 2
    The Impossible Planet - 5
    The Satan Pit - 5
    Love & Monsters - 1
    Fear Her - 1
    Army of Ghosts - 4
    Doomsday - 5

    The Runaway Bride - 5

    Smith and Jones - 3
    The Shakespeare Code - 3
    Gridlock - 3
    Daleks in Manhattan - 2
    Evolution of the Daleks - 2
    The Lazarus Experiment - 2
    42 - 3
    Human Nature - 2
    The Family of Blood - 2
    Blink - 5
    Utopia - 5
    The Sound of Drums - 5
    Last of the Time Lords - 4

    Voyage of the Damned - 3

    Partners in Crime - 4
    The Fires of Pompeii - 4
    Planet of the Ood - 3
    The Sontaran Stratagem - 3
    The Poison Sky - 3
    The Doctor's Daughter - 4
    The Unicorn and the Wasp - 5
    Silence in the Library - 4
    Forest of the Dead - 4
    Midnight - 5
    Turn Left - 5
    The Stolen Earth - 5
    Journey's End - 5

    The Next Doctor - 3
    Planet of the Dead - 4
    The Waters of Mars - 4
    The End of Time: Part One - 4
    The End of Time: Part Two - 5

    The Eleventh Hour - 4
    The Beast Below - 3
    Victory of the Daleks - 3
    The Time of Angels - 5
    Flesh and Stone - 3
    The Vampires of Venice - 4
    Amy's Choice - 4
    The Hungry Earth - 3
    Cold Blood - 3
    Vincent and the Doctor - 4
    The Lodger - 4
    The Pandorica Opens - 4
    The Big Bang - 5

    A Christmas Carol - 4

    The Impossible Astronaut - 5
    Day of the Moon - 4
    The Curse of the Black Spot - 2
    The Doctor's Wife - 4
    The Rebel Flesh - 3
    The Almost People - 3
    A Good Man Goes To War - 4
    Let's Kill Hitler - 3
    Night Terrors - 3
    The Girl Who Waited - 4
    The God Complex - 2
    Closing Time - 3
    The Wedding of River Song - 5

    The Doctor, The Widow and the Wardrobe - 1

    Asylum of the Daleks - 4
    Dinosaurs on a Spaceship - 2
    A Town Called Mercy - 3
    The Power of Three - 4
    The Angels Take Manhattan - 3
    The Snowmen - 5
    The Bells of Saint John - 5
    The Rings of Akhaten - 3
    Cold War - 4
    Hide - 4
    Journey to the Centre of the Tardis - 4
    The Crimson Horror - 3
    Nightmare in Silver - 4
    The Name of the Doctor -5
  • Options
    dancing.queendancing.queen Posts: 14,090
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    I think this is a really good way to see a group of peoples views on each episode. For example, I for one loved Power of Three, but looking at a lot of these it seems everyone else hated it. :D
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 9
    Forum Member
    I think this is a really good way to see a group of peoples views on each episode. For example, I for one loved Power of Three, but looking at a lot of these it seems everyone else hated it. :D

    I loved it too! My boyfriend hates it, says it's too slow, and I agree the ending was a bit of a disappointment but still - the rest outweighed that, I think! :)
  • Options
    TRT1968TRT1968 Posts: 2,166
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    I loved it too! My boyfriend hates it, says it's too slow, and I agree the ending was a bit of a disappointment but still - the rest outweighed that, I think! :)
    The slow pace and the humour was great. But then the ridiculous ending... 0 to 120 in zero seconds. The storyline equivalent of whiplash.
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 9
    Forum Member
    TRT1968 wrote: »
    The slow pace and the humour was great. But then the ridiculous ending... 0 to 120 in zero seconds. The storyline equivalent of whiplash.

    Yeah, I agree there. Was an interesting way of seeing how the Doctor interacts with normality! Perhaps it would have been better as a 2 parter?
  • Options
    dancing.queendancing.queen Posts: 14,090
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    Yeah, I agree there. Was an interesting way of seeing how the Doctor interacts with normality! Perhaps it would have been better as a 2 parter?

    Yes! Perhaps 'The Waiting Game' followed by 'The Power of Three'. The ending let the episode down for a lot of people, but it's still one of my favourites.
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 9
    Forum Member
    Yes! Perhaps 'The Waiting Game' followed by 'The Power of Three'. The ending let the episode down for a lot of people, but it's still one of my favourites.

    That's an awesome idea! I think, to be honest, the main reason I don't like 7A in general as much is because I loved both series 6 and 7B, so it got sandwiched between two great series imo.
  • Options
    Whovian1109Whovian1109 Posts: 1,812
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Rose - 3
    The End of the World - 3
    The Unquiet Dead - 3
    Aliens of London - 3
    World War Three - 3
    Dalek - 4
    The Long Game - 2
    Father's Day - 2
    The Empty Child - 3
    The Doctor Dances - 3
    Boom Town - 3
    Bad Wolf - 4
    The Parting of the Ways - 4

    The Christmas Invasion - 3

    New Earth - 3
    Tooth and Claw - 3
    School Reunion - 3
    The Girl in the Fireplace - 3
    Rise of the Cybermen - 3
    The Age of Steel - 4
    The Idiot's Lantern - 2
    The Impossible Planet - 3
    The Satan Pit - 4
    Love & Monsters - 2
    Fear Her - 2
    Army of Ghosts - 4
    Doomsday - 5

    The Runaway Bride - 3

    Smith and Jones - 3
    The Shakespeare Code - 3
    Gridlock - 3
    Daleks in Manhattan - 3
    Evolution of the Daleks - 3
    The Lazarus Experiment - 3
    42 - 4
    Human Nature - 3
    The Family of Blood - 4
    Blink - 3
    Utopia - 5
    The Sound of Drums - 3
    Last of the Time Lords - 3

    Voyage of the Damned - 2

    Partners in Crime - 3
    The Fires of Pompeii - 3
    Planet of the Ood - 3
    The Sontaran Stratagem - 4
    The Poison Sky - 4
    The Doctor's Daughter - 3
    The Unicorn and the Wasp - 2
    Silence in the Library - 4
    Forest of the Dead - 5
    Midnight - 4
    Turn Left - 3
    The Stolen Earth - 3
    Journey's End - 2

    The Next Doctor - 2
    Planet of the Dead - 3
    The Waters of Mars - 4
    The End of Time: Part One - 2
    The End of Time: Part Two - 2

    The Eleventh Hour - 5
    The Beast Below - 4
    Victory of the Daleks - 3
    The Time of Angels - 5
    Flesh and Stone - 5
    The Vampires of Venice - 4
    Amy's Choice - 3
    The Hungry Earth - 3
    Cold Blood - 3
    Vincent and the Doctor - 3
    The Lodger - 3
    The Pandorica Opens - 5
    The Big Bang - 5

    A Christmas Carol - 4

    The Impossible Astronaut - 5
    Day of the Moon - 5
    The Curse of the Black Spot - 3
    The Doctor's Wife - 3
    The Rebel Flesh - 3
    The Almost People - 4
    A Good Man Goes To War - 3
    Let's Kill Hitler - 5
    Night Terrors - 2
    The Girl Who Waited - 4
    The God Complex - 4
    Closing Time - 3
    The Wedding of River Song - 5

    The Doctor, The Widow and the Wardrobe - 1

    Asylum of the Daleks - 5
    Dinosaurs on a Spaceship - 4
    A Town Called Mercy - 2
    The Power of Three - 4
    The Angels Take Manhattan - 5
    The Snowmen - 4
    The Bells of Saint John - 4
    The Rings of Akhaten - 4
    Cold War - 3
    Hide - 5
    Journey to the Centre of the Tardis - 5
    The Crimson Horror - 2
    Nightmare in Silver - 3
    The Name of the Doctor - 5
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 1,003
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    I think this is a really good way to see a group of peoples views on each episode. For example, I for one loved Power of Three, but looking at a lot of these it seems everyone else hated it. :D

    I loved it too, especially when I rewatched it after The Angels Take Manhattan. Yes, not one of my favorite ever resolutions there at the end, but I never felt like that was the point of the episode. For me the point of the episode was the relationship between the Doctor and the Ponds and the way he deals with the normalcy of every day life and IMO it delivered very well there. (just as it did with Kate Stewart).
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 26
    Forum Member
    5 = Great
    4 = Good
    3 = Average
    2 = Poor
    1 = Bad

    Rose - 4
    The End of the World - 3
    The Unquiet Dead - 4
    Aliens of London - 3
    World War Three - 3
    Dalek - 5
    The Long Game - 3
    Fathers Day - 4
    The Empty Child - 5
    The Doctor Dances - 5
    Boom Town - 3
    Bad Wolf - 5
    The Parting of the Ways - 5

    The Christmas Invasion - 4

    New Earth - 2
    Tooth and Claw - 3
    School Reunion - 4
    The Girl In the Fireplace - 5
    Rise of the Cybermen - 4
    The Age of Steel - 4
    The Idiots Lantern - 3
    The Impossible Planet - 5
    The Saturn Pit - 5
    Love and Monsters - 2
    Fear Her - 3
    Army of Ghosts - 5
    Doomsday 5

    The Runaway Bride - 3


    Smith and Jones - 4
    The Shakespeare Code - 4
    Gridlock - 4
    Daleks In Manhattan - 3
    Evolution of the Daleks - 3
    The Lazarus Experiment - 3
    42 - 4
    Human Nature - 5
    The Family of Blood - 5
    Blink - 5
    Utopia - 4
    The Sound of Drums - 5
    Last of the Time Lords - 4

    Voyage of the Dammed - 3

    Partners In Crime - 3
    The Fires of Pompeii - 4
    Planet of the Ood - 4
    The Sontaran Stratagem - 4
    The Poison Sky - 4
    The Doctor’s Daughter - 2
    The Unicorn and the Wasp - 4
    Silence In the Library - 5
    Forest of the Dead - 5
    Midnight - 5
    Turn Left - 5
    The Stolen Earth - 3
    Journeys End - 3

    The Next Doctor - 3
    Planet of the Dead - 3
    The Waters of Mars - 5
    The End of Time Part 1 - 3
    The End of Time Part 2 - 4

    The Eleventh Hour - 5
    The Beast Below - 2
    Victory of the Daleks - 3
    The Time of Angles - 4
    Flesh and Stone - 3
    The Vampires of Venice - 3
    Amy’s Choice - 5
    The Hungry Earth - 3
    Cold Blood - 4
    Vincent and the Doctor - 5
    The Lodger - 4
    The Pandorica Opens - 4
    The Big Bang - 5

    A Christmas Carol - 4

    The Impossible Astronaut - 5
    Day of the Moon - 4
    The Curse of the Black Spot - 2
    The Doctor’s Wife - 5
    The Rebel Flesh - 3
    The Almost People - 3
    A Good Man Goes to War - 5
    Lets Kill Hitler - 3
    Night Terrors - 3
    The Girl Who Waited - 5
    The Good Complex - 4
    Closing Time - 4
    The Wedding of River Song - 3

    The Doctor the Window and the Wardrobe - 2

    Asylum of the Daleks - 3
    Dinosaurs on a Spaceship - 2
    A Town Called Mercy - 3
    The Power of Three - 4
    The Angles Take Manhattan - 3
    The Snowmen - 3
    The Bells of Saint John - 4
    The Rings of Akaten - 3
    Cold War - 3
    Hide - 4
    Journey to the Center of the TARDIS - 2
    The Crimson Horror - 3
    Nightmare In Silver - 3
    The Name of the Doctor - 4

    Series Rankings Best to Worse
    1: Series 3
    2: Series 4
    3: Series 5
    4: Series 1
    5: Series 6
    6: Series 2
    7: Series 7
  • Options
    AbominationAbomination Posts: 6,483
    Forum Member
    Okay, you can probably tell I need a job or a hobby or something :p I've spent a few hours across today putting together some statistics from all the responses on this thread so far. :) Hope this is of interest to at least somebody... I never want to see the "%" symbol again :p

    Episode List
    Primarily, I added all the scores together and figured out percentage-based averages for each episode. Many episodes carry the same score as each other, though to figure out which of those would be placed above the other, I went through and found out which episodes had the most "5's" in their results. This list contains no draws, and is (I hope) an accurate listing of all 102 episodes from our combined favourite through to the episodes that were bred to die a horrible death :D

    THE 34 CLASSICS
    001 The Name of the Doctor (Series 7, 93.10%)
    002 Blink (Series 3, 91.72%)
    003 Midnight (Series 4, 90.34%)
    004 The Empty Child (Series 1, 90.34%)
    005 The Doctor Dances (Series 1, 88.97%)
    006 Forest of the Dead (Series 3, 88.28%)
    007 The Family of Blood (Series 3, 87.59%)
    008 The Pandorica Opens (Series 5, 87.59%)
    009 Silence in the Library (Series 4, 87.59%)
    010 The Parting of the Ways (Series 1, 86.90%)
    011 Human Nature (Series 3, 86.90%)
    012 Turn Left (Series 4, 86.21%)
    013 Asylum of the Daleks (Series 7, 86.21%)
    014 Dalek (Series 1, 86.21%)
    015 The Doctor's Wife (Series 6, 85.52%)
    016 The Satan Pit (Series 2, 85.00%)
    017 The Impossible Planet (Series 2, 84.29%)
    018 The Big Bang (Series 5, 83.45%)
    019 The Girl in the Fireplace (Series 2, 83.45%)
    020 Vincent and the Doctor (Series 5, 82.76%)
    021 The Eleventh Hour (Series 5, 82.76%)
    022 The Waters of Mars (Specials, 82.76%)
    023 The Impossible Astronaut (Series 6, 82.07%)
    024 Utopia (Series 3, 82.07%)
    025 Day of the Moon (Series 6, 81.38%)
    026 The Stolen Earth (Series 4, 80.69%)
    027 The Angels Take Manhattan (Series 7, 80.69%)
    028 Doomsday (Series 2, 80.00%)
    029 The Time of Angels (Series 5, 80.00%)
    030 Amy's Choice (Series 5, 77.93%)
    031 Father's Day (Series 1, 77.93%)
    032 Bad Wolf (Series 1, 77.24%)
    033 The Snowmen (Series 7, 76.55%)
    034 School Reunion (Series 2, 75.86%)

    THE MIDDLE GROUND 34
    035 The Unicorn and the Wasp (Series 4, 75.71%)
    036 The Girl Who Waited (Series 6, 75.17%)
    037 Hide (Series 7, 74.48%)
    038 Gridlock (Series 3, 74.48%)
    039 The Sound of Drums (Series 3, 74.48%)
    040 The Bells of Saint John (Series 7, 74.48%)
    041 Flesh and Stone (Series 5, 73.79%)
    042 The Crimson Horror (Series 7, 73.79%)
    043 Partners in Crime (Series 4, 73.79%)
    044 Journey's End (Series 4, 73.10%)
    045 Army of Ghosts (Series 2, 73.10%)
    046 The Fires of Pompeii (Series 4, 72.41%)
    047 Planet of the Ood (Series 4, 72.14%)
    048 A Good Man Goes to War (71.72%)
    049 The Lodger (Series 5, 71.72%)
    050 The Christmas Invasion (Series 2, 71.03%)
    051 The Wedding of River Song (71.03%)
    052 The Sontaran Stratagem (Series 4, 71.03%)
    053 The Unquiet Dead (Series 1, 70.35%)
    054 The Poison Sky (Series 4, 71.03%)
    055 The Runaway Bride (Series 3, 68.57%)
    056 The Power of Three (Series 7, 68.28%)
    057 The God Complex (Series 6, 67.59%)
    058 The Shakespeare Code (Series 3, 67.59%)
    059 Rose (Series 1, 67.59%)
    060 Let's Kill Hitler (Series 6, 66.90%)
    061 Cold War (Series 7, 66.90%)
    062 Smith and Jones (Series 3, 66.90%)
    063 42 (Series 3, 65.71%)
    064 Tooth and Claw (Series 2, 65.52%)
    065 Dinosaurs on a Spaceship (Series 7, 64.83%)
    066 A Christmas Carol (Series 6, 64.14%)
    067 Last of the Time Lords (Series 3, 64.14%)
    068 The Age of Steel (Series 2, 64.14%)

    THE POOR 34
    069 The End of the World (Series 1, 64.14%)
    070 Journey to the Centre of the Tardis (Series 7, 63.45%)
    071 Closing Time (Series 6, 62.76%)
    072 Rise of the Cybermen (Series 2, 62.07%)
    073 Boom Town (Series 1, 61.38%)
    074 The End of Time: Part Two (Specials, 60.00%)
    075 The Vampires of Venice (Series 5, 60.00%)
    076 Planet of the Dead (Specials, 59.31%)
    077 A Town Called Mercy (Series 7, 59.31%)
    078 Nightmare in Silver (Series 7, 58.62%)
    079 The Beast Below (Series 5, 58.62%)
    080 Night Terrors (Series 6, 57.93%)
    081 The Rings of Akhaten (Series 7, 57.14%)
    082 Voyage of the Damned (Series 4, 56.43%)
    083 The Almost People (Series 6, 55.86%)
    084 Cold Blood (Series 5, 55.17%)
    085 The Doctor's Daughter (Series 4, 55.17%)
    086 The End of Time: Part One (Specials, 53.79%)
    087 The Hungry Earth (Series 5, 53.79%)
    088 New Earth (Series 2, 53.79%)
    089 The Rebel Flesh (Series 6, 52.41%)
    090 The Curse of the Black Spot (Series 6, 51.72%)
    091 The Idiot's Lantern (Series 2, 51.72%)
    092 The Next Doctor (Specials, 49.29%)
    093 The Long Game (Series 1, 48.26%)
    094 Victory of the Daleks (Series 5, 47.59%)
    095 World War Three (Series 1, 47.50%)
    096 Daleks in Manhattan (Series 3, 46.90%)
    097 The Lazarus Experiment (Series 3, 46.21%)
    098 Aliens of London (Series 1, 45.52%)
    099 Evolution of the Daleks (Series 3, 44.83%)
    100 The Doctor, The Widow and the Wardrobe (Series 7, 41.43%)
    101 Love & Monsters (Series 2, 39.31%)
    102 Fear Her (Series 2, 33.57%)


    Series Opener Ranking
    The opening stories from each series, in order of popularity. An average figure was worked out for Series 6 to accommodate the opening two-parter.

    1st - Asylum of the Daleks (Series 7) [86.21%]
    2nd - The Eleventh Hour (Series 5) [82.76%]
    3rd - The Impossible Astronaut / Day of the Moon (Series 6) [81.72%]
    4th - Partners in Crime (Series 4) [73.79%]
    5th - Rose (Series 1) [67.59%]
    6th - Smith and Jones (Series 3) [66.90%]
    7th - New Earth (Series 2) [53.79%]



    Series Finale Rankings
    The finale stories from each series, in order of popularity. Averages have been figured out to accommodate the two-part stories.

    1st - The Name of the Doctor (Series 7) [93.10%]
    2nd - The Pandorica Opens / The Big Bang (Series 5) [85.52%]
    3rd - Bad Wolf / The Parting of the Ways (Series 1) [82.07%]
    4th - The Stolen Earth / Journey's End (Series 4) [76.90%]
    5th - Army of Ghosts / Doomsday (Series 2) [76.55%]
    6th - The Wedding of River Song (Series 6) [71.03%]
    7th - The Sound of Drums / Last of the Time Lords (Series 3) [69.31%]
    8th - The End of Time (Specials) [56.90%]



    Christmas Special Rankings
    The Christmas specials, in order of popularity.

    1st - The Snowmen (Series 7) [76.55%]
    2nd - The Christmas Invasion (Series 2) [71.03%]
    3rd - The Runaway Bride (Series 3) [68.57%]
    4th - A Christmas Carol (Series 6) [64.14%]
    5th - Voyage of the Damned (Series 4) [56.43%]
    6th - The End of Time: Part 1 (Specials) [53.79%]
    7th - The Next Doctor (Specials) [49.29%]
    8th - The Doctor, The Widow and the Wardrobe (Series 7) [41.43]


    Series Overall Rankings
    The collective results for each series, excluding Christmas specials and ranked in order of average popularity.

    1st - Series 4 [76.75%]
    2nd - Series 7 [70.87%*]
    3rd - Series 5 [70.40%]
    4th - Series 1 [70.18%]
    5th - Series 3 [69.19%]
    6th - Series 6 [67.85%]
    7th - Series 2 [65.52%]
    8th - Specials [61.03%]

    *Series 7 result with The Snowmen included is 71.27%


    Accolades: Episodes to not score a single "5"
    Episodes that would just never be considered the cream of the crop...
    The End of the World
    Aliens of London
    World War Three
    The Long Game
    New Earth
    The Idiot's Lantern
    Fear Her
    Daleks in Manhattan
    Evolution of the Daleks
    The Lazarus Experiment
    The Doctor's Daughter
    The Next Doctor
    The End of Time: Part 1
    The Beast Below
    Victory of the Daleks
    The Hungry Earth
    Cold Blood
    The Doctor, The Widow and the Wardrobe


    Accolades: Episodes not to score a single "1"
    Episodes of all levels of quality, but never sink into the pits of unwatchable hell...
    Rose
    Dalek
    Father's Day
    The Empty Child
    The Doctor Dances
    Bad Wolf
    The Parting of the Ways
    The Christmas Invasion
    School Reunion
    The Impossible Planet
    The Satan Pit
    The Runaway Bride
    Gridlock
    Blink
    The Sound of Drums
    Partners in Crime
    The Sontaran Stratagem
    The Poison Sky
    The Unicorn and the Wasp
    Silence in the Library
    Forest of the Dead
    Midnight
    Turn Left
    The Waters of Mars
    The Eleventh Hour
    The Time of Angels
    Flesh and Stone
    Amy's Choice
    The Pandorica Opens
    The Big Bang
    The Doctor's Wife
    Dinosaurs on a Spaceship
    The Bells of Saint John
    Cold War
    The Name of the Doctor
  • Options
    AbominationAbomination Posts: 6,483
    Forum Member
    Okay, bored again :p
    Anyone up for the same thing with Torchwood? I imagine this could be quite interesting, though I expect a lull near Miracle Day :p
    If anyone is interested in this, we'll keep it at the same 1-5 scale as before :)

    Everything Changes -
    Day One -
    Ghost Machine -
    Cyberwoman -
    Small Worlds -
    Countrycide -
    Greeks Bearing Gifts -
    They Keep Killing Suzie -
    Random Shoes -
    Out of Time -
    Combat -
    Captain Jack Harkness -
    End of Days -

    Kiss, Kiss, Bang, Bang -
    Sleeper -
    To The Last Man -
    Meat -
    Adam -
    Reset -
    Dead Man Walking -
    A Day in the Death -
    Something Borrowed -
    From Out of the Rain -
    Adrift -
    Fragments -
    Exit Wounds -

    Children of Earth: Day One -
    Children of Earth: Day Two -
    Children of Earth: Day Three -
    Children of Earth: Day Four -
    Children of Earth: Day Five -

    Miracle Day: The New World -
    Miracle Day: Rendition -
    Miracle Day: Dead of Night -
    Miracle Day: Escape to LA -
    Miracle Day: The Categories of Life -
    Miracle Day: The Middle Men -
    Miracle Day: Immortal Sins -
    Miracle Day: End of the Road -
    Miracle Day: The Gathering -
    Miracle Day: The Blood Line -
Sign In or Register to comment.