Home› Doctor Who
Click here to check out Digital Spy's Doctor Who section for the latest breaking news, rumours and updates.
Options

Digital Spy Forum's Supposedly Favourite Doctor Who story

steven1977steven1977 Posts: 3,968
Forum Member
✭✭✭
in Doctor Who #1
247)Time-Flight Average score of 2.74/10
246)Timelash Average score of 2.75/10
245)Fear Her Average score of 3.08/10
244)Time and The Rani Average score of 3.11/10
243)The Twin Dilemma Average score of 3.26/10
242)Underworld Average score of 3.4/10
241)Terminus Average score of 3.47/10
240)The Space Pirates Average score of 3.5/10
239)The Dominators Average score of 3.7/10
238)The Monster of Peladon Average score of 3.88/10
237)The Arc of Infinity Average score of 4.06/10
236)The Evolution of The Daleks Average score of 4.08/10
235)The Web Planet Average score of 4.09/10
234)The Invasion of Time Average score of 4.12/10
233)New Earth Average score of 4.12/10
232)The Mutants Average score of 4.13/10
231)The Doctor's Daughter Average score of 4.32/10
230)Four to Doomsday Average score of 4.33/10
229)The Colony in Space Average score of 4.35/10
228)Love & Monsters Average score of 4.4/10
227)Mindwarp Average score of 4.4/10
226)Planet of the Dead Average score of 4.44/10
225)The Time Monster Average score of 4.44/10
224)Warriors of The Deep Average score of 4.5/10
223)King's Demons Average score of 4.54/10
222)Daleks in Manhattan Average score of 4.56/10
221)Victory of the Daleks Average score of 4.58/10
220)Paradise Towers Average score of 4.69/10
219)The Space Museum Average score of 4.7/10
218)Meglos Average score of 4.71/10
217)The Doctor,The Widow,and the Wardrobe Average score of 4.76/10
216)The Horns of The Nimon Average score of 4.83/10
215)The Idiot's Lantern Average score of 4.84/10
214)The Planet of the Daleks Average score of 4.88/10
213)The Power of Kroll Average score of 4.88/10
212)The Underwater Menace Average score of 4.88/10
211)The Krotons Average score of 4.95/10
210)The Lazarus Experiment Average score of 4.96/10
209)Silver Nemesis Average score of 5/10
208)Dragonfire Average score of 5/10
207)Galaxy 4 Average score of 5/10
206)Aliens of London Average score of 5.04/10
205)World War Three Average score of 5.04/10
204)Death to the Daleks Average score of 5.06/10
203)The Happiness Patrol Average score of 5.06/10
202)The Rebel Flesh Average score of 5.09/10
201)The Curse of the Black Spot Average score of 5.09/10
200)Attack of The Cybermen Average score of 5.1/10
199)The Next Doctor Average score of 5.12/10
198)Celestial Toymaker Average score of 5.13/10
197)The Planet of Fire Average score of 5.13/10
196)The Long Game Average score of 5.18/10
195)The Almost People Average score of 5.24/10
194)The Voyage of the Damned Average score of 5.25/10
193)The Armageddon Factor Average score of 5.36/10
192)Cold Blood Average score of 5.39/10
191)Planet of the Giants Average score of 5.4/10
190)Revenge of the Cybermen Average score of 5.48/10
189)The Sensorites Average score of 5.5/10
188)The Invisible Enemy Average score of 5.5/10
187)42 Average score of 5.52/10
186)The Mysterious Planet Average score of 5.53/10
185)The Two Doctors Average score of 5.53/10
184)The Hungry Earth Average score of 5.58/10
183)The Runaway Bride Average Score of 5.58/10
182)The Beast Below Average score of 5.61/10
181)The Chase Average score of 5.64/10
180)The Leisure Hive Average score of 5.67/10
179)The Frontier in Space Average score of 5.67/10
178)The End of Time Average score of 5.68/10
177)A Christmas Carol Average score of 5.69/10
176)The Ambassadors of Death Average score of 5.71/10
175)Delta and The Bannermen Average score of 5.72/10
174)Rise of the Cybermen Average score of 5.72
173)The Age of Steel Average score of 5.8/10
172)Frontios Average score of 5.81/10
171)Last of the Time Lords Average score of 5.84/10
170)The TV Movie Average score of 5.86/10
169)The Ark Average score of 5.9/10
168)The Nightmare of Eden Average score of 5.91/10
167)Battlefield Average score of 5.91/10
166)The Claws of Axos Average score of 5.94/10
165)The Mark of The Rani Average score of 5.95/10
164)Resurrection of the Dakeks Average score of 6/10
163)The Ultimate Foe Average score of 6/10
162)Planet of the Spiders Average score of 6.05/10
161)The Greatest Show in The Galaxy Average score of 6.07/10
160)The Keys of Marinus Average score of 6.09/10
159)The Reign of Terror Average score of 6.14/10
158)Castrovalva Average score of 6.14/10
157)Night Terrors Average score of 6.16/10
156)Closing Time Average score of 6.18/10
155)The Creature from the Pit Average score of 6.21/10
154)The Sontaran Stratagem Average score of 6.24/10
153)The Mind of Evil Average score of 6.29/10
152)The Ribos Operation Average score of 6.32/10
151)The Vampires of Venice Average score of 6.37/10
150)The Sun Makers Average score of 6.42/10
149)The Android Invasion Average score of 6.43/10
148)Robot Average score of 6.43/10
147)Boom Town Average score of 6.44/10
146)The Gunfighters Average score of 6.44/10
145)Survival Average score of 6.44/10
144)Black Orchid Average score of 6.47/10
143)The Savages Average score of 6.51/10
142)The Smugglers Average score of 6.57/10
141)The Edge of Destruction Average score of 6.58/10
140)The Poison Sky Average score of 6.6/10
139)Invasion of the Dinosaurs Average score of 6.61/10
138)Snakedance Average score of 6.61/10
137)The Wheel in Space Average score of 6.63/10
136)The Sontaran Experiment Average score of 6.63/10
135)Mawdryn Undead Average score of 6.65/10
134)The Seeds of Death Average score of 6.69/10
133)Warriors' Gate Average score of 6.79/10
132)The Five Doctors Average score of 6.79/10
131)The Masque of the Mandragora Average score of 6.83/10
130)Full Circle Average score of 6.83/10
129)Destiny of The Daleks Average score of 6.84/10
128)Gridlock Average score of 6.84/10
127)Day of the Daleks Average score of 6.84/10
126)The Sea Devils Average score of 6.84/10
125)Logopolis Average score of 6.84/10
124)Tooth and Claw Average score of 6.88/10\
123)The Army of Ghosts Average score of 6.88/10
122)The End of the World Average score of 6.88/10
121)The Macra Terror Average score of 6.88/10
120)The Three Doctors Average score of 6.89/10
119)The God Complex Average score of 6.92/10
118)The Sound of the Drums Average score of 6.92/10
117)The Christmas Invasion Average score of 6.92/10
116)The Terror of The Vervoids Average score of 6.93/10
115)The Awakening Average score of 6.94/10
114)The Lodger Average score of 7/10
113)Shada Average score of 7/10
112)Partners in Crime Average score of 7/10
111)The Face of Evil Average score of 7/10
110)Smith and Jones Averag score of 7.04/10
109)The Androids of Tara Average score of 7.04/10
108)Vengeance on Varos Average score of 7.05/10
107)Let's Kill Hitler Averge score of 7.06/10
106)The Rescue Average score of 7.1/10
105)The Silurians Average score of 7.11/10
104)The Visitation Average score of 7.11/10
103)The Pirate Planet Average score of 7.12/10
102)The Wedding of River Song Average score of 7.15/10
101)Doomsday Average score of 7.16/10
100)Rose Average score of 7.16/10
99)The Hand of Fear Average score of 7.17/10
98)The State of Decay Average score of 7.17/10
97)Journey's End Average score of 7.2/10
96)Enemy of the World Average score of 7.2/10
95)The Shakespeare Code Average score of 7.2/10
94)The Moonbase Average score of 7.25/10
93)Day of the Moon Average score of 7.27/10
92)The Unquiet Dead Average score of 7.32/10
91)The Image of the Fendahl Average score of 7.32/10
90)The Fires of Pompeii Average score of 7.32/10
89)The War Machines Average score of 7.33/10
88)The Curse of Peladon Average score of 7.35/10
87)A Good Man Goes To War Average score of 7.38/10
86)The Green Death Average score of 7.39/10
85)The Time Warrior Average score of 7.42/10
84)The Ice Warriors Average score of 7.43/10
83)The Myth Makers Average score of 7.43/10
82)The Keeper of Traken Average score of 7.44/10
81)Ghost Light Average score of 7.44/10
80)The Impossible Astronaut Average score of 7.48/10
79)The Daleks (aka The Mutants) Average score of 7.5/10

Comments

  • Options
    steven1977steven1977 Posts: 3,968
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    #2
    78)The Daleks (aka The Mutants) Average score of 7.5/10
    77)The Big Bang Average score of 7.52/10
    76)Planet of the Ood Average score of 7.52/10
    75)Revelation of the Daleks Average score of 7.55/10
    74)Terror of the Autons Average score of 7.56/10
    73)Planet of Evil Average score of 7.57/10
    72)Mission to the Unknown Average score of 7.6/10
    71)School Reunion Average score of 7.6/10
    70)The Impossible Planet Average score of 7.6/10
    69)Amy's Choice Average score of 7.61/10
    68)The Tenth Planet Average score of 7.63/10
    67)Flesh and Stone Average score of 7.67/10
    66)Kinda Average score of 7.68/10
    65)Dalek Average score of 7.72/10
    64)Marco Polo Average score of 7.75/10
    63)The Faceless Ones Average score of 7.75/10
    62)The Crusade Average score of 7.78/10
    61)Curse of Fenric Average score of 7.79/10
    60)Father's Day Average sciore of 7.8/10
    59)Enlightenment Average score of 7.81/10
    58)The Girl Who Waited Average score of 7.86/10
    57)The Massacre of St.Bartholomews Eve Average score of 7.86/10
    56)The Waters of Mars Average score of 7.88/10
    55)The Stones of Blood Average score of 7.88/10
    54)Earthshock Average score of 7.89/10
    53)The Daemons Average score of 7.89/10
    52)Remembrance of The Daleks Average score of 7.89/10
    51)The Evil of The Daleks Average score of 7.9/10
    50)The Romans Average score of 7.9/10
    49)The Aztecs Average score of 7.91/10
    48)The Unicorn and The Wasp Average score of 7.94/10
    47)*Time of the Angels Average score of 7.98/10
    46)The Satan Pit Average score of 8/10
    45)Utopia Average score of 8.04/10
    44)The Stolen Earth Average score of 8.04/10
    43)An Unearthly Child Average score of 8.08/10
    42)The Deadly Assassin Average score of 8.09/10
    41)The Dalek Invasion of Earth Average score of 8.09/10
    40)Forest of the Dead Average score of 8.2/10
    39)Girl In the Fireplace Average score of 8.2/10
    38)The Carnival of Monsters Average score of 8.21/10
    37)The Eleventh Hour Average score of 8.27/10
    36)Vincent and The Doctor Average score of 8.27/10
    35)The Brain of Morbius Average score of 8.29/10
    34)Terror of the Zygons Average score of 8.3/10
    33)Tomb of the Cybermen Average score of 8.31/10
    32)Midnight Average score of 8.32/10
    31)Silence in the Library Average score of 8.36/10
    30)The Caves of Androzani Average score of 8.37/10
    29)The Invasion Average score of 8.42/10
    28)Spearhead From Space Average score of 8.42/10
    27)The Abominable Snowmen Average score of 8.44/10
    26)The Time Meddler Average score of 8.45/10
    25)Genesis of The Daleks Average score of 8.5/10
    24)The Horror of Fang Rock Average score of 8.5/10
    23)Bad Wolf Average score of 8.52/10
    22)The Parting of The Ways Average score of 8.56/10
    21)The Doctor's Wife Average score of 8.59/10
  • Options
    outsideoutside Posts: 5,610
    Forum Member
    ✭
    #3
    What's the point of this thread?
  • Options
    steven1977steven1977 Posts: 3,968
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    #4
    20.The Pandorica Opens Average score of 8.67/10
    19.The Seeds of Doom Average score of 8.71/10
    18.The Mind Robber Average score of 8.75/10
    17.The City of Death Average score of 8.76/10
    16.The Ark in Space Average score of 8.79/10
    15. The War Games Average score of 8.79/10
    14. The Fury From The Deep Average score of 8.89/10
    13. The Family of Blood Average score of 9/10
    12. Turn Left Average score of 9/10
    11.Inferno Average score of 9/10
    10.Human Nature Average score of 9.04/10
    9. The Web of Fear Average score of 9.1/10
    8.The Power of the Daleks Average score of 9.2/10
    7.The Robots of Death Average score of 9.22/10
    6.The Talons of Weng Chiang Average score of 9.33/10
    5. The Daleks' Master Plan Average score of 9.38/10
    4.The Pyramids of Mars Average score of 9.44/10
  • Options
    davrosdodebirddavrosdodebird Posts: 8,692
    Forum Member
    ✭
    #5
    Point of this thread is to mock and discredit kingyrcanos' effort to come up with a comprehensive list of our favourite story :rolleyes:

    Of course, it also serves to summarise the results so far. That is what I will take out of this thread. Nothing more.
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 512
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    #6
    The Daleks is both 78 and 79...
  • Options
    AirboraeAirborae Posts: 2,649
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    #7
    I'm going to be really controversial here and publish my top 5 Doctor Who stories of all time.

    05. Earthshock (1982)
    04. The Dead Planet aka The Daleks (1963/4)
    03. Human Nature/The Family Of Blood (2007)
    02. The Caves Of Androzani (1984)
    01. Genesis Of The Daleks (1975)

    There you go. The five best stories of all time. No contest.
  • Options
    The Alpha GamerThe Alpha Gamer Posts: 3,122
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    #8
    How the hell are there eps worse than Fear Her?
  • Options
    TyjetTyjet Posts: 8,509
    Forum Member
    ✭
    #9
    No Blink? :eek:
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 1,265
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    #10
    Airborae wrote: »
    I'm going to be really controversial here and publish my top 5 Doctor Who stories of all time.

    05. Earthshock (1982)
    04. The Dead Planet aka The Daleks (1963/4)
    03. Human Nature/The Family Of Blood (2007):eek:]02. The Caves Of Androzani (1984)
    01. Genesis Of The Daleks (1975)

    There you go. The five best stories of all time. No contest.

    I really laughed out loud ...thats probably two of the worst series 3 episodes...The final 3 eps of that season are far far superior
  • Options
    davrosdodebirddavrosdodebird Posts: 8,692
    Forum Member
    ✭
    #11
    Matter of opinion. You have to remember that no opinion is ever right. For example, I loved Utopia, and thought that Derek Jacobi was brilliant as the Master, but I think the series 3 finale was a load of old tripe. I prefer Gridlock.

    But none of us is right or wrong ;):p
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 145
    Forum Member
    ✭
    #12
    This has been done to death but it's always interesting to get people's opinions.

    I'm going to admit I've only watched Nu-Who, I'm desperate to watch the old ones but work and uni take up most if not all of my time :(

    So for me, it's:
    5) The Girl Who Waited
    4) The Doctor's Wife
    3) Human Nature/Family of Blood
    2) Blink
    1) Midnight
  • Options
    performingmonkperformingmonk Posts: 20,086
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    #13
    One of the best things about Human Nature/Family of Blood is how the fob watch idea is then used for the Master in Utopia. Put together they make for some of the finest moments in nu-Who. Moffat still hasn't topped the Master reveal, nor those emotional parts of Family of Blood.

    You get the feeling that Moffat thinks he's soooo brilliant, and yet it's funny how he's still chasing RTD. :cool:
  • Options
    SillyBillyGoatSillyBillyGoat Posts: 22,266
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    #14
    Army of Ghosts / Doomsday is my favourite story.
  • Options
    Mystical123Mystical123 Posts: 15,822
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    #15
    I've only ever seen 'new' Who as well.

    My list would be something like:

    1. The Girl Who Waited
    2. Blink
    3. The Doctor's Wife
    4. Silence in the Library/Forest of the Dead
    5. The Girl in the Fireplace

    The top 3 are constant, the others seem to change a bit every time I make one of these lists depending on what I've rewatched :o
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 1,753
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    #16
    I can never remember the names of episodes, so I could probably never put together a list :)
  • Options
    daveyboy7472daveyboy7472 Posts: 16,416
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    #17
    Suddenly Psycho wrote: »
    This has been done to death but it's always interesting to get people's opinions.

    I'm going to admit I've only watched Nu-Who, I'm desperate to watch the old ones but work and uni take up most if not all of my time :(

    Good thing about the poll is that it gives you a rough idea of the best Classic Who stories to get started on when you do get round to watching it.

    :)
  • Options
    AirboraeAirborae Posts: 2,649
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    #18
    davetherave1701 wrote: »
    I really laughed out loud ...thats probably two of the worst series 3 episodes...The final 3 eps of that season are far far superior

    Ahh, just chill and relax. You're supposed to be a Doctor Who fan. Just accept that there are always different opinions. As I have accepted yours. *cough*
Sign In or Register to comment.