Top, middle and bottom 3 tonight
CloudyE
Posts: 9,230 Forum Member
✭
Cloudye's view of course 
TOP
Cher (her best yet IMO and thats a first for me to like what she has done to this degree)
Matt (more of the same but habdled the song well with his own atyle)
Rebecca (regrettably, if Rebeca doesnt attempt something different next week, she will drop further in my estimation)
Middle
Katie (good performance, handled the vocals really well)
One Direction (Still dont like them and think they are very much over backed vocally but it sounded OK tonight)
Mary (OK, sang in tune but her over emphasis on the diction made the song colder than it could have been)
Bottom
Paije (I feel that I WANT to like his vocals or that I should like him but he misses the full quality mark)
Aidan (cannot understand the hype people are attempting to give this good looking guy, oh, thats it)
Wagner ...............................
TOP
Cher (her best yet IMO and thats a first for me to like what she has done to this degree)
Matt (more of the same but habdled the song well with his own atyle)
Rebecca (regrettably, if Rebeca doesnt attempt something different next week, she will drop further in my estimation)
Middle
Katie (good performance, handled the vocals really well)
One Direction (Still dont like them and think they are very much over backed vocally but it sounded OK tonight)
Mary (OK, sang in tune but her over emphasis on the diction made the song colder than it could have been)
Bottom
Paije (I feel that I WANT to like his vocals or that I should like him but he misses the full quality mark)
Aidan (cannot understand the hype people are attempting to give this good looking guy, oh, thats it
)Wagner ...............................
0
Comments
Paije (sung with soul in his voice)
Rebecca (her tuning is immaculate)
Mary (bounced back after a weak performance last week)
Middle
Wagner (I enjoyed his performance
Matt (He did well - not the greatest fan of the song)
One Direction (They sung basically in tune)
Bottom
Cher (Didn't like the rap)
Katie (Didn't have enough depth to perform the song)
Aiden (Struggled badly after ok start)
Matt (Hate the song, but thought his vocals were amazing)
Cher (Hate the rapping, liked the singing)
1D:o (I don't even know, but i just liked them)
Middle:
Rebecca (Starting to bore me now, but her voice is lovely)
Aiden (Gutted about this week but his voice is unique)
Mary (Better then last week)
Bottom:
Paije (Wrong song and first on, so forgettable)
Katie (Not even ok)
Wagner (...............)
Aiden
Rebecca
Wagner
middle 3
Matt
1 Direction (shocker I know)
Paije
bottom 3
Cher- was ok but just lacked the emotional core of Stay
Katie
Mary- she's just getting boring now
Rebbeca. brill, heart warming. voted for her,
Matt. brill, not as good as last week.
Cher. different. nice vocals. not keen on her rap. but all in all a pretty good performence.
middle
Mary. good, but not her style
1 direction. goodish.
Paije. meh. tryed his best
Bottom
Aiden. off key. pretty lame version of the song. some parts were good. I didn't totatly hate it.
Katie. off key. flat, no harmony to her voice... boring. train wreck. Should have booed her off the stage
Wagner. sickening. speaking instead of singing. drunk at a party bad.
- Katie - She's got a warmth that comes through and every performance is entertaining, even if it isnt vocally perfect.
- Rebecca - stunning, every week.
- Aiden - he's different, and vocally really amazing.
middle
- Cher - back on form this week, but I doubt she'll ever have another repeat of stay.
- Matt - really great voice, but he just doesnt seem to have a personality.
- One Direction - they're cute but seriously, they didn't deserve that reaction from the judges.
bottom
- Wagner - seriously, who is voting for him?
- Mary - yawn.
- Paije - I forgot he was still in, until I realised I was missing someone. says it all really.
Rebecca (it was great:))
Mary (not perfect- she needs to relax more- but much better)
Middle
Matt (I love Matt but it just didn't work for me this week- he's safe though)
One Direction (not sure how much they were actually singing- very loud backing track- but not bad)
Paije (very hard to sing but he has a good voice)
Bottom
Cher- (over sang the words- warbled uncessarily- too much affection in the singing- found it very hard to listen to)
Katie (DIRE- could do better myself)
Aiden (song didn't suit him at all)
Wagner- wasn't even funny- was fairly boring
Rebecca
Mat but not his best tonight
Aiden not his best but like him
Middle
One Direction
Paije
mary:eek:
Bottom
Vagner
Cher
Katie
1. Rebecca
2. Cher
3. One Direction
Middle 3
4. Matt
5. Mary
6. Aiden
Bottom 3
7. Paije
8. Katie
9. Wagner
Matt
Cher
Rebecca
MIDDLE
Aiden
One Direction
Paije
BOTTOM
Mary
Katie
Wagner
Middle, Wagner, Mary, Katie
Bottom, Aiden, Paije, One Direction
1. Aiden
2. Wand erection ( Shocker ) :eek:
3. Mary
Middle
4. Matt ( Poor compaired to last week )
5. Wagner ( Out of Tune but he is funny )
6. Rebecca ( Out Of Tune and over rated )
Bottom
7. Katie ( Out of Tune, Bad song choice )
8. Cher ( Out Of Tune, only 1 good week )
9. Paige ( Pointless )
Wish these judges would stop trying to make these lot out to be world class super stars.
1. Matt - brilliant as always, not his best but still great
2. One Direction - I have been brainwashed, like them
3. Paije - love this guy and he is not getting the chances he should
Middle 3
4. Rebecca - good as always but nothing special for me
5. Cher - current, cool but still distinctly unlikeable
6. Aiden - I want him to be better than he is as he is interesting but he is not improving
Bottom 3
7. Mary - Mrs Bulldozer through songs, would never buy her albums
8. Katie - where to start? Just leave Weasel.
9. Wagner - not funny anymore, so dire
Rebecca - vocal performance of the night
Matt - struggled to make much of an indifferent song
Middle
1D - Too much backing track (again)
Cher - more of her "usual"
Mary - better than last week but uninspiring
Aiden - ditto ^^^
bottom
Paige - shafted songwise - designed to make him lose
Katie - seriously can't sing!!!!!!!
Wagner - fun but foul
Rebecca - a class apart
Matt - not his best and not my type, but he does what he does well
One Direction - I hate boybands, but they seemed like one tonight (backing track and all)
Middle 3
Aiden - I would rather he was in the top 3, but he needs to do songs he personally connects with
Paije - I just think he's good fun
Wagner - he won't win but, more than anyone, I want to see what he does next,
Bottom 3
Cher - I just don't much like her.She's not original, just derivative. Maybe I'm too old.
Katie: I can see why she was kept in last week, but once the headlines fade, there's little left.
Mary - top woman, but I've seen many cabaret acts like this.
Wagner (Was the best tonight by miles, he stole the show)
Aiden (You either like his thing or you don't, Marmite I guess)
Rebecca (Good vocal, should move though)
Cher
Middle
Rebecca (Good vocal, should move though)
One Direction
Paige
Bottom
Katie
Mary (Boring)
Matt (Same old.., same old..)
cher
matt
one direction
MIDDLE
rebecca
aiden
paige
BOTTOM
mary
wagner
katie
Matt
Rebecca
Wagner
Middle
One direction
Aiden
Mary
Bottom
Cher
Katie
Page
Matt -- the only one to find the drama of the song. Great vocal
Rebecca -- terrific moving beginning but became samey
Paije -- love his voice. Roland GIftish tonight, I thought
MIDDLE
Cher -- favourite yet by her
1D -- Harry sang, which was good. Harmonies dreary though
Aiden -- I like his more intense performances intensely. This OK
BOTTOM
Mary -- a bit stolid
Katie -- Don't rate this singer
Wagner -- ditto except I withdraw the word singer in his case.
Rebecca - I wasn't a fan until tonight, but yeah, she was something else there
Aiden - not tonight perhaps but I blame it on the song choice
Cher - interesting voice and definitely holds the attention
MIDDLE (not boring)
Matt - I'm on the fence with him. Last week's song is the only time he picked my interest.
One Direction - three of them can actually sing and they are quite adorable on q&a videos
Wagner - have no idea what it is about him, but he amuses me so
BOTTOM (don't really care)
Mary *meh*
Katie *bored of it*
Paije *yawns*
Rebecca
Matt
Mid
Cher
Mary
Bottom
Wand Erection
Aiden
Katie
Paije
Wagner
Top 3
Rebecca - Her voice gave the song a different feel.
Matt - Competent rather than outstanding but the vocals were solid
One Direction - Best week for them. Good song choice and Harry really nailed the ending
Middle 3
Cher- She's not my favourite contestant by a long way but her singing voice was controlled even if she did a few too many runs. Hated the rapping though.
Paije - Did his best with an awful song choice.
Aiden- Wrong song - again. Dannii doesn't get him at all. I don't think she really gets any of them actually. Her song choices are mostly way off.
Bottom 3
Mary- She can sing. She has a powerful voice. Unfortunately she has only one type of song she can perform. Plus I don't think her voice suited the tenderness of the song.
Wagner: He is fun in a weird sort of way but Louis is just taking the p**s now - he wants him out so he can concentrate on Mary (can't work out why though)
Katie - she didn't have a rough enough edge to her voice to carry it off. She sounded really weak when it should have been ( in the hands of a more suitable singer) belting. Plus she was desperately lost in places.
All of them but....
Mary & Katie should go now.
As soon as Wagner hits bottom 2 or 3 he should just be invited back each week as a guest singer.
1. Cher
2. Aiden
3. Rebecca
Middle:
4. One Direction
5. Katie
6. Matt
Bottom:
7. Mary
8. Paije
9. Wagner
^^ this. Said it better than I could
Rebecca
Cher
Mary
Middle
Matt
One Direction
Aiden
Bottom
Paije
Katie
Wagner