What a dreadful series this is - 2011
HHGTTG
Posts: 5,941 Forum Member
✭
I have just been spending some considerable time looking back at past winners and dancers on earlier SCD series and this brings me to the conclusion that this current one is the worst I've seen, from so many aspects.
The main culprits being the standard of the amateurs, the behaviour of the judges and the general tawdriness of the whole presentation. This culminated in the dreadful, gawdy, noisy shambles that was the show from Wembley at the weekend.
I have always been critical of the types of music chosen for the dances but this series has to be the worst ever. Even as a once ballroom dancer, if I don't concentrate of the programme, I am sometimes at a loss to know which dance they are supposed to be dancing as, invariably, the music gives no clues whatsoever.
I had high hopes, perhaps, for Harry J but fear that he won't win, now. A female dancer (say, Chelsee) may stand a chance as she can be dragged around the floor by her professional partner
The producers have got a lot to answer for, in this current SCD shambles.
The main culprits being the standard of the amateurs, the behaviour of the judges and the general tawdriness of the whole presentation. This culminated in the dreadful, gawdy, noisy shambles that was the show from Wembley at the weekend.
I have always been critical of the types of music chosen for the dances but this series has to be the worst ever. Even as a once ballroom dancer, if I don't concentrate of the programme, I am sometimes at a loss to know which dance they are supposed to be dancing as, invariably, the music gives no clues whatsoever.
I had high hopes, perhaps, for Harry J but fear that he won't win, now. A female dancer (say, Chelsee) may stand a chance as she can be dragged around the floor by her professional partner
The producers have got a lot to answer for, in this current SCD shambles.
0
Comments
Nope, it's definately not a good year.
I'd like to see it return to being a dancing competition with a bit of entertainment, rather than an entertainment show with a bit of dancing. But I won't hold my breath.
A very good summarisation.
Perhaps next year the judges should take on mentoring roles, like in X-Factor?
Len - The over 40's
Alesha - The girls
Bruno - The boys
Craig - ??
The camera work is terrible. You hardly EVER see someones feet and when you do they are about 1000 miles away (like the long shots at wembly - I needed a magnifying glass).
spot on
after about 20 minutes on saturday I was unable to continue watchin as the camera work made me feel like I had been on a roller coaster after eating a bucketfull of dodgy mussels!
totally hating this series
I'm enjoying it.
especially since Anton left.
Well I have to agree with almost all you say.
I'm not TOTALLY hating the series because I love Chelsee, and there have been lots of fun moments and even one or two good dances! But as everyone says, there have been far too many poor dances, to poor music choices (because of this wretched 'themed weekend' business) too many poor dresses (come back Sue), Len's bad temper this year and just a complete loss of proper dancing. I too watch almost no TV but Strictly has always been my 'something to look forward to on Autumn Saturdays', However this year's series has been such a let down, and Saturday's debacle from Wembley was grim . Maybe it was OK if you were there, but on TV the sound was awful and all the dashing about, up and down stairs, camers zipping about all over the place, flashing lights etc gave me headache. NEVER again please. Can we go back to lovely dancing, in lovely dresses, to lovely appropriate music, without gimmicks, on a ballroom floor please ?
My biggest gripe is the producers messing about with the order of dances. Give me two three dances each week in the first half of the series any day, over the unfair and confusing jumble we've seen this year.
I find its often the case with shows like this, that a fantastic year is followed by a poor one. This year it seems a bit lacklustre, so I'm already looking forward to next year!!
In summary: more annoyances and seemingly less quality dancing than the better series.
Ironically the ratings are very good but I don't really know if that's because the opposition is weaker this year or what.
I am enjoying it this year, but haven't decided which celebrity to support yet - which is unusual for me.
Anita would have been out week 3 on any other year
In terms of number of viewers, SCD's week-on-week figures are actually down on last year's but slightly better than past years. It's more that X-Factor's viewing figures have fallen off a cliff and are now closer to SCD's.
Ooo thanks for that, wondered why they hadn't used it this year - hope it is, its so beautiful and that comes across on screen.
I didn't watch it last year... but how far would Widdy have got this year?
The joke contestants aren't nearly as noxious in 2011, it seems to me, and they haven't been as disfiguring in terms of losing more talented dancers early.
The final is to be at Blackpool, so that will be good (I hope !!)
I think with Strictly this year it's a case of 'if it aint broke, don't fix it' . The Beeb seem to be trying to make it compete with the X Factor . Why ????
Strictly is in danger of losing its core audience, those of us who don't watch the X Factor anyway. The core audience have always loved the proper dancing and music on Strictly, the lovely dresses, and the fun and entertainment and don't want all this flashy camera work, gimmicks, unsuitable music, show dances rather than classic dances etc etc. The BBC gets its money from the licence fee and so doesn't need to pander to the whims of a larger audience, by dumbing down its flagship Autumn programme. One big fault on Saturday (apart from sound quality, far too big set etc) was that there were too many dances and too many Latin dances in particular. Go back to the original format BBC. It was great, it worked and we all loved it. Stop messing it about !!
As Buddy said, no WOW factor.
Still watching every week and every ITT though
Me too. I live in hope of better things once more !
Poor music has been right up there for me too and reading between the lines, it sounds like the pros have been given music to dance to each week far more than before, particularly for the themed weeks. When Brendan was on Zoe's radio show the other week, he said every week each pros still dancing with a celeb meets with Nikki (director?) from the show to discuss the music and sometimes Nikki is fine with the pro's choice of music, but sometimes they will be told Moira (Ross?) wants them to use a particular piece of music and he added you don't argue with Moira Ross! I think we can guess when Moira has chosen the music.