After 15 votes, the top 3 judges keep changing and keep a steady lead over the middle. The middle players keep changing and there is a new bottom judge who was once ranked as high as 4th.
Kelly Rowland.....top
Gary Barlow
Nicole Schezy
Danni minogue
Sharon Osborne
Mel b
Louis walsh
Simon Cowell
Cheryl tweedy/cole/f/v
Toloosa.....bottom (the worst one out of the bottom 4 imo)
Nicole Scherzinger
Simon Cowell
Mel B
Sharon Osbourne
Gary Barlow
Kelly Rowland
Louis Walsh
Tulisa
Dannii Minouge
Cheryl Cole
I think Nicole is probably one of the very few if not only judges that is a talented singer, big personality and beautiful all in one go. Anything Cheryl can do, Scherzy can do 10 times better and I think she made that quite clear with her (LIVE) performance last week. Nicole was a very successful judge even having both of her acts in the final 2, and she was always vibrant and truthful but without being cold or arrogant like Cheryl.
I don't care much for Tulisa, Louis, Dannii or Cheryl so would be happy with any line up that doesn't involve them.
This is hard because, for example, I liked Tulisa during her first year and then she looked like she didn't want to be there for her second year. Sharon has had some hit and miss years too...
1) Tulisa
2) Dannii Minogue
3) Nicole Scherzinger
4) Mel B
5) Louis Walsh
6) Simon Cowell
7) Sharon Osbourne
8) Kelly Rowland (Although I liked her on US)
9) Gary Borelow
10) Cheryl
I think Nicole is probably one of the very few if not only judges that is a talented singer, big personality and beautiful all in one go. Anything Cheryl can do, Scherzy can do 10 times better and I think she made that quite clear with her (LIVE) performance last week. Nicole was a very successful judge even having both of her acts in the final 2, and she was always vibrant and truthful but without being cold or arrogant like Cheryl.
I don't care much for Tulisa, Louis, Dannii or Cheryl so would be happy with any line up that doesn't involve them.
I agree with this post, apart from Louis, I don't mind him at all.
Comments
02 - Nicole Scherzinger
03 - Cheryl Cole
04 - Mel B
05 - Sharon Osbourne - LOVED her last year
06 - Louis Walsh
07 - Kelly Rowland
08 - Simon Cowell
09 - Tulisa
10 - Gary Barlow (BORELOW)
Gary Barlow
Nicole Schezy
Danni minogue
Sharon Osborne
Mel b
Louis walsh
Simon Cowell
Cheryl tweedy/cole/f/v
Toloosa.....bottom (the worst one out of the bottom 4 imo)
Simon Cowell
Mel B
Sharon Osbourne
Gary Barlow
Kelly Rowland
Louis Walsh
Tulisa
Dannii Minouge
Cheryl Cole
I think Nicole is probably one of the very few if not only judges that is a talented singer, big personality and beautiful all in one go. Anything Cheryl can do, Scherzy can do 10 times better and I think she made that quite clear with her (LIVE) performance last week. Nicole was a very successful judge even having both of her acts in the final 2, and she was always vibrant and truthful but without being cold or arrogant like Cheryl.
I don't care much for Tulisa, Louis, Dannii or Cheryl so would be happy with any line up that doesn't involve them.
in the end...
1 Simon Cowell
2 Dannii
3 Nicole
4 Sharon
2. Simon
3. Sharon
4. Tulisa
5. Dannii
6. Gary
7. Kelly
8. Mel
9. Cheryl
10. Louis
2) Dannii Minogue
3) Nicole Scherzinger
4) Mel B
5) Louis Walsh
6) Simon Cowell
7) Sharon Osbourne
8) Kelly Rowland (Although I liked her on US)
9) Gary Borelow
10) Cheryl
2. Simon
3. Sharon
4. Dannii
5. Gary
6. Cheryl
7. Louis
8. Kelly
9. Mel
10. Tulisa
I don't love or hate any of them, though I like Nicole quite a lot more than the rest. But the rest of my list changes all the time.
2. Nicole
3. Louis
4. Simon
5. Cheryl
6. Sharon
7. Kelly
8. Dannii
9. Mel
10. Gary
2 Kelly
3 Sharon
4 Louis
5 Mel B
6 Nicole
7 Cheryl
8 Tulisa
9 Simon
You miss out Dannii
2. Sharon Osbourne
3. Louis Walsh
4. Simon Cowell
5. Dannii Minogue
6. Tulisa
7. Gary Barlow
8. Kelly Rowland
9. Mel B
10. Cheryl Cole
I agree with this post, apart from Louis, I don't mind him at all.
2. Nicole Scherzinger
3. Cheryl
4. Simon Cowell
5. Mel B
6. Sharon Osbourne
7. Kelly Rowland
8. Tulisa
9. Louis Walsh
10. Gary Barlow
Sharon Osbourne
Dannii Minogue
Louis Walsh
Cheryl Cole
Tulisa
Mel B
Nicole Scherzinger
Gary Barlow
Kelly Rowland
2. Sharon Osbourne
3. Nicole Scherzinger
4. Simon Cowell
5. Mel B
6. Dannii Minogue
7. Kelly Rowland
8. Cheryl Cole
9. Tulisa
10. Gary Barlow
2. Simon Cowell
3. Sharon Osbourne
4. Dannii Minogue
5. Cheryl Cole
6. Gary Barlow
7. Kelly Rowland
8. Tulisa
9. Louis Walsh
10. Mel B
Sharon Osbourne
Nicole Scherzinger
Kelly Rowland
Dannii Minouge
Louis Walsh
Simon Cowell
Tulisa
Mel B
Cheryl Cole
2) Sharon Osbourne
3) Cheryl Cole
4) Simon Cowell
5) Nicole Scherzinger
6) Tulisa
7) Kelly Rowland
8) Dannii Minouge
9) Gary Barlow
10) Mel B
2. Simon Cowell.
3. Sharon Osbourne.
4. Gary Barlow.
5. Nicole Scherzinger.
6. Danni Minogue.
7. Kelly Rowland.
8. Tulisa.
9. Cheryl Fernández-Versini.
10. Mel B.
Sharon Osbourne
Louis Walsh
Gary Barlow
Mel B
Tulisa
Nicole Scherzinger
Kelly Rowland
Dannii Minouge
Cheryl Cole
2. Nicole Scherzinger
3. Sharon Osbourne
4. Dannii Minogue
5. Tulisa
6. Cheryl Cole
7. Louis Walsh
8. Gary Barlow
9. Mel B
10. Kelly Rowland
Mel would have been much higher if this was before the live shows!