If people don't like an act why on earth would it because of any threat to their favourite? To consider someone a threat, you have to rate them, which would mean rating Cher.
I don't have anything against Cher. I think that she probably has a good voice but the last performance I say was s***e. I have no reason to "hate" her. She hasn't started a stupid baiting thread on her afterall.
I don't hate her, but she is not equipped to cope with this (even if she was talented enough, which I'm not at all sure she is). I have held back from saying this, because I know that some teenage girls just are naturally thin, but now I have to say that I strongly suspect that Cher is anorexic. She worries me and I think she needs help.
If people don't like an act why on earth would it because of any threat to their favourite? To consider someone a threat, you have to rate them, which would mean rating Cher.
I don't have anything against Cher. I think that she probably has a good voice but the last performance I say was s***e. I have no reason to "hate" her. She hasn't started a stupid baiting thread on her afterall.
Just maybe because Cher is one of the favourites with evidence coming from the social networking support and the bookies?
No, I think to consider someone a threat entails the threat being a favourite regardless if you personally rate them or not.
I purposefully chose the word “hating” instead of “disliking” because I know that this is the case on this forum, and this thread proves I was right in entitling it what I did.
I'm coming round to her (maybe because she's getting a lot of bad comments). When she sings she's not just being pretty or trying to be spectacular with her voice. She's pushing her performance; she pushes her voice into roughness and twists her face into grimaces. It's not pretty. She's an abrasive little bug*er and I like her for that. But she's very uneven. In some ways I think she's like a bit of electrical equipment with a wobbly connection. One minute it's working fine, but then something happens and it's all crackles and crap. No idea how different she really is but she is different to the average singer on the show.
She's a bit temperamental though.
Her breakdown seemed real, whereas Katie's was an act from beginning to end.
Why is it always the case that if you don't like the most hyped up act, it's because 'they're a threat to your favourite' or 'you're jealous'?
I liked Cher in her audition, but since then she's been poor, and the ridiculous over-hyping of her hasn't endeared her to me any further.
I don't see her as a threat to my favourite, because I'm already fully aware that Nicolo hasn't a hope in hell of winning.
I don't hate the kid, why would I, I don't know her. But I did hate her initial performance. To see a 16 year old child doing the crotch grabbing gave me the creeps. I found it very uncomfortable bordering on repulsive.
Why is it always the case that if you don't like the most hyped up act, it's because 'they're a threat to your favourite' or 'you're jealous'?
I liked Cher in her audition, but since then she's been poor, and the ridiculous over-hyping of her hasn't endeared her to me any further.
I don't see her as a threat to my favourite, because I'm already fully aware that Nicolo hasn't a hope in hell of winning.
Hey, we don't know anything yet! Nicolo's an oddball charmer and adds a bit of intrigue in that no one seems sure whether he's being serious or not. I can't see the producers wanting to lose him early in the show (supposing he gets through to the lives...)
I think I just prefer to positively like the singers we like and leave the others (ahem, Storm) to the side of the plate.
hated is good. Means she has more chance of becoming famous. hated and talked about, and of course liked by a lot, means more chance of winning.
I have no problem with her. I have liked her singing, in some parts, I heard something really good, and in some parts she just falls flat on her chair... I think she has what it takes but she is all over the place at the moment.
hated is good. Means she has more chance of becoming famous. hated and talked about, and of course liked by a lot, means more chance of winning.
I have no problem with her. I have liked her singing, in some parts, I heard something really good, and in some parts she just falls flat on her chair... I think she has what it takes but she is all over the place at the moment.
I think the pressure of being an internet sensation all over the world is getting to her :rolleyes:
Hey, we don't know anything yet! Nicolo's an oddball charmer and adds a bit of intrigue in that no one seems sure whether he's being serious or not. I can't see the producers wanting to lose him early in the show (supposing he gets through to the lives...)
I think I just prefer to positively like the singers we like and leave the others (ahem, Storm) to the side of the plate.
I'm always pessimistic with these things Two acts from the same category have never won two years in a row, and I think Nicolo will be very marmite anyway - I'm expecting him to go around week 5.
I don't hate her, but she is not equipped to cope with this (even if she was talented enough, which I'm not at all sure she is). I have held back from saying this, because I know that some teenage girls just are naturally thin, but now I have to say that I strongly suspect that Cher is anorexic. She worries me and I think she needs help.
i agree lulu her face looks haggered ang her voice loss could be down to chucking up... hope im wrong
Can you imagine if she was in a sing-off? If she cracks like that at Judges Houses, no way will she be able for the pressures of live TV. She appears to be a very sheltered 16 year old, and I could actually see this show completely ruining her.
TBF, Throat problems are common with singers especially when they are under pressure. It is possible that she simply had a virus and continued to practice when she should have been resting. That could happen to anyone and anyone would be upset if they were trying to perform when they were ill. Sometimes this forum can be a very unforgiving place.
I don't hate her, but she is not equipped to cope with this (even if she was talented enough, which I'm not at all sure she is). I have held back from saying this, because I know that some teenage girls just are naturally thin, but now I have to say that I strongly suspect that Cher is anorexic. She worries me and I think she needs help.
I hadn't considered that, though she may be susceptible to illness if she doesn't eat well. Oh dear, that's a shame if true.
However, as I said in my previous post, she may just have picked up an infection. I had to have a day of work on Monday due to a cold. I have to talk in my job and I wasn't able to work because my throat was too sore. It happens.
I don't hate the kid, why would I, I don't know her. But I did hate her initial performance. To see a 16 year old child doing the crotch grabbing gave me the creeps. I found it very uncomfortable bordering on repulsive.
Thank God I'm not the only one that found it repulsive. If my daughter acted like that I would have been so embarassed
Comments
If people don't like an act why on earth would it because of any threat to their favourite? To consider someone a threat, you have to rate them, which would mean rating Cher.
I don't have anything against Cher. I think that she probably has a good voice but the last performance I say was s***e. I have no reason to "hate" her. She hasn't started a stupid baiting thread on her afterall.
People like TreyC and Gamu, and even Keri are alledgedly being sacrificed for them two drama queens.
Just maybe because Cher is one of the favourites with evidence coming from the social networking support and the bookies?
No, I think to consider someone a threat entails the threat being a favourite regardless if you personally rate them or not.
I purposefully chose the word “hating” instead of “disliking” because I know that this is the case on this forum, and this thread proves I was right in entitling it what I did.
Nor am I. I'm a straight male and can't stand her.
She's a bit temperamental though.
Her breakdown seemed real, whereas Katie's was an act from beginning to end.
I liked Cher in her audition, but since then she's been poor, and the ridiculous over-hyping of her hasn't endeared her to me any further.
I don't see her as a threat to my favourite, because I'm already fully aware that Nicolo hasn't a hope in hell of winning.
Hey, we don't know anything yet! Nicolo's an oddball charmer and adds a bit of intrigue in that no one seems sure whether he's being serious or not. I can't see the producers wanting to lose him early in the show (supposing he gets through to the lives...)
I think I just prefer to positively like the singers we like and leave the others (ahem, Storm) to the side of the plate.
I have no problem with her. I have liked her singing, in some parts, I heard something really good, and in some parts she just falls flat on her chair...
I think the pressure of being an internet sensation all over the world is getting to her :rolleyes:
I'm always pessimistic with these things
i agree lulu her face looks haggered ang her voice loss could be down to chucking up... hope im wrong
TBF, Throat problems are common with singers especially when they are under pressure. It is possible that she simply had a virus and continued to practice when she should have been resting. That could happen to anyone and anyone would be upset if they were trying to perform when they were ill. Sometimes this forum can be a very unforgiving place.
I hadn't considered that, though she may be susceptible to illness if she doesn't eat well. Oh dear, that's a shame if true.
However, as I said in my previous post, she may just have picked up an infection. I had to have a day of work on Monday due to a cold. I have to talk in my job and I wasn't able to work because my throat was too sore. It happens.
Thank God I'm not the only one that found it repulsive. If my daughter acted like that I would have been so embarassed