Seriously, what are the judges problem with Dannii?
Stefano92
Posts: 66,392 Forum Member
✭✭
What exactly has she done wrong??
It looks like every week that Dannii has had an argument with Cheryl and Simon. Cheryl doesn't even look at her in the face.
Satisfaction if Aidan and Matt are in the Top 2. And the rest can sod off. They treat her like crap, and its obvious they are trying to push her further and further off the show... but if she wins with her act this year I will be so overjoyed.
It'c clear they don't want her there.
It looks like every week that Dannii has had an argument with Cheryl and Simon. Cheryl doesn't even look at her in the face.
Satisfaction if Aidan and Matt are in the Top 2. And the rest can sod off. They treat her like crap, and its obvious they are trying to push her further and further off the show... but if she wins with her act this year I will be so overjoyed.
It'c clear they don't want her there.
0
Comments
Simon and Cheryl are obviously using each other for their own gain and are pushing Dannii and Louis aside.
Especially Dannii, it seems as though they are trying to make it so that Cheryl really is the national treasure that she is being perceived as at the moment.
However it does seem some people are realizing what they are doing and it may be their downfall!
It's about time one of them dared to criticise this overwhelmingly average young girl. Cher's responses to being praised and then criticised said it all. Clearly being praised all the time is going straight to her head.
But back OT, yes it's very clear that Simon and Cheryl have some sort of problem with Dannii. God knows why, perhaps because she's becoming more and more popular for being an honest judge who always gives constructive criticism. On the bright side though, it's really nice to see Louis sticking up for Dannii
Totally agree I wish Simon would stop being Cheryls lapdog and realise that Danni is a far better judge than Cheryl
Although, tonight was really uncomfortable viewing, I didn't like Simon calling her "Miss Minogue" in that sneery voice of his, and his constant disagreeing with her was... noticeable.
I'd like to think it's all panto though, since it's pretty uncomfortable viewing, but, I can watch it if I think that Dannii knows it's all an act for the cameras.
100% agree.
She is the only one that judges based on singing and performance. Which is why Simon saved Jedward over Lucie for some bizarre reason, but Dannii sent Jedward home instead of Olly, which was the right thing to do.
Also Dannii was the only one to pick correctly this year, look at the others...
Simon- Picks Diva Fever, just a walking contradiction after hating Jedward last year, then saving them, then bringing Diva Fever as a wildcard.
Cheryl- By picking Katie when she didnt sing the song in judge shomes (same for Cher really)
Louis- By picking Wager as another novelty act.
Dannii actually chose on performance and singing ability.
She is not biased either. Her opinion is mostly what people are thinking.
I'm with Louis on that one!:D
Sacking a pregnant woman just wouldn't do for his and the XF's image though would it?
He's all about the ratings and conning the GBP. I'm sure he's wanted rid for a couple of years now. Dannii's better than this bloody pantomime anyway.
I do think that Dannii probably gives the most honest opinions, although in these types of shows it's hard to say!
She isnt going to kowtow and tow the party line that Cowell has dictated, thats why!
Cheryl knows which side her bread is larded on and shes keeping in with Cowell....and we already know that Louis is a lapdog and will say and do anything the others tell him!
Dannii has a mind of her own and isnt patronising or fake and doesnt sell herself out like Cole.
Remember last year that as soon as Dannii and Cheryl started getting along well......Dannii was shoved down the end of the table.
Very true. And it was sprung on Dannii right before she sat down live on tv. She couldn't understand why they were moving her and what she'd done wrong.
He also fired 2 out of 3 judges on Australia's Got Talent - she was the only one that kept her job.
Obviously she was pregnant, but seeing as everyone else got fired, there wouldn't be any need to worry about it. And she could have been moved to XF Australia if he wanted rid of her from XF UK.
But she wasn't and she continues to spend most of the year working on his shows.
For whatever reason, this forum seems to be permanently on "Dannii watch" and extremely sensitive to anyone disagreeing with her.
Yes, he disagreed with her more than usual tonight - which is like 3 times in 150 minutes! It's still not half as much as he tends to disagree with Louis Walsh (and vice versa) yet nobody really bothers (unless it's in the context of Simon/Cheryl vs Dannii/Louis).
It was also minor things - just picking up on something that the other had said rather than any significant disagreement.
As for Miss Minogue - better than "Madam" which was for Cheryl or "Miss Friedman" for Brian!
Cheryl is jealous of her and Simon is Cheryls lapdog. I think thats a big part of the problem.
Simon knows how popular Danni is and if he gets rid of her he won't be smiled on for doing so. I suppose if they can force her to leave of her own accord it looks much better for them. I hope Danni rises above it and stays in spite of their feeling towards her.
It would however seem that most people here have a problem with Cheryl and Simon having a great friendship :cool:
A great friendship?
How would you see it if Simon or Cheryl was your partner, or your partner had a 'great friendship' with someone of the opposite sex?
Personaly I think their behaviour is rather questionable.
As for Cheryl, I suppose I'm the only one who noticed Cheryl turn to Dannii and start to talk, giggling, just after her comment on Simon's teeth? (Predictably the camera cut away as soon as they turned to each other, can't have the viewers thinking the girls don't hate each other :rolleyes: .) Yep, she's sure got it in for Dannii there.
So you can't disagree with Dannii incase it hurts her feelings?! Negativity for not agreeing with a person?
People are forever having a go at Simon for apparantly trying to keep Cheryl happy :yawn: yet you want Simon to do this for Dannii?!