Ahh so its Louis that only has 1 win and all the others have had 2 each?
Too much to hope that Simon would get rid of Louis, I wish he would, Louis really gets on my nerves.
Out of the 7 series, it's been won once by an over and the other 6 times by the under's category. The one time Louis has had the under's, he won. The rest of the time he has had the groups/overs. I doubt Simon sees Louis's lack of winning as a reflection of his mentoring skills.
Top 4 of each show. Series 1: Steve (Simon), G4 (Louis), Tabby (Sharon), Rowetta (Simon)
Series 2: Shayne (Louis), Andy (Sharon), Journey South (Simon), Brenda (Sharon)
Series 3: Leona (Simon), Ray (Simon), Ben (Sharon), Macdonalds (Louis)
Series 4: Leon (Dannii), Rhydian (Dannii), Same Difference (Simon), Niki (Louis)
Series 5: Alexandra (Cheryl), JLS (Louis), Eoghan (Simon), Diana (Cheryl)
Series 6: Joe (Cheryl), Olly (Simon), Stacey (Dannii), Danyl (Simon)
Series 7: Matt (Dannii), Rebecca (Cheryl), One Direction (Simon), Cher (Cheryl).
Sharon (4 series)
1st place: 0 (0% of her series)
2nd place: 1
3rd place: 2
4th place: 1
Louis (7 series)
1st place: 1 (14% of his series)
2nd place: 2
3rd place: 0
4th place: 2
Simon (7 series)
1st place: 2 (28% of his series)
2nd place: 2
3rd place: 4
4th place: 2
Dannii (4 series)
1st place: 2 (50% of her series)
2nd place: 1
3rd place: 1
4th place: 0
Cheryl (3 series)
1st place: 2 (66% of her series)
2nd place: 1
3rd place: 0
4th place: 2
Out of the 7 series, it's been won once by an over and the other 6 times by the under's category. The one time Louis has had the under's, he won. The rest of the time he has had the groups/overs. I doubt Simon sees Louis's lack of winning as a reflection of his mentoring skills.
Do you think If Matt had stayed in his original category he still would of won?:)
I guess it depends how much Simon wants to use his new "big" judge. I agree that it would be shambolic to sack Dannii now & I can`t see him choosing between Louis and his pet Cheryl.
Maybe it will become 5 categories...They could add "reject novelty act" for Louis to mentor.
He was so goddam rude," shrieks Sharon. "He'd just done his song, and I opened my mouth to say: 'That was really good, Steve', when he just rolled his eyes then went: 'Whatever, yeah, c'mon, hurry up, blah, blah, blah.'
"I thought: 'You little ****. You've ******* done it now.'
"So I stood up and gave it to him, in front of the whole crew. I said: 'You cheeky ****** ******. Who do you think you are? You are 36 and it has taken all this time, and three talent contests to get here. **** you, you piece of ****. I am 52 and have earned my place in this industry. Who are you? You little *****.'"
"It's nothing to what I could have said," she says, smiling sweetly. "I could have nailed his ******* **** to the floor."
Unfortunately for Sharon, Steve went on to win the contest. Even more unfortunately, some believe he won because Sharon - unable, or unwilling, to let the matter go - turned against him later that evening, in front of the camera - and 9.9 million viewers.
She branded him a 'fake', and 'an average singer'. It was a venomous attack, and it won him a huge sympathy vote.
Do you think If Matt had stayed in his original category he still would of won?:)
It's an interesting question because without the changes, the line up could have been very different but I still think he would've won. I would love to know the real reason behind the changes. Whatever the reason, Louis took it with grace. I wonder how Simon, Cheryl and Danni would've reacted if the changes meant they lost the strongest contenders out of their category.
He was so goddam rude," shrieks Sharon. "He'd just done his song, and I opened my mouth to say: 'That was really good, Steve', when he just rolled his eyes then went: 'Whatever, yeah, c'mon, hurry up, blah, blah, blah.'
"I thought: 'You little ****. You've ******* done it now.'
"So I stood up and gave it to him, in front of the whole crew. I said: 'You cheeky ****** ******. Who do you think you are? You are 36 and it has taken all this time, and three talent contests to get here. **** you, you piece of ****. I am 52 and have earned my place in this industry. Who are you? You little *****.'"
"It's nothing to what I could have said," she says, smiling sweetly. "I could have nailed his ******* **** to the floor."
Unfortunately for Sharon, Steve went on to win the contest. Even more unfortunately, some believe he won because Sharon - unable, or unwilling, to let the matter go - turned against him later that evening, in front of the camera - and 9.9 million viewers.
She branded him a 'fake', and 'an average singer'. It was a venomous attack, and it won him a huge sympathy vote.
OK, you caught me. I didn't watch Series 1, I watched from 2 onwards, lol. :') That sounded like fun though...
iluvdannii
Posts: 3,147
Comments
EDIT: I stand corrected
Leona? :sleep:
He won in Leonas yeah, Ray was also 2nd in that year too.
Anyway i'd be shocked if he doesnt bring back the winning judge!
Ahh so its Louis that only has 1 win and all the others have had 2 each?
Too much to hope that Simon would get rid of Louis, I wish he would, Louis really gets on my nerves.
I think it will be the same 4 next year
Louis and Simon both. Ray came second in Leona's year, like Rhydian came second in Leons year.
1. Simon.
1. Louis
1. Sharon
2. Cheryl
2. Dannii
Simon has had two wins - Leona and Steve.
Sharon? Who did she win with?
Simon =Steve/Leona
Louis = Shayne
Dannii= Leon/Matt
Cheryl= Alexandra/Joe
Edit: perhaps not.
Simon 2 - Steve (S1) and Leona (S3)
Louis 1 - Shayne (S2)
Dannii 2 - Leon (S4) and Matt (S7)
Cheryl 2 - Alexandra (S5) and Joe (S6)
In fact Sharon was so poor that in S4 she got knocked out by week 5
Series 1: Steve (Simon), G4 (Louis), Tabby (Sharon), Rowetta (Simon)
Series 2: Shayne (Louis), Andy (Sharon), Journey South (Simon), Brenda (Sharon)
Series 3: Leona (Simon), Ray (Simon), Ben (Sharon), Macdonalds (Louis)
Series 4: Leon (Dannii), Rhydian (Dannii), Same Difference (Simon), Niki (Louis)
Series 5: Alexandra (Cheryl), JLS (Louis), Eoghan (Simon), Diana (Cheryl)
Series 6: Joe (Cheryl), Olly (Simon), Stacey (Dannii), Danyl (Simon)
Series 7: Matt (Dannii), Rebecca (Cheryl), One Direction (Simon), Cher (Cheryl).
Sharon (4 series)
1st place: 0 (0% of her series)
2nd place: 1
3rd place: 2
4th place: 1
Louis (7 series)
1st place: 1 (14% of his series)
2nd place: 2
3rd place: 0
4th place: 2
Simon (7 series)
1st place: 2 (28% of his series)
2nd place: 2
3rd place: 4
4th place: 2
Dannii (4 series)
1st place: 2 (50% of her series)
2nd place: 1
3rd place: 1
4th place: 0
Cheryl (3 series)
1st place: 2 (66% of her series)
2nd place: 1
3rd place: 0
4th place: 2
Do you think If Matt had stayed in his original category he still would of won?:)
Maybe it will become 5 categories...They could add "reject novelty act" for Louis to mentor.
He was so goddam rude," shrieks Sharon. "He'd just done his song, and I opened my mouth to say: 'That was really good, Steve', when he just rolled his eyes then went: 'Whatever, yeah, c'mon, hurry up, blah, blah, blah.'
"I thought: 'You little ****. You've ******* done it now.'
"So I stood up and gave it to him, in front of the whole crew. I said: 'You cheeky ****** ******. Who do you think you are? You are 36 and it has taken all this time, and three talent contests to get here. **** you, you piece of ****. I am 52 and have earned my place in this industry. Who are you? You little *****.'"
"It's nothing to what I could have said," she says, smiling sweetly. "I could have nailed his ******* **** to the floor."
Unfortunately for Sharon, Steve went on to win the contest. Even more unfortunately, some believe he won because Sharon - unable, or unwilling, to let the matter go - turned against him later that evening, in front of the camera - and 9.9 million viewers.
She branded him a 'fake', and 'an average singer'. It was a venomous attack, and it won him a huge sympathy vote.
OK, you caught me. I didn't watch Series 1, I watched from 2 onwards, lol. :') That sounded like fun though...