Options
Survivor: Torchwood Characters Round Sixteen
Rita's Kabin
Posts: 36,478 Forum Member
✭
Thanks to everyone who voted in Round Fifteen 
We have two ties this time around. In joint top place with votes from 41.18% of you we wave goodbye to Steven Carter and Emma whilst Evan Sharman and Johnny Davies are tied in third place.
But, as always it's cumulative votes that count so it's Evan Sharman who gets the chop.
Well done to
+dgembadgemba,
+ KrisHayward,
+ Shinyteapot
and
+ Solamenn
who all managed to get two out of the three evictees.
None of the evicted characters were part of anyone's Predictions on the first leaderboard so it remains unchanged.....
Prediction Leaderboard (All Characters)
01) 8 Predictions Left
+ allison_bm
+ carefactornil
+ clever chick
+ dgembadgemba
+ Eowyn W
+ GillP
+ kazzabee
+ KrisHayward
+ kp2ni
+ lolly-licker
+ Muttley 76
+ Shineyteapot
+ solamenn
+ solgang
+ syramu
+ Tigger-Roo
+ Tumpy
+ u5e10
+ Verence
20) 7 Predictions Left
+ gogfumble
On the second leaderboard syramu and Tumpy slide down the scale after the evictions of Evan Sharman and Emma.......
Prediction Leaderboard 2 (No Recurring Characters)
01) 5 Predictions Left
+ allison_bm
+ clever chick
+ dgembadgemba
+ Eowyn W
+ Shineyteapot
06=) 4 Predictions Left
+ Muttley 76
+ solgang
+ syramu
+ Tumpy
+ u5e10
+ Verence
12=) 3 Predictions Left
+ gogfumble
+ kazzabee
+ KrisHayward
+ solamenn
+ Tigger-Roo
Here's the question for this round:
Should Alice Carter return for the next season and should Jack face feelings of guilt over Steven?
As with the last round you need to pick which of the four characters listed below you like the least then post your votes on this thread or send them to me via PM. The three with the most votes will be evicted from the game. If you'd like any that aren't evicted to roll forward into the next round all you need to do is type "auto" with your votes & any that have Survived will automatically roll forward into the next round. In the event of a tie-break cumulative votes will be taken into account.
So, it's on with the game then. Time to pick your four least favourite characters from:-
Recurring
01) Captain Jack Harkness (John Barrowman)
02) Gwen Cooper (Eve Myles)
03) Toshiko Sato (Naoko Mori)
04) Ianto Jones (Gareth David-Lloyd)
05) Rhys Williams (Kai Owen)
06) Owen Harper (Burn Gorman)
07) PC Andy Davies (Tom Price)
08) Suzie Costello (Indira Varma)
09) Bilis Manger(Murray Melvin)
10) Captain John Hart (James Marsters)
11) Martha Jones (Freema Agyeman)
Series 1
12) Small Worlds: Estelle (Eve Pearce)
13) Small Worlds: Jasmine Pierce (Lara Phillipart)
14) Out of Time: John Ellis (Mark Lewis Jones)
15) Captain Jack Harkness: Captain Jack Harkness ~ The Captain (Matt Rippy)
Series 2
16) Sleeper: Beth Hallaran (Nikki Amuka-Bird)
17) To the Last Man: Tommy Brockless (Anthony Lewis)
18) Reset: Aaron Copley (Alan Dale)
19) Adrift: Nikki Bevan (Ruth Jones)
Series 3
20) John Frobisher (Peter Capaldi)
21) Clement McDonald (Paul Copley)
22) Brian Green (Nicholas Farrell)
23) Bridget Spears (Susan Brown)
24) Alice Carter (Lucy Cohu)
25) Lois Habiba (Cush Jumbo)
26) Johnson (Liz May Brice)
27) Denise Riley (Deborah Findlay)
28) Rupesa Patanjai (Rik Makarem)
29) Rhiannon Davies (Katy Wix)
30) Johnny Davies (Rhodri Lewis)
The deadline for your votes for this round is 8pm on Saturday 28th November
We have two ties this time around. In joint top place with votes from 41.18% of you we wave goodbye to Steven Carter and Emma whilst Evan Sharman and Johnny Davies are tied in third place.
But, as always it's cumulative votes that count so it's Evan Sharman who gets the chop.
Well done to
+dgembadgemba,
+ KrisHayward,
+ Shinyteapot
and
+ Solamenn
who all managed to get two out of the three evictees.
None of the evicted characters were part of anyone's Predictions on the first leaderboard so it remains unchanged.....
Prediction Leaderboard (All Characters)
01) 8 Predictions Left
+ allison_bm
+ carefactornil
+ clever chick
+ dgembadgemba
+ Eowyn W
+ GillP
+ kazzabee
+ KrisHayward
+ kp2ni
+ lolly-licker
+ Muttley 76
+ Shineyteapot
+ solamenn
+ solgang
+ syramu
+ Tigger-Roo
+ Tumpy
+ u5e10
+ Verence
20) 7 Predictions Left
+ gogfumble
On the second leaderboard syramu and Tumpy slide down the scale after the evictions of Evan Sharman and Emma.......
Prediction Leaderboard 2 (No Recurring Characters)
01) 5 Predictions Left
+ allison_bm
+ clever chick
+ dgembadgemba
+ Eowyn W
+ Shineyteapot
06=) 4 Predictions Left
+ Muttley 76
+ solgang
+ syramu
+ Tumpy
+ u5e10
+ Verence
12=) 3 Predictions Left
+ gogfumble
+ kazzabee
+ KrisHayward
+ solamenn
+ Tigger-Roo
Here's the question for this round:
Should Alice Carter return for the next season and should Jack face feelings of guilt over Steven?
As with the last round you need to pick which of the four characters listed below you like the least then post your votes on this thread or send them to me via PM. The three with the most votes will be evicted from the game. If you'd like any that aren't evicted to roll forward into the next round all you need to do is type "auto" with your votes & any that have Survived will automatically roll forward into the next round. In the event of a tie-break cumulative votes will be taken into account.
So, it's on with the game then. Time to pick your four least favourite characters from:-
Recurring
01) Captain Jack Harkness (John Barrowman)
02) Gwen Cooper (Eve Myles)
03) Toshiko Sato (Naoko Mori)
04) Ianto Jones (Gareth David-Lloyd)
05) Rhys Williams (Kai Owen)
06) Owen Harper (Burn Gorman)
07) PC Andy Davies (Tom Price)
08) Suzie Costello (Indira Varma)
09) Bilis Manger(Murray Melvin)
10) Captain John Hart (James Marsters)
11) Martha Jones (Freema Agyeman)
Series 1
12) Small Worlds: Estelle (Eve Pearce)
13) Small Worlds: Jasmine Pierce (Lara Phillipart)
14) Out of Time: John Ellis (Mark Lewis Jones)
15) Captain Jack Harkness: Captain Jack Harkness ~ The Captain (Matt Rippy)
Series 2
16) Sleeper: Beth Hallaran (Nikki Amuka-Bird)
17) To the Last Man: Tommy Brockless (Anthony Lewis)
18) Reset: Aaron Copley (Alan Dale)
19) Adrift: Nikki Bevan (Ruth Jones)
Series 3
20) John Frobisher (Peter Capaldi)
21) Clement McDonald (Paul Copley)
22) Brian Green (Nicholas Farrell)
23) Bridget Spears (Susan Brown)
24) Alice Carter (Lucy Cohu)
25) Lois Habiba (Cush Jumbo)
26) Johnson (Liz May Brice)
27) Denise Riley (Deborah Findlay)
28) Rupesa Patanjai (Rik Makarem)
29) Rhiannon Davies (Katy Wix)
30) Johnny Davies (Rhodri Lewis)
The deadline for your votes for this round is 8pm on Saturday 28th November
0
Comments
Anyway Old votes:
Rupesa Patanjai (Rik Makarem)
Tommy Brockless (Anthony Lewis)
New votes:
Aaron Copley (Alan Dale) - I thought the character was good, but I have this problem with Alan Dale as I can't see past his unintentionally hilarious death scene in Neighbours!
Martha Jones (Freema Agyeman) - I just felt her apperence in TW was a bit underwhelming, tbh.
So Evan has gone - would have liked to see him last longer.
Good question, RK - Yes, I'd like to see an Alice/Jack face off at some point.
Votes:
Old:
Small Worlds: Estelle (Eve Pearce)
Small Worlds: Jasmine Pierce (Lara Phillipart)
New:
Reset: Aaron Copley (Alan Dale) - considering it was Alan Dale, I was hoping for more from this character.
Johnny Davies (Rhodri Lewis)
I would like Alice to return at some point but it would have to be sooner rather than later. Jack could be just about getting over what he had done and then she comes back into his life and pushes him over the edge again.
16) Sleeper: Beth Hallaran (Nikki Amuka-Bird)
17) To the Last Man: Tommy Brockless (Anthony Lewis)
18) Reset: Aaron Copley (Alan Dale)
Id love to see Alice back. perhaps trying to put an end to Torchwood by controlling an army of weevils
08) Suzie Costello (Indira Varma)
14) Out of Time: John Ellis (Mark Lewis Jones)
18) Reset: Aaron Copley (Alan Dale)
27) Denise Riley (Deborah Findlay)
14) Out of Time: John Ellis (Mark Lewis Jones)
19) Adrift: Nikki Bevan (Ruth Jones)
28) Rupesa Patanjai (Rik Makarem)
As for Alice, I think it'd have to be integrated tightly into the plot to be working.
If Jack facing his guilt was a situation too quickly solved, it wouldn't seem very believable ("You killed my son ! - Yeah, sorry, I had to. - Ok then..." ). But on the other hand, if Jack's guilt were to last (as it should because that's not the kind of guilt you overcome with six month of travelling and a trip among the stars, I think, particularly if you face the mother, your own daughter, afterwards !) it could seriously put a damper on the plot.
This time round, it's the chop for:
Small Worlds: Estelle (Eve Pearce)
Small Worlds: Jasmine Pierce (Lara Phillipart)
Out of Time: John Ellis (Mark Lewis Jones)
Rupesa Patanjai (Rik Makarem)
I'm a bit surprised John Ellis was the last man standing from Out of Time TBH but that's the way it goes I suppose!
Regards
Karen
18) Reset: Aaron Copley (Alan Dale)
21) Clement McDonald (Paul Copley)
30) Johnny Davies (Rhodri Lewis)
27) Denise Riley (Deborah Findlay)
29) Rhiannon Davies (Katy Wix)
30) Johnny Davies (Rhodri Lewis)
Personally I'm not at all surprised that he was the last one left from that episode
12) Small Worlds: Estelle (Eve Pearce)
18) Reset: Aaron Copley (Alan Dale)
28) Rupesa Patanjai (Rik Makarem)
14) Out of Time: John Ellis (Mark Lewis Jones)
As for Alice I would have her back and I always wondered about her and Johnson as there was some chemistry between them before Steven's death or is that just me!
Damn RTD and his agendas!
18) Reset: Aaron Copley (Alan Dale)
22) Brian Green (Nicholas Farrell)
28) Rupesa Patanjai (Rik Makarem)
10) Captain John Hart (James Marsters)
19) Adrift: Nikki Bevan (Ruth Jones)
15) Captain Jack Harkness: Captain Jack Harkness ~ The Captain (Matt Rippy)
01) Captain Jack Harkness (John Barrowman)
I would like to see Alice return (soon), too.
I agree, he was the best by a mile. The scene were he talks to his son, and then the scene in the car are two of the best and most poignant moments in Torchwood ever.
Have checked and those with 2 out of 3 were:-
+dgembadgemba,
+ KrisHayward,
+ Shinyteapot
and
+ Solamenn
plus
+ carefactornil
+ kazzabeee
+ Muttley76
+ Tumpy
Silly me was looking at the wrong row when it came to Stephen......
Round 15:
15) Captain Jack Harkness: Captain Jack Harkness ~ The Captain (Matt Rippy)
30) Johnny Davies (Rhodri Lewis)
New:
13) Small Worlds: Jasmine Pierce (Lara Phillipart)- well acted, but less impact than others who remain.
28) Rupesa Patanjai (Rik Makarem)- nice twist that he didn't turn out to be the obvious new TW doctor, but other than that fairly bland.
I'd quite like to see Alice back at some point, though it would have to be through co-incidence as I can't imagine she'd choose to see Jack again. Preferably after quite a long time has passed from Jack's perspective (he could travel the universe for a few hundred years then return to Cardiff 2010), so he's dealt with the guilt and is getting on with life, only to have it all brought up again.