She completely murdered that song, yet again confusing shouting for singing! Her overly dramatic snarling and face contortion was also a really big turn off. To my ears, her voice has an extremely harsh element to it which grates on me very badly. I too had to turn the volume down as the screeching was almost ear piercing at various points in her performance.
No tears this time, but we still had to endure her 'poor little me' sob story before she sang. I just can't take to her and I'm convinced she's playing everybody like a violin which some people seem to falling for. One minute she's the coy, shy little girl - the next she appears to be quite confident, cocky and assured.
Harry Connick Jr would have had some serious words with her about her delivery - and rightly so. Great voice, but I felt like she was very angry with me
She's way to loud and desperate, last week she was this fragile Shakey little girl and this week she's a completely different person /:
Desperate post. She was clearly trying to hold it together, but I guess she cant win with you.
Love the contrarions who decide someone with a huge voice is shouty, not cool to agree with most people is it? Very boring. Happened with Leah Mcfall, happens with Mariah Carey etc. Its transparent and quite sad.
Personal opinion really isn't it, I love her voice, love the power - I don't think it's shouting, if it is I must love shouting because I really enjoyed tonight's performance.
She does have an incredible voice and while this was in no way her best (I thought Chris was better tonight) im not upset Christina Marie is through.
If she would have played it more like a suave sensual version of the song it could have been the stand out performance of the night. I hope she comes back strong like we know she can do
Its a shame she didn't take longer to build the song. As it was it was like a desperate club singer trying to be heard over the conversations. Zero subtlty or sophistication. And she barked her way through the team song.
Strange
Posts: 14,955
Comments
Way over the top and the shouty delivery completely lost the story of the song.
WHAT DID YOU SAY I CAN'T HEAR YOU
There's a difference between a big vocal and shouting. Also, I'm not sure that song required a big vocal.
No tears this time, but we still had to endure her 'poor little me' sob story before she sang. I just can't take to her and I'm convinced she's playing everybody like a violin which some people seem to falling for. One minute she's the coy, shy little girl - the next she appears to be quite confident, cocky and assured.
I'm afraid she's at it again in the group song.
The Cher one does.
Unfortunately, Christina turned it into a shouty mess!
Desperate post. She was clearly trying to hold it together, but I guess she cant win with you.
Love the contrarions who decide someone with a huge voice is shouty, not cool to agree with most people is it? Very boring. Happened with Leah Mcfall, happens with Mariah Carey etc. Its transparent and quite sad.
Is she the one that sang Vision of Love by Mariah Carey earlier in the series? She did a good job of that.
If she would have played it more like a suave sensual version of the song it could have been the stand out performance of the night. I hope she comes back strong like we know she can do
I also like Jamie but he murdered that beautiful ,fragile Bonnie Raitt song, sometimes less is more.