Who Would You Have Saved?

[Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 989
Forum Member
✭✭
If you'd have been the judge with the deciding vote, who would you have saved each bottom two this series...?

Bad Lashes vs. Girlband
Girlband vs. Ruth
Scott vs. Daniel
Austin vs. Rachel
Laura vs. Ruth
Daniel vs. Rachel
Rachel vs. JLS

I would have...

Probably been a wimp and left the girl groups to deadlock because I adored both of them.
Saved Ruth over Girlband.
Saved Daniel over Scott.
And I hate, hate, hate saying it but probably either sent it to deadlock or saved Rachel over Austin because I loved both of them but thought at that moment in time Rachel had more to give - although that is largely because of Simon's song choices. No, I would have saved Austin, no Rachel... no Austin... damn, I would have sent it to deadlock!
Saved Laura over Ruth, although I adore Ruth and have wanted her to win soooo much since Laura left, Laura has been my number one from the start.
Saved Rachel over Daniel.
Saved Rachel over JLS.

Comments

  • Unigal07Unigal07 Posts: 22,326
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Bad Lashes vs. Girlband
    Girlband vs. Ruth
    Scott vs. Daniel
    Austin vs. Rachel
    Laura vs. Ruth - loved both and none should have been in bottom 2 though, but liked Laura a little more
    Daniel vs. Rachel - because he sang better in the sing off. 'One' by Rachel was dreadful.
    Rachel vs. JLS

    :)
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 3,350
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Bad Lashes vs. Girlband - Bad Lashes
    Girlband vs. Ruth - Ruth
    Scott vs. Daniel - Daniel
    Austin vs. Rachel - Austin
    Laura vs. Ruth - Laura
    Daniel vs. Rachel - Daniel
    Rachel vs. JLS - JLS
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 8,960
    Forum Member
    If you'd have been the judge with the deciding vote, who would you have saved each bottom two this series...?

    Bad Lashes vs. Girlband
    Girlband vs. Ruth
    Scott vs. Daniel
    Austin vs. Rachel
    Laura vs. Ruth
    Daniel vs. Rachel
    Rachel vs. JLS

    I would have...

    Probably been a wimp and left the girl groups to deadlock because I adored both of them.
    Saved Ruth over Girlband.
    Saved Daniel over Scott.
    And I hate, hate, hate saying it but probably either sent it to deadlock or saved Rachel over Austin because I loved both of them but thought at that moment in time Rachel had more to give - although that is largely because of Simon's song choices. No, I would have saved Austin, no Rachel... no Austin... damn, I would have sent it to deadlock!
    Saved Laura over Ruth, although I adore Ruth and have wanted her to win soooo much since Laura left, Laura has been my number one from the start.
    Saved Rachel over Daniel.
    Saved Rachel over JLS.

    Bad Lashes vs. Girlband -
    Bad Lashes were much better in my opinion,they had potential

    Girlband vs. Ruth -
    Ruth

    Scott vs. Daniel -
    Daniel

    Austin vs. Rachel -
    i couldnt bare to watch this because i liked them both

    Laura vs. Ruth -
    another horrible position,but laura was my winner

    Daniel vs. Rachel
    Rachel

    Rachel vs. JLS
    Rachel
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 18,013
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    Bad Lashes vs. Girlband - deadlock as I couldn't have cared less
    Girlband vs. Ruth
    Scott vs. Daniel
    Austin vs. Rachel
    Laura vs. Ruth
    Daniel vs. Rachel
    Rachel vs. JLS
  • MikePJBMikePJB Posts: 5,514
    Forum Member
    Bad Lashes vs. Girlband
    Girlband vs. Ruth
    Scott vs. Daniel
    Austin vs. Rachel
    Laura vs. Ruth
    Daniel vs. Rachel
    Rachel vs. JLS
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 2,114
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Bad Lashes vs. Girlband
    Girlband vs. Ruth
    Scott vs. Daniel
    Austin vs. Rachel
    Laura vs. Ruth
    Daniel vs. Rachel
    Rachel vs. JLS
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 1,143
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Bad Lashes vs. Girlband
    though both were dreadful

    Girlband vs. Ruth
    For me this week the bottom two was Girlband and any other because GB were just the worst act on by a long way. It may as well have been Ruth because I think everyone did ok except Girlband.

    Scott vs. Daniel
    Can't remember which week this was and what they actually sang but I recall Scott wasn't very good.

    Austin vs. Rachel Austin was dreadful on disco week, I think he did Wishing On A Star which isn't even disco.

    Laura vs. Ruth
    Neither of them the worst singer that week, that was Rachel doing Against All Odds.

    Daniel vs. Rachel
    Rachel on their first performance, she should not have been there this week, I actually voted for her. I liked Daniel throughout the series though.

    Rachel vs. JLS
    Rachel won the battle to sing Rule The World but lost the war.
  • shamrock_dancershamrock_dancer Posts: 2,271
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Bad Lashes vs. Girlband
    Bad Lashes
    Girlband vs. Ruth
    Ruth
    Scott vs. Daniel
    Scott
    Austin vs. Rachel
    Austin
    Laura vs. Ruth
    Laura
    Daniel vs. Rachel
    Rachel
    Rachel vs. JLS
    JLS
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 30
    Forum Member
    Bad Lashes vs. Girlband - BAD LASHES
    Girlband vs. Ruth - RUTH
    Scott vs. Daniel - SCOTT
    Austin vs. Rachel - AUSTIN
    Laura vs. Ruth - LAURA
    Daniel vs. Rachel - RACHEL
    Rachel vs. JLS - JLS
  • RodriguezMan267RodriguezMan267 Posts: 28,156
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Bad Lashes vs. Girlband - DEADLOCK
    Girlband vs. Ruth
    Scott vs. Daniel
    Austin vs. Rachel
    Laura vs. Ruth
    Daniel vs. Rachel
    Rachel vs. JLS
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 11,159
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    Bad Lashes vs. Girlband
    Girlband vs. Ruth
    Scott vs. Daniel
    Austin vs. Rachel
    Laura vs. Ruth
    Daniel vs. Rachel
    Rachel vs. JLS
  • Blue RainBlue Rain Posts: 1,390
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    I would have sent home...

    1. Bad Lashes. They were awful.

    2. Sent home Girlband. I like them, but Ruth is fantastic.

    3. Daniel. Scott had potential.

    4. Austin. His four live performances on the show were awful.

    5. Laura. Ruth completely blew her out of the water.

    6. Daniel. He was awful.

    7. Rachel. JLS had alot of potential, but Louis was letting them down.
  • SystemSystem Posts: 2,096,970
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Bad Lashes vs. Girlband
    Girlband vs. Ruth
    Scott vs. Daniel
    Austin vs. Rachel
    Laura vs. Ruth
    Daniel vs. Rachel
    Rachel vs. JLS

    The bold are those I would have saved.
  • TakeachancexTakeachancex Posts: 8,029
    Forum Member
    Who i would have saved
    Week 1: Badlashes
    Week 2: Ruth !
    Week 3: Scott.. although i didn't like him he had a good voice
    Week 4: Austin !!!!
    Week 5: Ruth.. totally outsung laura.. even though laura had a good voice too
    Week 6: Rachel
    Week 7: JLS.. but rachel did do a very good survival performance
Sign In or Register to comment.