Emmerdale Kidnapper (Theory)

CJWALKERCJWALKER Posts: 545
Forum Member
✭✭
I was thinking to myself last night

What if its
Natasha

That has kidnapped/had kidnapped Nathan!
She could use it to force a confession out of him, send it to the police and do a runner! Thereby getting off scott free
«1

Comments

  • Melephunk2010Melephunk2010 Posts: 38,383
    Forum Member
    CJWALKER wrote: »
    I was thinking to myself last night

    What if its
    Natasha

    That has kidnapped/had kidnapped Nathan!
    She could use it to force a confession out of him, send it to the police and do a runner! Thereby getting off scott free

    Considering she was ringing him/wanting to know where he was when he was tied up helpless in the barn...I think we can rule her out.

    I still think its either
    ABI

    or
    MAISIE
  • becksy1892becksy1892 Posts: 326
    Forum Member
    Was thinking last night after all the stuff
    about the barn, that maybe it is Jai and thats where he is hiding him
  • CJWALKERCJWALKER Posts: 545
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    She could be doing that for effect though!
  • Daisy19Daisy19 Posts: 3,311
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    The only person i thought it could be was
    Cain

    I didn't even consider any of these other suggestions.
  • dubgazdubgaz Posts: 2,908
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    I hope it isnt
    Cain
    It would be too obvious if it was. I want it to be a surprise
  • cherrytops(82)cherrytops(82) Posts: 3,287
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    declan could have done it or maisie
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 391
    Forum Member
    I think it could be Declan maybe him going away was just a cover up
  • linlamlinlam Posts: 9,023
    Forum Member
    My guess is also that it's
    Abi, she's strong enough, given her job, she's been stopped seeing Ryan, thanks to Nathan, and probably knows how to interrogate.
    :)
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 3,538
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    linlam wrote: »
    My guess is also that it's
    Abi, she's strong enough, given her job, she's been stopped seeing Ryan, thanks to Nathan, and probably knows how to interrogate.
    :)

    Agree, just purely for that character having been quiet the last couple of episodes. They will do something won't they?
  • sheepiefarmsheepiefarm Posts: 27,580
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Declan has no reason to.
    Maisie (unless she's had a personality transplant) isn't capable.
    Why would it be Natasha - Nathan played an absolute blinder for her in the courtroon.
    Jai? - it doesn't even make sense if it's him!

    Abi is a possibility - but why do it after he's been on the witness stand?

    Cain - has a score to settle with Nathan.

    Also
    Next week Maisie gets to interogate Nathan - that fits with Ryan asking Cain to help her - and fits with Cain helping her (without getting himself sent down).
  • KFAKFA Posts: 3,382
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    linlam wrote: »
    My guess is also that it's
    Abi, she's strong enough, given her job, she's been stopped seeing Ryan, thanks to Nathan, and probably knows how to interrogate.
    :)

    I agree, I think it is her.

    I do hope Cain will do something to help though.
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 36
    Forum Member
    i think cains involved too its the only way to help without dropping himself in it over the blackmail BUT
    Maisie is def involved...she attacks him next week while he tied up in the barn so i think it must be her and Cain working together...there's no way Maisie could of knocked him out forced him into a car, bound & gagged him and then carried him into a warehouse, plus she not emotionally strong enough either..wonder if Maisie is there with Nathan confesses it was Natasha?!?!
  • Melephunk2010Melephunk2010 Posts: 38,383
    Forum Member
    CJWALKER wrote: »
    She could be doing that for effect though!

    The effect for what?? Seems strange she would make the phonecall with no-one else around if that was her plan....


    ooooh maybe its
    Deccers.
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 36
    Forum Member
    Natasha really dosent know....she thinks he has done one of his regular Nathan disapearing acts....

    :)
  • Mike TeeveeMike Teevee Posts: 35,574
    Forum Member
    I don't think it's
    Cain as that's too obvious

    I'm liking the
    Abi or Maisie
    guesses

    can't wait for tonight's reveal (I think it's revealed tonight)
  • CJWALKERCJWALKER Posts: 545
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    phone records!
  • Aunt SallyAunt Sally Posts: 41
    Forum Member
    I think it's
    Nikkil
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 152
    Forum Member
    I reckon it has to be either
    Declan
    or
    Abi
    or maybe
    Nikhil
    .

    Maisie isn't emotionally strong enough, Cain is physically strong enough and shrewd enough too but just a tadge too obvious.

    If I was a betting man i'd have to say my favourite of my 3 contenders would be
    Abi
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 7,168
    Forum Member
    aww im hoping its cain...about time he did something!!
  • CJWALKERCJWALKER Posts: 545
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    is noone even entertaining the possibility that it could be natasha?
  • sheepiefarmsheepiefarm Posts: 27,580
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Cain is definitely obvious - but isn't it the obvious that Emmerdale are good at :rolleyes:

    Charlie was a conman
    Leyla was the mother of the kid
    Nikhill was a virgin
    Aaron has fallen for the first gay guy to cross his path

    :D
  • Ray BaroneRay Barone Posts: 232
    Forum Member
    I reckon it's sam, getting revenge for all the times Nathan put him down. Plus Sam wants to prove how much of a Dingle he is:)
  • thebill22thebill22 Posts: 1,504
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    I have a feeling its not just one of them but a group of them. Im kind of hoping that Maisie asked Cain to do it, he agreed, she told Declan who then said he would help Cain, Maisie had already consulted with Faye who agreed. Abi then came along, asked how she could help and then helped with the kidnapping. Faye then asked Jai if theres anywhere to use, hence why he brought the barn to hide him in.
  • I did It First!I did It First! Posts: 528
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    I think Cain as well. I think its been set up that way.
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 1,083
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    I think Cain . Also think it could either go 2 ways that Maisie and Cain both came up with the plan together or she doesnt know but he soon tells her .But yeah think those two are involved

    Although I think it would be interesting if it did turn out to be Abi
Sign In or Register to comment.