Options
I refuse to watch X Factor this year. Blooming Cheryl Cole
![[Deleted User]](https://w2.vanillicon.com/v2/2317b1f8e6b07ef3db07264704de77b0.svg)
[Deleted User]
Posts: 313 Forum Member
✭
I will not watch X factor this year. I hate that over rated Cheryl Cole. It will all be about me me me me. How can anyone who cannot sing get such a position to judge others.
Talentless people do not deserve all the hype.:(
Try Judging this everyone. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1UH5Sxb6Kkw
This is more like it. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D_WaHbj7Zyw
Talentless people do not deserve all the hype.:(
Try Judging this everyone. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1UH5Sxb6Kkw
This is more like it. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D_WaHbj7Zyw
0
Comments
I've already been reading from journalists who have seen the first show how she 'dominates' it and has all this camera time. I mean, why? Her personality is dull compared to Nicole and just because she's told Simon to shut up a few times, she has this AMAZING chemistry with him & must be by his side at all times? They barely speak compared to what Simon and Paula Abdul was like. Shouldn't Mel B be given a lot of the focus, seeing as she's the new judge? The camera was never off Cheryl in 2008 when she was the new girl in town.
I always look forward to X Factor starting, but from what I've heard, it's going to be all the annoying bits of 2010 (Katie Waisell-type characters, the Cheryl/Simon show and manipulation) and I'm not looking forward to that.
I know what you mean. It was always going to become the Cheryl Cole show the moment she was signed. Why Simon brought her back god knows but I am not watching it with her on there as a judge.:(
Bring Nicole back !
I don't hate nor like any particular judges but based on spoilers we got so far, this season is going to be THE BEST ONE and I hope you won't miss it due to one person and one only.
Turning down the the tv is ok but I still have to watch her smug face. No thanks
Yes, because clearly nothing happened since the TV show and Cheryl just arbitrarily became mean.
Actually I cant watch Walsh or the smugness of Cowell.
OK I might watch the show if they could do without the judges please lol
A live performance of the exact same song. Like I said, she's no Mariah, but that was a good performance. Most popstars in the industry today suffer from inconsistency; one minute they're good, the next they're awful - It all depends on the venue, song, atmosphere ect. Don't get me wrong, I agree that singers should be able to sing amazingly whatever the situation... But in reality, unfortunately, that's not what this industry is anymore.
The same can be said for all major pop stars nowadays. I hear a lot of people dissing Katy Perry's vocal ability also. Again, like Cheryl, she doesn't have a voice worthy of all the hype, as shown in these two performances: A and B.
However, by the same account, here's another live performance from Katy. She sounds fantastic.
I guess what i'm trying to say is, you can't make such claims based on one performance. Alright, I know she's had some other bad episodes too, but she's had her good times also. Besides, Cheryl's main talent is her dancing - She can genuinely dance very well.
Being a popstar isn't about vocals anymore, it's about the whole package. Where Cheryl lacks in real vocal power, she makes up for it elsewhere, as do other artists like Katy.
I don't really get the argument that because someone can't sing, they're not entitled to judge other singers. Why not? Does a criminal judge have to be a murderer to sentence a murderer? No. I think that same principle applies to talent shows. So long as the judges have the appropriate and relevant experience, they're qualified for the role. Cheryl's had heaps of experience in the industry, and has been at the top (still is... #1 single this year) of the UK music scene. Surely this alone gives her the right to judge people who are hoping to achieve exactly what she has?
Simon can't sing, nor can Louis... I guess they need to leave the panel too?
And remember: Cheryl's not in control of the edit. She doesn't know that she's going to be the most featured judge in episode one. OK, she probably has guessed she will be, based on the hype - But it's not her decision, it's the producers.
Couldn't agree more.
People have short memories when it comes to past X Factors. As much as I loved Nicole, she was one of the biggest attention seeking judges, particularly on the live shows.
When Dannii first joined, she was Simon's pet (not to mention lover) - pushing out Sharon. It backfired on her when Simon put all his attention on Cheryl the following year, Dannii didn't like it one bit.
Regarding the story about Cheryl getting all the attention this year, the show hasn't even started yet, so we're only going on what the journalists are saying. There will be some hype because she's returning, but I doubt it'll continue throughout the whole series.
I bet most of Dannii's fans would expect the attention to be on her if she ever returns, they wouldn't be on here complaining.
If Louis had been a bit more supportive of Girls Aloud, maybe Cheryl would treat him differently.
Using clips from over a decade ago? Because obviously, nothing could have happened in that time
Why do people take it so seriously? It's a Saturday night entertainment show.
It was just an observation that I found interesting, really. I guess people change when they become famous.:cool:
The X Factor will be a big damp squib with the winner used and abused by Cowell and then dumped when he's made money of them.
Mind you could you imagine if Cowell was to give an act a free pass to the final and then wins what the furore would be
Lust to good advantage. Talentless but very clever.
Judging by the extremely negative reviews of Bootcamp I can't imagine those who decide not to tune in will be missing much.
I might record the show so that I can fast forward through all the unnecessary parts of the show although I have no intention of watching the show live due to Cherly being back but that's just me.
As Louis has admitted himself, he was useless as Girls Aloud's manager and they had little to no contact with them but he was still taking his cut. There is issues on both sides, from Cheryl to Louis that they were left to fend for themselves and Louis to Cheryl because she (and the other members) exposed Louis's uselessness.
Alot happened since then though, Louis was supposed to manage them after the show but ended up abandoning them and even refusing to take their calls, so it fell on their own shoulders the first couple of years to manage the group. Also didn't stop him taking a cheque despite doing nothing for them, so its hardly surprising she isn't hugely fond of him.