DAB Radio - The Future:
Lee Morris
Posts: 2,824
Forum Member
✭✭✭
Hi! All
For myself not only living across from the Pontop Pike transmitter in County Durham but also having had the pleasure of being able to listen to DAB in the car via the Goodmans adaptor, I find DAB really good as well as clear stereo sound.
While some others are against DAB, it would be a shame for all of us who have got DAB radios to suddenly be told that we will have to purchase something else which at first as with other new items would be very expensive.
So does DAB radio have a future?.
Well my thoughts and or hopes are as follows:
1: I have the Roberts recordable DAB Radio which I think is upgradable to DAB+ as well as the Pure Flow[WiFi/Internet/FM] clock radio which is upgradable to DAB+, so I would not have too much problem if we changed to DAB+.
2: I have seen on the BBC website only today that a brand new transmitter has gone live to transmit DAB signals for London and the South East from Wrotham in Kent.
3: At the moment the BBC are spending their money on the switchover to digital television, but this will come to an end in 2012 so what are the chances that the BBC will then transfer some money on new transmitters for DAB as well as funding a switchover to digital radio?.
4: I tried to think the other day about how many people and how many areas have stations on Satellite/DAB/WiFi Radio/Freeview, maybe if there are areas which have good coverage of stations on DAB that are also on Medium Wave.
Why not end the broadcasts on Medium Wave in order to put any money saved towards funding a switchover to DAB as well as improving coverage.
5: Just think about BBC Five Live or Absolute Radio which are broadcast on Medium Wave, if they are available in all areas of the country on DAB the why don't the BBC and Absolute stop broadcasting these on Medium Wave and put the money saved towards improved coverage and the digital radio switchover.
Alright maybe I am just hoping but seeing as there is a thread which someone has stared discussing what I have seen on Radio Today regarding commercial groups broadcasting anti DAB ads, it is worrying that DAB will die a death which as I have said above is a shame.
Then again I have seen some car manufactures[is it Ford?] or someone earlier this year announce DAB as standard in their cars which is possitive.
Anyway I now look forward to your comments.
For myself not only living across from the Pontop Pike transmitter in County Durham but also having had the pleasure of being able to listen to DAB in the car via the Goodmans adaptor, I find DAB really good as well as clear stereo sound.
While some others are against DAB, it would be a shame for all of us who have got DAB radios to suddenly be told that we will have to purchase something else which at first as with other new items would be very expensive.
So does DAB radio have a future?.
Well my thoughts and or hopes are as follows:
1: I have the Roberts recordable DAB Radio which I think is upgradable to DAB+ as well as the Pure Flow[WiFi/Internet/FM] clock radio which is upgradable to DAB+, so I would not have too much problem if we changed to DAB+.
2: I have seen on the BBC website only today that a brand new transmitter has gone live to transmit DAB signals for London and the South East from Wrotham in Kent.
3: At the moment the BBC are spending their money on the switchover to digital television, but this will come to an end in 2012 so what are the chances that the BBC will then transfer some money on new transmitters for DAB as well as funding a switchover to digital radio?.
4: I tried to think the other day about how many people and how many areas have stations on Satellite/DAB/WiFi Radio/Freeview, maybe if there are areas which have good coverage of stations on DAB that are also on Medium Wave.
Why not end the broadcasts on Medium Wave in order to put any money saved towards funding a switchover to DAB as well as improving coverage.
5: Just think about BBC Five Live or Absolute Radio which are broadcast on Medium Wave, if they are available in all areas of the country on DAB the why don't the BBC and Absolute stop broadcasting these on Medium Wave and put the money saved towards improved coverage and the digital radio switchover.
Alright maybe I am just hoping but seeing as there is a thread which someone has stared discussing what I have seen on Radio Today regarding commercial groups broadcasting anti DAB ads, it is worrying that DAB will die a death which as I have said above is a shame.
Then again I have seen some car manufactures[is it Ford?] or someone earlier this year announce DAB as standard in their cars which is possitive.
Anyway I now look forward to your comments.
0
Comments
Sorry nothing personal though.......
DAB Radio - The future:
That's right, there isn't one.
DAB isn't going to be switched off anytime soon, but nor is FM. If you have purchased DAB radios you can rest easy, they will continue working for many years to come.
The rollout of the BBC national DAB multiplex to FM-equivalent coverage is part of the licence fee settlement, it's included in Jeremy Hunt's letter to the BBC outlining the deal. Whatever else gets cut back at the BBC, funding will have to be found for this.
Absolute have stated they will close MW/AM in 2015! There are still some parts of the UK especially NI, where improved DAB coverage will be needed before this happens!
Yes and can you manage to listen to Traffic radio for more than 20 mins before switching over as its repeats itself again and again and again and again........:sleep:
Except that we keep getting told that there are no plans to introduce DAB+ in this country.
It should have been done a long time ago, and it probably would have if Channel 4's DAB plans had gone ahead. At this rate it'll just be us and Norway left with original flavour DAB...
Whether it's been said or not it is a relatively easy thing to do. For my ten pence worth I would only be able to justify it for Radio Three amongst the BBC output - though it could be used at a very low bitrate to add extra sports. From my observations the BBC would need to find about 192kbps additional bandwidth to simulcast Radio Three on DAB+ to provide the quality it needs to keep everyone happy, but it would need also to keep the current 192kbps on R3, and 128kbps on 1,2 & 6 to keep existing DAB users happy too.
All this can be considered at a much later time. Meanwhile let's get the network fully rolled out and multi format DAB sets into all our new cars first.
There's only so much space you can use on each multiplex and I believe the BBC multiplex is more or less or completely full, though there will be 64 kbps free when the Asian network is closed.
There can't be much space, if any, on Digital One either.
Whilst most local and regional multiplexes are not full at the moment that may not be the case when or if proposals to merge some of them are implemented. When they did an impact assessment for the Digital Britain legislation future lack of capacity on local and regional DAB multiplexes was given as a possible risk.
At some stage Ofcom will agree to this across the UK and rapid closures will follow.
One of the reasons that a quick switchover where stations on DAB left the FM/AM platform was seen as unlikely in the industry (this is going back a few years) was because of the potential loss of listeners. If you say the switch (all FM TX's for a station are switched off) occurs at a high of 90% DAB/digital listening that's still 10% of your audience who might not switch and that's a big percentage. If you ask the sales team would they be happy with you losing that amount almost overnight, I can guarantee you a frosty reception and not thanks to the weather either.
I've yet to meet a PC/PD/MD who would be happy about deliberately losing listeners like that, although they normally are about the automatic roll over of their licence.
http://www.brandrepublic.com/go/radio/article/1043699/absolute-continues-invest-digital-absolute-radio-00s/
And don't forget that damn, unfunny, contsantly repeated voiceover that drives you away from their stations (before the small playlist does)!
Cheers,
David.
As the target is 2015 enhancing the coverage and matching FM could be before 2015, depending how you read it
If they wanted to commit to matching FM before 2015, it would have said "I also welcome the BBC's plans to enhance its national DAB coverage to match its national FM coverage as the 2015 switchover date draws near."
They didn't say this.
It couldn't be much clearer.
Cheers,
David.
Same as freeview.
I think DAB is ok for cars and portables where quality is not really necessary. For a decent system, when FM disappears then the good quality stuff can be found on internet radio.
We still need a reliable way to get the good quality stuff from the internet to our ears. My hi-fi (Linn) sounds fine with FM, CD, vinyl or even a Sky box but the only way I can get a decent sound on internet radio is to plug in a wi-fi radio; but wi-fi radios don't seem to be compatible with high quality Flash-based streams such as the BBC's. It'\s really frustrating that the best quality audio is only available on lo-fi equipment such as desktops and laptops.
You can listen to the high-quality Flash-based iPlayer BBC streams on the Logitech Squeezebox Radio or Touch, which is a big advantage. The Touch is designed for hooking up to your hi-fi system. Another big advantage is that they are platform-independent as the software they run on is open-source.
AFAIK the Squeezeboxes are the only internet radios that can play the iPlayer streams. Unless someone else knows differently?
Do you seriously think the audio sections in your Sky box are designed with more care than a decent PC sound card, or external DAC?!
Not sure you can compare DAB with Freeview. Freeview started later, and will have conquered earlier. Plus Freeview now offers HD too - a genuine quality improvement. DAB's take over is far slower, and not so inevitable.
Also, for bandwidth reasons, IP will complement Freeview rather than replace it (at least for a long time), whereas IP can replace DAB right now in the home.
Or to put it another way, at home, even if you have IP, Freeview is still useful or essential. Whereas if you have IP, DAB can be redundant.
Cheers,
David.
Have you tried listening to sports coverage on BBC local radio via IP? In many cases it isn't available, and you have go back to FM/AM or DAB.