Options
Cheryl Cole Wins X Factor Judging Battle
camy934
Posts: 1,821 Forum Member
✭✭✭
http://tellymix.co.uk/reality-tv/the-x-factor/179027-cheryl-cole-won-x-factor-2014-judging-battle-with-nicole-scherzinger.html
Does anybody believe this article? If there is an element of truth in it it makes Cheryl out to be incredibly petulant and not very professional in all honesty.
Does anybody believe this article? If there is an element of truth in it it makes Cheryl out to be incredibly petulant and not very professional in all honesty.
0
Comments
During the interview Simon and Cheryl did on Lorraine, Simon made a comment about deciding on the panel together and not putting Cheryl next to someone she "hates"
No I don't believe it and I find it pretty awful that people continue to pit women against each other and call 'catfight' to try and get attention for a story. Nicole said last year she was unsure of her return because of music so her exit was always in the pipeline so I doubt it was because of Cheryl, its most likely crap the papers and magazines are pushing to get people reading . Oh and its New magazine for god sake who really believes them
How its New Magazine?
https://www.google.co.uk/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=1&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0CC4QFjAA&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.digitalspy.co.uk%2Ftv%2Fs103%2Fthe-x-factor%2Fnews%2Fa523251%2Fnicole-scherzinger-considering-x-factor-exit-at-end-of-2013-series.html&ei=VN4sU7fpAorH7AbEyIG4Bg&usg=AFQjCNFIy7yFOhA3ElwNdaAh1ySZT3FnUg&sig2=QYJxabU0bnuLie-KGhhC_w&bvm=bv.62922401,d.bGQ
I think that's more because he wanted Cheryl to work and Fox made a decision to get rid of her
.
“Then she started singing ‘Promise This’ to me, and I swear to God the woman sang the whole song, to my face. It was just so awkward.”
It must have been very awkward hearing someone who can sing without auto tune.
Haha true
I remember when Nicole responded to that quote and I know who I believe more.
Nicole made it quite clear she sang a little bit because she heard it on the radio and wanted to make Cheryl feel good. However she also made it clear she didn't sing the full song at all because she didn't actually know it that well. Lets be honest, Promise This was hardly a global smash, was it? Why would Nicole know it? She probably knew the generic, repetitive chorus and that was it.
Plus like you say, it must of hurt Cheryl, having someone sing one of her songs in tune...
Cheryl's fans are always doing the most because she's had two good eras - which, let's be honest was entirely down to the promotion she received from X Factor. Nicole is far superior in my eyes, and had her bandmates not labelled her to be a bitch who hogged the attention she would be x10 more successful than she is now as a solo artist. People are so naive to believe such bullshit, because its the producers who are in charge of allocating solos...and the other girls' vocals were merely not strong enough to take lead. The same happened to Nadine from GA.
Yeah that is a good point about Nadine too. It's funny, the only video footage I've ever seen of any of them being bitchy, is actually Cheryl herself.
I also think that Nicole had two other things against her. She has never been able to improve the ratings and Simon with his ego is probably not a big fan of "everybody pay attention to me" Nicole.
This is such an absurd comment to make.
1. She isn't
2. Even if she was, are you that naive to believe that audiences are so passive they pay close attention to everything Nicole does?
Cheryl doesn't need to be jealous of Nicole. While Nicole fans like to go on and on about how vocally "talented" Nicole is, the bottom line is that she is a second rate version of the vocal powerhouses of our generation (e.g., Beyonce, Christina, etc. even Leona). That is in terms of vocal ability, and in terms of actual hits!! Fact is Cheryl had bigger pop hits than Nicole. Fight For This Love, Promise This, Call My Name, etc. All Nicole has is a bunch of failed attempts at breaking through (ya, I know she had some #1 success on the UK charts, but they weren't exactly huge hits that had staying power i.e., nobody really remembers those songs).
Cheryl Cole is the bigger solo popstar, she was the more popular X Factor judge, and now she's reclaiming her throne, while Nicole was rightfully shown the door so she could focus on her "music career". After all the Cheryl drama in the US, there were months and months of intense speculation and numerous articles and exposes, Simon apologies, then year after year of rumors of her return.... on the other hand, Nicole was fired over Twitter and I haven't heard anybody say they care - says it all!!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cpancx5pl2I
To Beyonce's:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rgxfthPHTwc
Nicole hit those high notes flawlessly. Not saying Beyonce isn't incredible but Nicole has been trained to do opera, she has a voice which needs to have incredible range and power. She has a far bigger range than Beyonce.
All I can see/hear is the ridiculous reaction Cheryl has had in reply to Nicole singing a song (in tune)...you'd think she killed her cat or something. Also Nicole has what Cheryl has never had - a personality, a voice and good looks. No wonder Cheryl feels so insecure...
As much as I was looking forward to Simon coming back I vowed if Cheryl ever came back I was never watching the show again, her on the judging panel is a joke given her very limited singing abilities, and I could physically stand watch her and Simon be up each others backsides.
The show is dying anyway and the ratings will still be poor. Bringing back Cowell and Tweedy Cole won't improve things in the long run.
I agree. They're flogging a dead horse and just prolonging the money spinning before admitting the inevitable defeat