Options
Should Capaldi have appeared in DOTD?
Sufyaan_Kazi
Posts: 3,862 Forum Member
✭✭✭
I'm sorry if this is being discussed in other threads, the forum is so busy I can't keep up!
<caveat>
So firstly - I loved both DOTD and TOTD and I think Capaldis' Cameos were great in both and I am not a Moffat hater, this is just a genuine question as per my title.
</caveat>
So, now that's clear, what I'm saying is: Matt's incarnation really thought his life (and all the Doctors lives) were going to end in TOTD, he had no more regenerations to use. So DID Capaldi "sneak" into 'that scene' in DOTD without Matt noticing (because of excitement) or did Matt just forget about it? It really was great to see Capaldis' hand and his eyes at the time, awesome. But on reflection of how TOTD played out, it actually doesn't make sense really does it or have I missed soemthing?
and yes, as with many of my threads, I know its just a TV show ....
<caveat>
So firstly - I loved both DOTD and TOTD and I think Capaldis' Cameos were great in both and I am not a Moffat hater, this is just a genuine question as per my title.
</caveat>
So, now that's clear, what I'm saying is: Matt's incarnation really thought his life (and all the Doctors lives) were going to end in TOTD, he had no more regenerations to use. So DID Capaldi "sneak" into 'that scene' in DOTD without Matt noticing (because of excitement) or did Matt just forget about it? It really was great to see Capaldis' hand and his eyes at the time, awesome. But on reflection of how TOTD played out, it actually doesn't make sense really does it or have I missed soemthing?
and yes, as with many of my threads, I know its just a TV show ....
0
Comments
It was epic.
But I guess story-wise, all the other Doctors were concentrating on doing their own thing at the time and only the people on Gallifrey were counting the number of TARDIS and were aware of Doctor Scary Stare.