Has Lorna had much screen time? I didn't really notice her until judges houses? probably saw her bootcamp audition but I can't remember it.
I thought the same thing but then this was the same thing that happened with Leona and look where she ended up. I mean she was not even in my equation of being in the final , Leona that is, until about week 4 when I started to take notice so you never can tell.
Never said it wasn't an opinion - most things said on here are (though people seem to think whether someone hits the right notes is opinion). And many would also agree.
Never said it wasn't an opinion - most things said on here are (though people seem to think whether someone hits the right notes is opinion). And many would also agree.
There is always one "unknown" singer who makes it through to Week 4 and then gets eliminated. I remember Sophie Abidas (sp?) was unknown and was eliminated at Week 4. And Alicia from Series 4 was also eliminated at this point.
By crumble, I mean train wreck to the extreme previous contestants like Rachel did.A voice with that many problems and limitations is almost certain to fall apart when challenged with something other than the few of songs that hide the person's vocal issues, which is why her crumbling most weeks was so easy to predict.
Sam won't. Her pitch , range, and basic voice are good enough that even if she is nervous, she'll still deliver a reasonably good performance.At worst, maybe a bit of pushing too hard (shouting) or an off note or two. Also, being older, she has maturity on her side.
I think Luke is going. He's vlearly the worst singer left, apart from perhaps the chorus boys in Kingsland who can hideto a certain extent and just fill in harmonies. Luke can't hide and I think it will show.
I'm worried about Lorna and for some reason her talent seems underestimated, probably because she's less well known. She's actually one of the best singers in the competition so I really hope she doesn't go early. That's why we all have to vote for our favourites. Remember James v Ella last year? My God that was one of the biggest shocks I've ever seen on the show out of all series.
Supersnake, I was only giving my reasons for believing she will be fine. Everything has exceptions. For what it is worth, I have experience over the years of evaluating vocalists and predicting with a degree of accuracy how people will sound with training , how ready they are to perform in high pressure situations, and how likely/when they are to have success, and not just as a hobby.
You could be right. She might crumble, and her voice might not hold up under pressure. I have seen maybe 2 instances of this from someone with her vocal ability, experience and maturity over the years, and that's why I think she will not.
Imo most likely to crumble are Tamera, Luke and Kingsland, with Rough Copy & Ms Dynamix less likely but still on.
Tamera clearly had a lot of coaching before JH, proba ly organised by producers and that will have continued. Lack of experience may trouble her though. She has forgotten her words once already.
Groups and Overs are tougher categories - so many seem to lack votes in the earlier stages of the competition.Apart from Frankie, has a Boy every been in the bottom2 in week1?
I cant see Shelley, Kingsland, Luke lasting very long. Luke could pick up the 'cute boy' for a couple of weeks. Not sure how popular the two other groups are at the moment.
Lorna should be ok for week1 - I think her vocals will be strong as she showed at bootcamp but up against the girls category and the other couple of boys, I dont know how long she can last. Her lack of coverage is going to put her at a disadvantage, the first time I remember seeing her was the performance for one of the seats at bootcamp!
I thought the same thing but then this was the same thing that happened with Leona and look where she ended up. I mean she was not even in my equation of being in the final , Leona that is, until about week 4 when I started to take notice so you never can tell.
I remember all of Leona's very well but with Lorna I thought it was the first time seeing her at judges houses. I was thinking who's she maybe they showed it. Oh she sang "I Wanna Dance With Somebody" I still don't remember watching it or she's not that rememberable.
I agree with you, I like Lorna a lot but she does seem very anonymous. She would not deserve to be out first in terms of talent, but if less talented people are working the voters when Lorna's not it might not work out well for her.
Surely though Shelly ought to be out first, out of all of them she's the one that has no business being there in terms of actual singing, and she's not an appealing character. Even Kingsland are better than her, and that's saying an awful lot :eek: Surely she must go first?!
Comments
She won't she's already been seen as unpopular being edited next to fan fav Joseph (evil woman :mad:). She's also butters.
I am thinking Luke Friend to go on Sunday if I am being honest. Possibly Shelly too but we have to wait and see who is the best and most likable.
I thought the same thing but then this was the same thing that happened with Leona and look where she ended up. I mean she was not even in my equation of being in the final , Leona that is, until about week 4 when I started to take notice so you never can tell.
A matter of opinion, and many would disagree.
Never said it wasn't an opinion - most things said on here are (though people seem to think whether someone hits the right notes is opinion). And many would also agree.
Sophie Habibis?
She'll be fine though, I can see it being someone else, probably a boy, one of the other overs or possibly one of the groups.
ETA: I remember Alesha, I liked her. The ones I like always go out though, I must jinx them
Not necessarily always true.
That would be quite delicious though. Provided someone good came second.
You could be right. She might crumble, and her voice might not hold up under pressure. I have seen maybe 2 instances of this from someone with her vocal ability, experience and maturity over the years, and that's why I think she will not.
Tamera clearly had a lot of coaching before JH, proba ly organised by producers and that will have continued. Lack of experience may trouble her though. She has forgotten her words once already.
I cant see Shelley, Kingsland, Luke lasting very long. Luke could pick up the 'cute boy' for a couple of weeks. Not sure how popular the two other groups are at the moment.
Lorna should be ok for week1 - I think her vocals will be strong as she showed at bootcamp but up against the girls category and the other couple of boys, I dont know how long she can last. Her lack of coverage is going to put her at a disadvantage, the first time I remember seeing her was the performance for one of the seats at bootcamp!
I remember all of Leona's very well but with Lorna I thought it was the first time seeing her at judges houses. I was thinking who's she maybe they showed it. Oh she sang "I Wanna Dance With Somebody" I still don't remember watching it or she's not that rememberable.
Surely though Shelly ought to be out first, out of all of them she's the one that has no business being there in terms of actual singing, and she's not an appealing character. Even Kingsland are better than her, and that's saying an awful lot :eek: Surely she must go first?!