Clutch control petrol 1.3 litre car

BleedRedBleedRed Posts: 244
Forum Member
I recently passed my driving test in a diesel car and have now bought a 1.3 litre petrol car.

Anyway, I'm really struggling with the clutch control on hills and even when still. I always seem to be stalling and it feels like I'm learning how to drive again. When I had my lessons in a diesel I didn't even have to use the accelerator to move forward as the clutch is very strong.

What I'm doing is I lift the clutch to the highest biting point and then I press a bit on the accelerator but it either revs really loudly and stalls.

What am I doing wrong?

Comments

  • MustabusterMustabuster Posts: 5,975
    Forum Member
    It's easier to stall a petrol car than a diesel. Try pressing the accelerator down a little before reaching the biting point.
  • Paul_DNAPPaul_DNAP Posts: 25,978
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    The diesel car will produce much more torque at low revs, (this is what you describe as "clutch is very strong") and as such you won't need as much gas pedal to move away. Petrol engines have lower torque at low revs, especially these modern high efficiency small capacity jobs.

    Yes, some diesel cars which would move away from standing just lifting the clutch with no gas pedal, I used to use that as a very lazy way to move in crawling traffic jams. But you'd be very lucky to find a petrol car that could do that without a stall.

    Anyway, yes, you will need to put some revs on before you lift the clutch so it survives the bite point, and then as you move through the bite point you need to feather in the revs to pull away. A little bit like a hill start in fact.
  • stackmanstackman Posts: 710
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    There's no substitute for practice. Eventually it will build up the muscle-memory you need and it will become second nature.
  • RobinOfLoxleyRobinOfLoxley Posts: 27,040
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Practice in car-parks, industrial estates after hours.

    Get biting point, add small amount of accelerator, crawl away at first.

    Hills will require more accelerator.

    Book one more driving lesson if you can't get the hang of it.
  • AndrueAndrue Posts: 23,360
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    BleedRed wrote: »
    What am I doing wrong?
    You didn't buy an automatic :D

    But yeah, most manual petrol cars will struggle to pull away even on the flat if you just let the clutch out. You need to apply a bit of extra power and definitely on a hill start.
  • BleedRedBleedRed Posts: 244
    Forum Member
    It's easier to stall a petrol car than a diesel. Try pressing the accelerator down a little before reaching the biting point.
    Paul_DNAP wrote: »
    The diesel car will produce much more torque at low revs, (this is what you describe as "clutch is very strong") and as such you won't need as much gas pedal to move away. Petrol engines have lower torque at low revs, especially these modern high efficiency small capacity jobs.

    Yes, some diesel cars which would move away from standing just lifting the clutch with no gas pedal, I used to use that as a very lazy way to move in crawling traffic jams. But you'd be very lucky to find a petrol car that could do that without a stall.

    Anyway, yes, you will need to put some revs on before you lift the clutch so it survives the bite point, and then as you move through the bite point you need to feather in the revs to pull away. A little bit like a hill start in fact.
    stackman wrote: »
    There's no substitute for practice. Eventually it will build up the muscle-memory you need and it will become second nature.
    Practice in car-parks, industrial estates after hours.

    Get biting point, add small amount of accelerator, crawl away at first.

    Hills will require more accelerator.

    Book one more driving lesson if you can't get the hang of it.
    Andrue wrote: »
    You didn't buy an automatic :D

    But yeah, most manual petrol cars will struggle to pull away even on the flat if you just let the clutch out. You need to apply a bit of extra power and definitely on a hill start.

    Thank you all for the advice. I can see where i'm going wrong and will try your suggestions like not lifting the clutch as much.

    I guess practice makes perfect, and I'm going today with some friends for a drive. i'm dreading those hill starts though :o

    Doesn't help when I have people taking the piss saying how did you pass your test :D
  • Philip WalesPhilip Wales Posts: 6,373
    Forum Member
    Congratulations on passing your test. You've just discovered that not all cars are the same in fact not all cars even of the same model are the same. Go somewhere quite and practice, as it's something that will come up time and time again as you progress in your driving.

    I know some people really struggle driving a new (to them) vehicle and they have years of driving experience. I'm fairly lucky (touch wood) that I can jump i'm most vehicles and within a few minutes are comfortable with clutch, accelerator positioning, size of the car etc.

    I may be worth asking your instructor to take you out in your own car, add in a bit of motorway driving too.
  • AndrueAndrue Posts: 23,360
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Paul_DNAP wrote: »
    Yes, some diesel cars which would move away from standing just lifting the clutch with no gas pedal, I used to use that as a very lazy way to move in crawling traffic jams.
    Waaaay back in the mists of time my first few cars had manual chokes. I used to use them to control speed in traffic jams. As long as you didn't pull them out so far as to actually enrich the mixture it was an effective way to adjust the idle speed :)

    My very first car was a knackered Mini and I never pushed the choke all the way in because the engine would stall when warm :D
  • bri160356bri160356 Posts: 5,147
    Forum Member
    Andrue wrote: »
    You didn't buy an automatic :D

    But yeah, most manual petrol cars will struggle to pull away even on the flat if you just let the clutch out. You need to apply a bit of extra power and definitely on a hill start.

    My old dad taught me to drive and every few lessons he’d make me start off in 1st gear and get the car from zero to 15mph ‘ish, without changing gear and without touching the accelerator pedal!

    I then had to repeat the exercise starting off in 2nd gear!;

    .... then repeat, starting off in 3rd gear!

    And finally, start in 4th gear and get to 15mph ‘ish, again without any help from the accelerator pedal;

    ............ if you can complete that exercise, without stalling, you’ll never have a problem with 'clutch control' again.

    My dad used to punch me in the ear if I stalled :o!...as you can imagine I very quickly became proficient at this particular task.

    P.S. you must do this exercise on a flat/level road;… if the road is slightly downhill that will be 'cheating'! :D
  • AndrueAndrue Posts: 23,360
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    bri160356 wrote: »
    My dad used to punch me in the ear if I stalled :o!...as you can imagine I very quickly became proficient at this particular task.
    And deaf in one ear?

    :D
  • bri160356bri160356 Posts: 5,147
    Forum Member
    Andrue wrote: »
    And deaf in one ear?

    :D

    …both ears, TBH; :D

    …he’d punch me in the left ear,…and the right side of my head would rattle into the drivers’ side-window.
  • foxydogfoxydog Posts: 423
    Forum Member
    Andrue wrote: »
    Waaaay back in the mists of time my first few cars had manual chok es. I used to use them to control speed in traffic jams. As long as you didn't pull them out so far as to actually enrich the mixture it was an effective way to adjust the idle speed :)

    My very first car was a knackered Mini and I never pushed the choke all the way in because the engine would stall when warm :D

    Wow, that made me smile. I remember doing the same thing.
  • IqoniqIqoniq Posts: 6,299
    Forum Member
    BleedRed wrote: »
    Thank you all for the advice. I can see where i'm going wrong and will try your suggestions like not lifting the clutch as much.

    I guess practice makes perfect, and I'm going today with some friends for a drive. i'm dreading those hill starts though :o

    Doesn't help when I have people taking the piss saying how did you pass your test :D
    I was lucky with hill starts and it just seemed natural to me. One thing I will say that's really helpful is not being afraid to use the handbrake. There's a hill not far from where I live that is quite steep and you can guarantee I'll always hit a traffic light. I have to use the handbrake otherwise the minute I tried to move I'd start rolling back.

    Handbrake on, apply accelerator (not crazy amounts) and depress clutch. When you reach biting point, you'll feel the car try to move forward and at that point simply release the handbrake while tempering your clutch and throttle.

    The first few times you do this try and practice, making sure there's nothing directly in front of you or behind you. If you over rev you will go shooting forward when you release the handbrake and/or possibly wheelspin which can cause you to slide backwards on a hill (especially if it's wet).

    Using a handbrake when stationary for more than a few seconds is good practice anyway, hill or not.
  • David (2)David (2) Posts: 20,632
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    BleedRed wrote: »
    I recently passed my driving test in a diesel car and have now bought a 1.3 litre petrol car.

    Anyway, I'm really struggling with the clutch control on hills and even when still. I always seem to be stalling and it feels like I'm learning how to drive again. When I had my lessons in a diesel I didn't even have to use the accelerator to move forward as the clutch is very strong.

    What I'm doing is I lift the clutch to the highest biting point and then I press a bit on the accelerator but it either revs really loudly and stalls.

    What am I doing wrong?

    Yep, 100% normal.

    The difference your expericing is basically down to 2 things...

    Diesels have more torque or pulling power at low speeds - they try to keep going, while a small petrol will just cut out.

    The other thing is the individual clutch on a given make/model of car. Some stall very easily. Some are more forgiving, I recently borrowed an original shape 1.3 petrol Yaris, and it was like I had to rev the engine to prevent it stalling, even worse on hills, It reminded me of the late 1980s 950cc petrol fiesta I learned to drive in. I would make a point of never buying a car like this. As an aside note, driving a car like that + repeatedly using the parking brake every time You stop and then purposely gas + clutch every time makes for slow driving. But other manual cars I have owned, such as the mk2 1.2 corsa petrol were very easy on the clutch. This is why a test drive is essential.

    Personally, I Prefer automatics now. The number of times I have to keep stopping and starting, it just makes more sense (at least to me).
  • RobinOfLoxleyRobinOfLoxley Posts: 27,040
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    There was also a software lean burn hill start issue a couple of years ago.

    I think manufacturers have now mostly fixed it.

    https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=cinquecento+hill+start+problems&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8
  • David (2)David (2) Posts: 20,632
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    There was also a software lean burn hill start issue a couple of years ago.

    I think manufacturers have now mostly fixed it.

    https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=cinquecento+hill+start+problems&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8


    That was only on certain fiat cars.
Sign In or Register to comment.