I'd be really upset if those 3 were the overs. Joseph is the only one of those that could last long imo. I'd have taken through him, Andrea and Shelly/Sam
lmao this Ryanair rumour is so ridic, from what I've read in this thread I'd be fairly confident that Melanie has made the lives. If she hasn't it's pretty ridiculous, I'm not even a massive fan of hers or anything but I can't see why they'd put her through all this just to make her fall at the final hurdle again, it would be incredibly cruel and rather pointless. I'm sure at least one of the returnees will make it through to the lives anyway, and it seems pretty certain that Jade Richards hasn't made it.
lmao this Ryanair rumour is so ridic, from what I've read in this thread I'd be fairly confident that Melanie has made the lives. If she hasn't it's pretty ridiculous, I'm not even a massive fan of hers or anything but I can't see why they'd put her through all this just to make her fall at the final hurdle again, it would be incredibly cruel and rather pointless. I'm sure at least one of the returnees will make it through to the lives anyway, and it seems pretty certain that Jade Richards hasn't made it.
Melanie is a goner i'm afraid. But know doubt she will return next year. Just hope that she does not apply for The Voice as well.
lmao this Ryanair rumour is so ridic, from what I've read in this thread I'd be fairly confident that Melanie has made the lives. If she hasn't it's pretty ridiculous, I'm not even a massive fan of hers or anything but I can't see why they'd put her through all this just to make her fall at the final hurdle again, it would be incredibly cruel and rather pointless. I'm sure at least one of the returnees will make it through to the lives anyway, and it seems pretty certain that Jade Richards hasn't made it.
Well unless both jade & melanie they have certainly done this to one of them which i think is cruel
lmao this Ryanair rumour is so ridic, from what I've read in this thread I'd be fairly confident that Melanie has made the lives. If she hasn't it's pretty ridiculous, I'm not even a massive fan of hers or anything but I can't see why they'd put her through all this just to make her fall at the final hurdle again, it would be incredibly cruel and rather pointless. I'm sure at least one of the returnees will make it through to the lives anyway, and it seems pretty certain that Jade Richards hasn't made it.
Agreed : why feature Melanie on the show at all this year if they have no intention of putting her through? "XF auditionee gets rejected for the fourth time" is a non story and non event......where's the 'entertainment' in that?
Agreed : why feature Melanie on the show at all this year if they have no intention of putting her through? "XF auditionee gets rejected for the fourth time" is a non story and non event......where's the 'entertainment' in that?
Agreed : why feature Melanie on the show at all this year if they have no intention of putting her through? "XF auditionee gets rejected for the fourth time" is a non story and non event......where's the 'entertainment' in that?
Because it makws a good story, and a few headlines, and that is what this show is about. They are not bothered about the contestants in the slightest. Its all about the £ sign.
But they've given Melanie wall to wall coverage....full footage of both her song performances so far, plus reactions from the judges. It seems utterly pointless that they would do this for a returning contestant who doesn't even get through.
This is just a tweet from some guy, so doesn't prove anything at all but does add to the speculation at the moment..
Jack Smith @JackSmithhhhhhh @MelanieMcCabe gutted that Nicole didn't pick you for live shows don't give up tho that's me not watching x factor anymore this season x
This is just a tweet from some guy, so doesn't prove anything at all but does add to the speculation at the moment..
Jack Smith @JackSmithhhhhhh @MelanieMcCabe gutted that Nicole didn't pick you for live shows don't give up tho that's me not watching x factor anymore this season x
I'd be sceptical about that one. It seems to be from some random XF fan in England and you'd wonder how he would be privy to any inside info on Melanie.
This is just a tweet from some guy, so doesn't prove anything at all but does add to the speculation at the moment..
Jack Smith @JackSmithhhhhhh @MelanieMcCabe gutted that Nicole didn't pick you for live shows don't give up tho that's me not watching x factor anymore this season x
Think he's a FM on here who probably just saw the speculation going on in this thread....
Comments
ok, everyone can have their opinion, not long till we all find out for sure, but don't all rush at once to apologise
Wishful thinking:rolleyes:
Melanie is a goner i'm afraid. But know doubt she will return next year. Just hope that she does not apply for The Voice as well.
Well unless both jade & melanie they have certainly done this to one of them
Agreed : why feature Melanie on the show at all this year if they have no intention of putting her through? "XF auditionee gets rejected for the fourth time" is a non story and non event......where's the 'entertainment' in that?
Boys:
Nicholas McDonald
Sam Callahan
Luke Friend
Girls:
Melanie McCabe
Abi Alton
Tamera Foster
Hannah Barrett
Groups:
Brick City
Rough Copy
Kingsland
Miss Dynamix
Overs:
Joseph Whelan
Sam Bailey
Andrea Magee
Zoe Devlin
Souli Roots
Anyone want to add to the list by suggesting all the other names in the Top 24?
Nobody has said Andrea is in the Top 12.
It would be downright cruel.
And this is X Factor we are talking about this would be too cruel even for X Factor.
I think its obvious from your previous posts you wish she was, but unfortunately for you just saying it doesn't make it happen.
what about shellie in the overs:D
same could be said about jade Richards and joe
Jade Richards hasn't had much coverage this series...:o
Yes they have? Someone posted last night that the Top 3 Overs were her, Joseph and Sam.
Chances are 98% of the sources are based on hearsay so we probably won't know the real Top 12 until it's screened
But they've given Melanie wall to wall coverage....full footage of both her song performances so far, plus reactions from the judges. It seems utterly pointless that they would do this for a returning contestant who doesn't even get through.
Jack Smith @JackSmithhhhhhh
@MelanieMcCabe gutted that Nicole didn't pick you for live shows
I'd be sceptical about that one. It seems to be from some random XF fan in England and you'd wonder how he would be privy to any inside info on Melanie.
Think he's a FM on here who probably just saw the speculation going on in this thread....
Probably!:D:D