Cameron & Miliband - Who Won?

Comments

• [Deleted User] Posts: 12,830

  Forum Member

  ✭✭

  26/03/15 - 23:28 #2

  Ed, but not by much. He seemed more sincere and honest than Cemeron, who appeared a bit slimy.

  0
• Soho Posts: 312

  Forum Member

  ✭

  26/03/15 - 23:29 #3

  Non! Vote UKIP Nigel should have been there.

  0
• Phil_Coulthard Posts: 2,843

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  26/03/15 - 23:30 #4

  I don't like Milliband and I was hoping for a Cameron win but I have to admit Milliband did better than Cameron

  0
• DJGAVT Posts: 197

  Forum Member

  ✭

  26/03/15 - 23:30 #5

  Cameron for me

  0
• connor the judg Posts: 8,961

  Forum Member

  ✭

  26/03/15 - 23:30 #6

  Soho wrote: »

  Non! Vote UKIP Nigel should have been there.

  No, why should he, he wouldn't win?

  0
• Rafer Posts: 14,231

  Forum Member

  ✭✭

  26/03/15 - 23:31 #7

  Neither. Cameron was the least worst. But neither won.

  0
• LostFool Posts: 90,647

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  26/03/15 - 23:32 #8

  Both of them will be thinking they could have done better.

  0
• gulliverfoyle Posts: 6,318

  Forum Member

  ✭

  26/03/15 - 23:32 #9

  scores on the doors
  Cam 6/10
  Ed 5/10

  0
• taurus_67 Posts: 6,948

  Forum Member

  ✭

  26/03/15 - 23:33 #10

  No clear winner for me.

  0
• [Deleted User] Posts: 12,830

  Forum Member

  ✭✭

  26/03/15 - 23:35 #11

  Thing is, Milliband gave the impression that he cared about people, whereas Cameron gave the impression that he couldn't care less about people.

  0
• MattN Posts: 2,534

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  26/03/15 - 23:35 #12

  Hard to judge.
  
  Both performed well in the audience session and both got a mauling of Paxman

  0
• LostFool Posts: 90,647

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  26/03/15 - 23:35 #13

  gulliverfoyle wrote: »

  scores on the doors
  Cam 6/10
  Ed 5/10

  
  Sounds about right. Neither did great but neither had a disaster and I can't see anyone changing their preconceived views.

  0
• Jason C Posts: 31,283

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  26/03/15 - 23:37 #14

  I don't think it's a case of who won, it's a case of who lost least.

  0
• Tellystar Posts: 12,253

  Forum Member

  ✭✭

  26/03/15 - 23:37 #15

  Milliband was stumped for answers, inarticulate and embarrassing to wartch him struggle with Paxman
  Cameron had a better manner, didn't waffle and was a match for Paxo

  0
• Sanguinius Posts: 1,723

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  26/03/15 - 23:37 #16

  Draw.
  
  Both grilled by Paxman on different issues, both did ok with the audience questions.

  0
• debdaw Posts: 91

  Forum Member

  ✭

  26/03/15 - 23:39 #17

  Cameron. He managed to remain calm and appeared more like a statesman. Milliband appeared flustered and unconvincing,

  0
• TelevisionUser Posts: 41,414

  Forum Member

  ✭

  26/03/15 - 23:39 #18

  Cameron & Miliband - Who Won?
  
  Paxman won of course! He asked uncomfortable and searching questions of both party leaders so he gets a 10/10 from me for doing that.
  
  Both Cameron and Miliband did pretty well on the audience questions so I'd call that a draw. In respect of the Paxman questions, Cameron seemed to wilt and get overly defensive at times so I'd say Miliband did better on that aspect not least because Miliband seemed at times to fight back and elicit spontaneous audience applause on a number of occasions.

  0
• MargMck Posts: 24,115

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  26/03/15 - 23:40 #19

  Neither for me -
  Cameron: Slippery, snake oil salesman, no idea about real life for most people. (puke smiley + >:()
  Miliband: Highly talented but neurotic, not to be trusted with top job. Likely to throw Brown-style wobblers. //:(

  0
• MattN Posts: 2,534

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  26/03/15 - 23:40 #20

  The good thing for both leaders is that it was only on Channel 4 and rather more important news has pushed it of the front pages tomorrow

  0
• MattN Posts: 2,534

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  26/03/15 - 23:41 #21

  #BattleForNumber10 poll verdict (ICM):
  CAMERON - 54%
  MILIBAND - 46%

  0
• Sanguinius Posts: 1,723

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  26/03/15 - 23:42 #22

  ICM poll interesting, thought Miliband would have been the winner.

  0
• SnowStorm86 Posts: 17,273

  Forum Member

  ✭✭

  26/03/15 - 23:43 #23

  Miliband. However I'm sure the Tory voters will pretend otherwise.

  0
• Richievilla Posts: 6,179

  Forum Member

  ✭

  26/03/15 - 23:44 #24

  Miliband was slightly less bad imo so just shaded it, though that is hardly a ringing endorsement as he should have been able to thrash a woeful Cameron. I doubt that either will have won many votes from the people that matter, the undecideds.

  0
• Landis Posts: 14,855

  Forum Member

  ✭✭

  26/03/15 - 23:44 #25

  So..............no 42 point gap then?
  
  The 42 point personal gap that yougov said is priced into the headline voting intention....
  
  But that means that................

  0
• TelevisionUser Posts: 41,414

  Forum Member

  ✭

  26/03/15 - 23:45 #26

  MattN wrote: »

  #BattleForNumber10 poll verdict (ICM):
  CAMERON - 54%
  MILIBAND - 46%

  
  ...and yet Dan Hodges, scourge of Miliband, said tonight that Miliband was the better of the two in the Paxman interview section and here's Nigel Farage's view of the situation:
  

  Nigel Farage @Nigel_Farage
  Miliband is showing more humour and courage than Cameron! #BattleForNumber10

  0