Just about to post it. Absolutely perfect television. Just incredible.
Now heading to the episode thread to see all the anti-Moffatt brigade saying how shit it was
No it wasn't shit, but a lot (not all) of Series 5 to 7 has been. That's why there is an anti Moffat brigade. If he can write as good stuff as "The Empty Child", "The Girl in the Fireplace" and tonight's episode then people obviously complain when his standards fall well below these.
No it wasn't shit, but a lot (not all) of Series 5 to 7 has been. That's why there is an anti Moffat brigade. If he can write as good stuff as "The Empty Child", "The Girl in the Fireplace" and tonight's episode then people obviously complain when his standards fall well below these.
Well that's your opinion.
I think his tenure has been nothing short of brilliant.
And many more will agree with me.
but hey, if we all thought this same the world would be a boring place.
I think his tenure has been nothing short of brilliant.
And many more will agree with me.
but hey, if we all thought this same the world would be a boring place.
Why do people try to back up their opinions with stuff like that? A personal opinion is just that. Some loved it, some hated it. All as valid as one another, no matter how many people support a certain viewpoint.
The Parting of the Ways
The Big Bang
Doomsday
Journey's End
Last of the Time Lords
The Name of the Doctor
The End of Time: Part 2
The Wedding of River Song
Why do people try to back up their opinions with stuff like that? A personal opinion is just that. Some loved it, some hated it. All as valid as one another, no matter how many people support a certain viewpoint.
I was simply pointing out that many people love Moffat's tenure, don't get your knickers in a twist now.
The Name of The Doctor 11111111/10
Doomsday 10/10
The Wedding of River Song 9/10
The Big Bang 9/10
The Parting of the Ways 8/10
Last of The Time Lords 7/10
Journey's End 6/10
This was the first one I've watched all the way through from series seven and I enjoyed it. I don't think John Hurt wiill be playing the Doctor for a tenure, it'll probably be a couple of episodes playing the future Doctor. For all that I've disliked Moffat's style, Matt Smith has been a brilliant Doctor, one of the best.
Comments
I was very impressed.
I can't remember any finales from classic Who though.
The finale was excellent anyway, but the reveal at the end is the television moment of the year so far for me.
Although some of the dodgy effects and production values were hoky it still retained a certain epic quality to it.
haha i'll second that!!!!!!!
It didn't have The Master jumping like the Hulk and throwing lightning like the Emperor.
It didn't have David staggering around taking 45 minutes to die, saying how he couldn't go because he was so damn lovely and great.
It didn't have a grow your own David to please the shippers.
So pretty damn good.:D
Just about to post it. Absolutely perfect television. Just incredible.
Now heading to the episode thread to see all the anti-Moffatt brigade saying how shit it was
AGREED!!!
Just off how am feeling at the moment (may change on next viewing but doubt it): (only NuWho)
The Parting Of The Ways
The Name Of The Doctor
The Big Bang
Journeys End
DoomsDay
Last Of The Time Lords
The Wedding Of River Song
You never seen the last episode of The Daleks Masterplan?
No it wasn't shit, but a lot (not all) of Series 5 to 7 has been. That's why there is an anti Moffat brigade. If he can write as good stuff as "The Empty Child", "The Girl in the Fireplace" and tonight's episode then people obviously complain when his standards fall well below these.
Well that's your opinion.
I think his tenure has been nothing short of brilliant.
And many more will agree with me.
but hey, if we all thought this same the world would be a boring place.
Why do people try to back up their opinions with stuff like that? A personal opinion is just that. Some loved it, some hated it. All as valid as one another, no matter how many people support a certain viewpoint.
Fair point!
This.
David staggering around saying he didn't want to go was just so embarrassing.
This was fantastic though.:D
The Parting of the Ways
The Big Bang
Doomsday
Journey's End
Last of the Time Lords
The Name of the Doctor
The End of Time: Part 2
The Wedding of River Song
The Wedding of River Song
The Big Bang
The Name of the Doctor
Journey's End
Last of the Timelords
Parting of Ways
The End of Time
Doomsday
Brilliant episode, but I prefer the overall arc of series five and series six. If we incorporated mid-series finales though..
I was simply pointing out that many people love Moffat's tenure, don't get your knickers in a twist now.
Doomsday 10/10
The Wedding of River Song 9/10
The Big Bang 9/10
The Parting of the Ways 8/10
Last of The Time Lords 7/10
Journey's End 6/10
Noooo it was incredibly emotional and sad, drew a tear in my eyes!!
Why not 11111112 you negative fool!!!! :mad: