Options
Ruthie
![[Deleted User]](https://w3.vanillicon.com/v2/3f83c005b4f0b611093f13d4a914655b.svg)
[Deleted User]
Posts: 433 Forum Member
✭
Is there really any point at all in her being on the panel??
0
[Deleted User]
Posts: 433 [Deleted User]
Posts: 433 [Deleted User]
Posts: 433 [Deleted User]
Posts: 433
Comments
:mad:
She has been since she joined the panel. To think she used to be one of my idols :eek:
Just goes to show that liking someones talent tells you nothing about what kind of person they are.
She one of the most sanctimonious idiots i've ever seen on tv. Give me Jasons crass comments any day over her self righteous ones.
And what's gonig on with the camera work tonight? Dire, especially for Michael's performance. It's like everyone is f*cked on drugs.
I think he's overmarking to compensate for the two sitting on his left !!!
But as Nicky pointed out he was only going on the advice of chief judge Robin who probably told him dont give him a six in the third week!!
Hot? Yes that a good reason to agree with her... shallow much?:rolleyes:
Yeah but wasn't Coleen one of the highest marks he gave?!
I think she had a point (I was thinking Nicky's comments were rather high), but raising the comments in the way she just came across as a bit unprofessional, especially since it detracted from the performance of the other skaters (i.e. she should have been discussing Ray's performance, not Nicky's marking). I suspect that Jason was of the same opinion as Ruthie, but this time he behaved professionally.
Personally I'd rather have Nicky with his slightly inconsistent marking than Ruthie, whom I just don't like.
That's fair enough I guess, but it's still peculiar to be so close to Coleen and for Coleen to be one of his highest marks, if not the second highest after Ray, can't remember now.
Well I agree, she does come across as a bit rude and unprofessional and she's so damn annoying that yes, I would prefer Nicky any day. I've never liked her. It's just I don't think she should be criticised for making a point no doubt a lot of us were curious about. Just perhaps not in that way.
Totally agree with this.
Nicky's marking is poor. There was a big gap in the abilities of some skaters but Nicky's marks are only 0.5 apart.:mad:
He's lost all credibility as a 'judge'.
Ruthie was right to point this out but she could have done it in a more appropriate manner.
She had a pop at Nicky for overmarking Coleen (and he explained that he had given her 4.5 because of her obvious enjoyment in her performance) - then went and overmarked Zoe - because of her performance.
The judges can award whatever marks they like for whatever reason they like - and if they disagree they should discuss it between themselves off air.
What she did last night was totally unprofessional and showed clearly why she should not be a judge in a show dealing with a subject she has absolutely NO expertise in!
Agreed after last night Ruthie made him look like a fool which last night he was.
She made herself look a fool.
Jason gives low scores because he believes that's what they deserve and tells them so, in not so polite terms. I often feel Ruthie gives low scores so that they'll go to her and she gets more airtime.
She is pointless and very annoying. And I too used to really like her before she became a judge.