Would have been pretty pointless to put TreyC through anyway...
Tinpot
Posts: 2,731 Forum Member
✭✭✭
She can belt, yeah, but can she do anything else? Emotion? Nope. Subtlety? Hell no.
The point was really hammered home when she spent 2 minutes SHOUTING Creep - a melancholy Radiohead song.
Pretty irrelevant in modern music and would have been eviction fodder by Week 5.
The point was really hammered home when she spent 2 minutes SHOUTING Creep - a melancholy Radiohead song.
Pretty irrelevant in modern music and would have been eviction fodder by Week 5.
0
Comments
I'm not a fan of Katie or Cher personally, but at least they're a bit different, a bit quirky. There's a chance of them catching fire with the right song and building a following. Especially Cher. Equally though, one or both could flop hard.
TreyC is what she is. Competent singer, would have given competent performances and eventually went out midway through.
It's a risk/reward scenario. Both Cher and Katie have higher upsides.
Treyc can always be coached to tone her vocals down a bit - Katie and Cher can't be taught not to fall apart, or to sing (because neither of them really can, particularly Cher).
Yeah, agreed.