Options
EE: Who does Emma think the killer is?
![[Deleted User]](https://w9.vanillicon.com/v2/938f292b9115fb159267917519bd1cc7.svg)
[Deleted User]
Posts: 84 Forum Member
✭
What if Emma guesses the killer is Jay because in Fatboy's video he is wearing that woolly hat. The hat belonging to the mystery boy on the bus! Jay and Ben already have to something to hide plus they had Lucy's phone and wallet. What if they knew they would be framed and they or one of them tamper with her car - they both work in the garage and would know what to do?
0
Comments
Which makes me think it's a Beale. Lest we forget she's been there from the start with the whole family. It stands to reason she'd feel - among many other things - badly let down. And for me it suddenly seems to obvious to be a Branning...
Yeah that's what I'm thinking too. Would be an interesting explanation for not going straight to the police because it would be hard to believe in one of the Beales committing cold blooded murder, it would suggest more of a tragic mistake. DTC said the killer reveal would be sad.
This is my bet, of course I predict even if Emma dies, the person she thinks it is won't be the person it actually is.
The only supposedly deleted video we've seen so far is the CCTV of Max abusing Lucy outside the car lot. Max burned the laptop containing the evidence, but it could have been stored away somehow.
There could also be CCTV of when Max pushes her over the table. The tape ends before Lucy got up again, so Emma could believe that that's the moment in which she died.
Was Denise said she was only out for 5 minutes i believe
Not to insult her but Lauren isn't exactly strong, how would she have moved the body from the flat, to the Common, without any detection?
But I think all of this is a red herring. I'm not sure that Emma has got this right at all.
IF she has got it right, though, then I'm pretty sure we've just ruled out Max, Lauren, Jane and Ian.
She didn't even take a second look at Jane or Ian as they walked past her. If she was starting to realise it was one of them, she definitely would have.
As for Max and Lauren - when they came into the house, she left to ring her suspect. "I was hoping to get hold of you." Well, that's not how you greet someone a) you're living with or b) you've just run away from.
In fact, the way she said it made it seem like someone she hasn't seen for a short while - that greeting isn't a "I saw you half an hour ago or this morning" kind of greeting.
That heavily implicates Whitney who isn't around at the moment - possibly even David Wicks -although where she'd have got his number from, I don't know.
Lastly, if the Square (and the pictures of the houses on the Square) held so many clues to her, then I think we can rule out: Ben and Dean, neither of them were on the Square at the time.
In fact, that then opens it up for everyone at the party if it is accurate - they might have stepped out for fresh air, or a cig, or anything for just five minutes - usually you don't have to report every minute detail of your night to the interview/cops, especially for something as minor as a **** break
Surely that means Abi then?
Why else would she flee the Branning house? If it's not someone under that roof then she could just take that call just outside the door or even in another room as we've seen her do on a couple of occasions when speaking to Cameron.
I think The Beale's are definitely being quite secret. I don't like how they jump whenever someone mentions Lucy. It's as if they don't want the killer to be found.