Belle Amie looked a bit Flat and Dejected tonight

[Deleted User] · 23/10/10 - 21:35

Was it me or do they think their going home tomorrow??

They look defeated and have no fight left

Terrible song choice, sung poorly and totally deflated!

[Deleted User] · 23/10/10 - 21:42

Think they did a great version of that song and genuinely all have great individual voices. But think Louis might have hit the nail on the head by claiming Simon is only interested in one act, hence why a group of his has gone every week.

Abbasolutely 40 · 23/10/10 - 21:44

I loved that song and the only one tonight that made me look up from my book .

[Deleted User] · 23/10/10 - 21:52

I felt sorry for Belle Amie with those comments, I think this was their best week.

I really thought they did well and deserved much better comments. It was a good version of the song.

BumblingBee · 23/10/10 - 22:24

They know they're gone.

And about time, I've been a bit harsh about them but whilst a couple of them cans ing quite good, as a group they're bollocks, frankly.

Haven't bonded well personally and musically and they're just so excrutiatingly dull and awkward to watch.

Feel for them with that dire song choice though.

Kapellmeister · 23/10/10 - 22:26

Atrocious. They chose a song to 'showcase' their voices?? Big mistake as two of them can't sing, and it showed.

Out tomorrow. Them or Paige Tumbleweed.

[Deleted User] · 23/10/10 - 22:26

Well, they have Simon '20% effort' Cowell as a judge. It's enough to deflate anyone.

[Deleted User] · 23/10/10 - 22:27

I thought they did good, they really need to get rid of the blonde one. The 3 alone are amazing together

dee-rec · 23/10/10 - 22:29

I thought they were quite good but think Louis was right in the money about Simon not mentoring them properly. Does anyone know what song Simon wanted them to sing?

MACTOWIN · 23/10/10 - 22:30

They are far better than the boys but I have said before they are attractive young Girls = no chance I am afraid.

[Deleted User] · 23/10/10 - 22:36

Both groups are rubbish..Poor Simon this year

[Deleted User] · 23/10/10 - 22:37

dee-rec wrote: »

I thought they were quite good but think Louis was right in the money about Simon not mentoring them properly. Does anyone know what song Simon wanted them to sing?

Footloose...

Skinny Tree · 23/10/10 - 22:40

Belle Amie stuck it to the man and won. I hope they get through just for that.

MARTYM8 · 23/10/10 - 22:51

I think after Hope Simon has lost interest in promoting girl bands. Louis was 100% spot on in his comments.

Simon prefers the boys.

Laneyh · 23/10/10 - 22:57

I can see why they wanted to show that they can all sing and I do believe they can

But I suppose they need to be convincing as a group
The edit they're getting isn't helping
Sophia seems to be spokeswoman and the only focus is crisis and negative stuff

Xtra factor haven't given them much coverage
I haven't seen any of their friends or family being spoken to
- with them being in the bottom 3 last week I would've expected that
Has anyone bothered asking them if they're single or not or even anything about them ?

I can't see them going much further in the competition unless there is a major pr drive and even then it'll be tough for them

[Deleted User] · 23/10/10 - 22:57

I never ever liked them. The show is not geared towards manufactured groups

threecheeses · 23/10/10 - 23:02

Wasn't that keen on the performance, the red head mucked up royally at the beginning.

If that is what they believe showcases them then they may as well give up now.

'Pure Shores' or a Sugababes song would have served them better if they carried it off.

[Deleted User] · 23/10/10 - 23:04

MARTYM8 wrote: »

I think after Hope Simon has lost interest in promoting girl bands. Louis was 100% spot on in his comments.

Simon prefers the boys.

I agree, i think he chose the boys from the start. He's knows they're worth the most.

[Deleted User] · 23/10/10 - 23:06

It's because they clearly hate each other! They don't work well as a group. Plus Simon obviously only cares about One Direction - they're where he sees the most money-making potential and he's focusing on that.

[Deleted User] · 23/10/10 - 23:06

What makes them a million times better then 1 direction is all they have a go at part of the song. Liam seems to be doing all the lead vocals on 1 direction songs

Hey there!

Quick Links

Belle Amie looked a bit Flat and Dejected tonight

Comments