Rachel/Sarah - As If We Never Said Goodbye (outstanding performance of the series for me)
Rachel - Cabaret Rachel (and not Niamh) - Another Suitcase In Another Hall Jessie - The Man Who Got Away Sarah - The Midnight Train To Georgia Jodie/Ashley/Rachel - Man, I Feel Like A Woman Keisha - As Long As He Needs Me Rachel - As Long As He Needs Me Jodie - Nine To Five (maybe not the best, but it was fun Jodie, and I enjoyed it)
Worst:
Niamh - Moon River Niamh - Valerie Niamh - True Colours Sarah - Ironic Sam - Hurt Jessie - Fighter Rachel - I'm With You
Several early efforts from Ashley & Fran & Keisha Niamh - As Long As He Needs Me
can't blame JB for sams lack of talent - its not his fault she can't sing in tune and show emotion!
It is when she'd been singing in tune up to then, and her bad performance on Hurt was specifically down to hideous over-emoting in response to his criticism over her supposed lack of emotion.
She can sing in tune and showed it on every song bar that one. And for me she shows emotion well enough; she doesn't overdo it (again, except that week when John had been working with her).
Ashley: As Long As He Needs Me/Black Velvet/The Winner Takes It All Rachel: Cabaret/Beautiful/As Long As He Needs Me Jodie: Send In The Clowns/I Have Nothing/Out Here On My Own Sarah: Midnight Train To Georgia/Maybe This Time Jodie, Ashley, Rachel: Man! I Feel Like A Woman Tara: Lets Hear It For The Boy (I think its because I love the song!) Rachel and Sarah: As If We Never Said Goodbye Ashley and Fran: Whistle Down The Wind
Worst:-
Sam: Hurt/Defying Gravity/Somewhere Niamh: Moon River/True Colours/As Long As He Needs Me Kiesha: Get The Party Started Jessie: Fighter/What I Did For Love (She almost killed my fave song )
I've got to add Jessie's ALAHNM to this thread - she won me over with that tonight.
Yeah me too...I'm usually cynical and black hearted but I was really moved by her performance...my OH was :eek: LOL
The other performances that stick in my mind
BEST Rachel - ALAHNM/ Cabaret Ashley -The Winner Takes It All/ ALAHNM (I also liked big spender) Jessie - The man who got away/ ALAHNM & actually - every number in the final. She blew me away tonight Jodie - send in the clowns/ Out Here On My Own
Comments
Rachel/Sarah - As If We Never Said Goodbye (outstanding performance of the series for me)
Rachel - Cabaret
Rachel (and not Niamh) - Another Suitcase In Another Hall
Jessie - The Man Who Got Away
Sarah - The Midnight Train To Georgia
Jodie/Ashley/Rachel - Man, I Feel Like A Woman
Keisha - As Long As He Needs Me
Rachel - As Long As He Needs Me
Jodie - Nine To Five
(maybe not the best, but it was fun Jodie, and I enjoyed it)
Worst:
Niamh - Moon River
Niamh - Valerie
Niamh - True Colours
Sarah - Ironic
Sam - Hurt
Jessie - Fighter
Rachel - I'm With You
Several early efforts from Ashley & Fran & Keisha
Niamh - As Long As He Needs Me
It is when she'd been singing in tune up to then, and her bad performance on Hurt was specifically down to hideous over-emoting in response to his criticism over her supposed lack of emotion.
She can sing in tune and showed it on every song bar that one. And for me she shows emotion well enough; she doesn't overdo it (again, except that week when John had been working with her).
Ashley: As Long As He Needs Me/Black Velvet/The Winner Takes It All
Rachel: Cabaret/Beautiful/As Long As He Needs Me
Jodie: Send In The Clowns/I Have Nothing/Out Here On My Own
Sarah: Midnight Train To Georgia/Maybe This Time
Jodie, Ashley, Rachel: Man! I Feel Like A Woman
Tara: Lets Hear It For The Boy (I think its because I love the song!)
Rachel and Sarah: As If We Never Said Goodbye
Ashley and Fran: Whistle Down The Wind
Worst:-
Sam: Hurt/Defying Gravity/Somewhere
Niamh: Moon River/True Colours/As Long As He Needs Me
Kiesha: Get The Party Started
Jessie: Fighter/What I Did For Love (She almost killed my fave song
Yeah me too...I'm usually cynical and black hearted but I was really moved by her performance...my OH was :eek: LOL
The other performances that stick in my mind
BEST
Rachel - ALAHNM/ Cabaret
Ashley -The Winner Takes It All/ ALAHNM (I also liked big spender)
Jessie - The man who got away/ ALAHNM & actually - every number in the final. She blew me away tonight
Jodie - send in the clowns/ Out Here On My Own
WORST
Tara - Suddenly I see