Options
Should Mel B return next year
Pattfrance
Posts: 338 Forum Member
✭
Last night was her worst performance as mentor. Paul,Andrea and Jack all appeared uncomfortable with their song choices, and Andrea does not need to look so stupid in GOLD!!!!!
With the pursuit of her own goals, she has forgotten that she is there to help them attain a future in the music world. As a judge she is supposed to give professional opinions, but she just laughed at Stevie, who did give a good performance. He also looked mystified and uncomfortable, which is usually difficult for him. This is not all.
She is rough and rude/crude with no regard to the fact that this is a family show. Last night for instance she said to Ben 'he was so hot, and she wanted to rush home to her husband just now'. Is this the level that X Factor has gone to, to try and raise the viewing figures.?
With the pursuit of her own goals, she has forgotten that she is there to help them attain a future in the music world. As a judge she is supposed to give professional opinions, but she just laughed at Stevie, who did give a good performance. He also looked mystified and uncomfortable, which is usually difficult for him. This is not all.
She is rough and rude/crude with no regard to the fact that this is a family show. Last night for instance she said to Ben 'he was so hot, and she wanted to rush home to her husband just now'. Is this the level that X Factor has gone to, to try and raise the viewing figures.?
0
Comments
She's "gobby", no finesse about her at all, She should not return
BTW Does she have a husband?
I thought she does...Stephen Belafonte????...why u ask???...
I don't think Mel is a very good judge at all, she is too bias to her own acts most of the time and she cannot take criticism of them or herself. I think that Mel and Louis could go next year and not be missed. As for Cheryl I personally think she is one of the best mentors and judges they have had as she completely proved last night with Lauren. She got Lauren over her wobble and got her to harden up for the music industry just like she has had to do in her time in Girls Aloud and as a solo artist.
Cheryl is a good example to youngsters that are trying to make it as she will show tonight with her new song going to number 1 in the I tunes charts! I think that Cheryl is also very fair with the other judges acts and is never backwards in coming forwards of giving them masses of praise if she thinks they are good like she has done with Fleur, Stevie, Only the young, Paul and Andrea!
Exactly this!
I agree with Nicole. She was a very good mentor, extremely hardworking, even helping those not of her group.
Dannii was excellent, but just not available now, but Nicole is. I think she expected to be given the chance. She bought a house in UK and I know she states she loves England etc.
Thought she would be great for this category aand the show on a whole. ....how wrong waas I???
I agree Cheryl's always been a good judge in my books too always picked the right acts and generally picks the right songs for them to sing as well. I wouldn't say she always gets things 100% perfect but at least 90% of the time she does and I think she really helps her acts too and she deserves a lot of credit for that. She's been through this process herself when she auditioned for Girls Aloud so she knows the process and how tricky it can be. So really I think she's as close to perfect for the role I think as anyone can be.
Agree, Cheryl has been the best and I would not see her replaced. Mel B appears to already have been signed for a second year and I think this is a mistake, she does need replaced. Also Louis has not really helped his groups, who have commented on wanting their own choice of songs, with a definite improvement when they did.
I'd love a panel of Simon-Tulisa-Anastasia-Nicole.
Have 3 women like they did on X Factor USA
I liked Nicole and Tulisa best..... and Danni wasn't too bad.
It is difficult to understand if as you say she made a mess of it in 2011, why they invited her back in 2012. I do not see her as an amazing celeb., not on her own. Anyway her continual acceptance as a judge/mentor should be based on accepted ability to do the job. This is the case with any job. These celebs taking on the responsibility of judge/mentor should understand that they are not enhancing their position but their team of contestants. Anyone who cannot do this, should not be there.
I think Nicole and Dannii showed these characteristics. I just hope that Mel B does not come back as she does not have the required ability to do the job well.